5 ms·
This article seems to neglect that Google earnings continue to rise year over year with continued growth forecast. [0] This article tells a flagging story but
by prepend 6y ago
This article seems to neglect that Google earnings continue to rise year over year with continued growth forecast. [0]
This article tells a flagging story but it needs an earnings ticker next to the timeline showing ad revenue growing and earnings growing.
Maybe they could make even more. Maybe they are just exploiting a captured market. But the article ignoring and not addressing this seems like the author just didn’t do their research.
[0] https://www.marketbeat.com/stocks/NASDAQ/GOOG/earnings/ https://www.marketbeat.com/stocks/NASDAQ/GOOG/earnings/
- disown 6y agoApparently GOOG is dying and that's why it gained $1 trillion market cap the last 10 years - the vast majority of it in the last 5 years. The article is so full of nonsense, it's unbelievable. > Google made almost all its money from ads. Like it always did. > It was a booming business — until it wasn’t. It's still a booming business. Look at their quarterly reports. > Here’s how things looked right before the most spectacular crash the technology industry had ever seen. What crash? > Google was a driving force in the technology industry ever since its disruptive entry in 1998. No. Google was an internet search pioneer. It didn't drive the technology industry. > Innovation costs money, and Google’s main stream of revenue had started to dry up. Has this guy ever look at financial statements? Google had $46 billion in revenue the latest quarter. It had a net profit of more than $11 billion in the latest quarter. What is this guy talking about? Edit: It's even worse than I expected. The article is a rehash of an article from April 2017. https://hackernoon.com/how-google-collapsed-b6ffa82198ee https://hackernoon.com/how-google-collapsed-b6ffa82198ee To show how incredibly wrong the predictions were, google's stock price more than doubled since the article was published and Google's market cap increased by more than $700 billion.
- marta_morena_28 6y agoThat's all well and good. However it still doesn't address three key factors: * Everyone hates ads. You can try to shove it down their throats anyway by being a monopoly, but eventually this won't work anymore, since there is too much competition that doesn't rely on ad revenue and too many companies trying to block ads. * Google doesn't have a solid revenue stream besides ads. And it's unclear how they are gonna get one. At least not in the magnitude they need to survive. * Google faces strong competition on all fronts and all of them, except perhaps Facebook, don't count ad revenue as primary source of income. This puts Google at a substantial disadvantage, amplified by the first point: EVERYONE freakin hates ads
- arcturus17 6y agoEveryone hates ads, but everyone hates paying for stuff even more. Installing an ad blocker on desktop is easy, but about 90% of the planet still wouldn’t know how to do it. Blocking ads on mobile is much harder and that’s where most of web traffic is coming from anyway. Everyone hates ads, but everyone hates paying for content even more, and they don’t have the technical means to do anything about the ads. See where this is going? Also, the claim that everyone hates ads is itself questionable. Everyone on HN hates ads, but Karen from Wisconsin or Rajit from Bangalore haven’t even so much as thought about it. They go on with their lives as they visit their favorite websites multiple times per hour, without realizing the atrocious UX and flagrant privacy violations they are being subjected to. Because the sites are free, and they provide value to them, and because they have other things to worry about.
- DoingIsLearning 6y ago> Blocking ads on mobile is much harder and that’s where most of web traffic is coming from anyway. Most of the developing world (i.e. the market share that is growing) can't afford Apple products. On Android it is absolutely trivial to block adds: - Firefox + ublock - Brave You can argue that these are unknown or have different user experiences compared to Chrome but you cannot argue that "blocking ads on mobile is much harder".
- arcturus17 6y agoI argued for both, but OK, excuse me for the lack of rigor in my wording. "About half of the US population, and a quarter of the top EU markets have it much harder to block ads on their phones". Clearly not the same scale as "the rest of the world", but also arguably the ad targets with the deepest pockets. Regardless, you may easily be able to block ads on your Android today, but you're completely subject to the whims of Google tomorrow. And the discussion is about the imminent downfall of Google. Oh the irony.
- tlarkworthy 6y agoGoog has search, Gmail, YT and Play store, GCP. All massive assets. Not all of them require ads. YT has a ad free version for subscription. The escape pods are there. I would pay $2 a month for my gmail. If pushed (I would be annoyed). But it looks like as of today digital ads is still a good business
- ghego1 6y agoThanks for pointing out all theses flaws of the article. This article is merely opinions over opinions with very few facts, without source. It does look like it wants to sound like a fact-based article, but it's not as you've correctly pointed out
- sthnblllII 6y agoBuggy whip makers grew revenue in 1899. They were still doomed.
- koonsolo 6y agoYou could have a "cash out" strategy where you burn your users, but are cashing out in the process of losing them. This would not show in statistics such as revenue, but would in terms of daily active users for example
- danielbarla 6y agoIt's just an anecdote, but last week was the point at which I switched away from the Android YouTube client for casual video watching. I don't have an issue at all with them showing ads, but it has really gotten to another level recently. The frequency, duration, and the trend towards unskippable ads has been extremely sharp, at least for me. Their implementation is also fairly bad; in spots where my wifi is not great, I frequently have the video reset to an unwatchably low quality after an ad, and buffer for 10+ seconds, even though pre-ad, everything was working just fine. Their paid offering is probably OK, but slightly overpriced IMHO (e.g. when compared with NetFlix), especially for a family - and I would be more inclined to go with it, if it wasn't for their heavy-handed advertising of that, too. With the lack of competitors, I suspect most people will stay; but there's definitely something to this.
- prepend 6y agoI have simile personal anecdotes and do feel like the author is close to some truth. But I think it may just be my wishful thinking to confirm to what I believe. Companies can coast on way past their prime and maybe Google ends up being CBS or something in 100 years (they were a big technology innovator in the early to mid 20th century). And IBM still has lots of customers even though they aren’t what they once were. I remember using Novell [0] in the mid 90s and they stayed around until 2014 making money with 1000s of employees somehow. So I guess there’s companies that stop being interested to me from a technology perspective and that’s a form “collapse” even though they’re still making gobs of cash and existing. Maybe the author really means we’ve hit “Peak Google” and it’s all downhill from here. But I think it’s important that the peak of the Roman Empire was like 117AD but it took hundreds of years to really stop (maybe the peak was really 10AD under Augustus and maybe it still exists today, but you get my drift).
- danielbarla 6y agoI agree; it's fairly unlikely that this is a huge downward turning point for them. I suspect they are keeping an eye on market trends, and basically know they are close to untouchable (although it's probably dangerous to play with that quite this severely). That said, I think one core difference to the parallels you drew is that Google is perhaps less diversified (in terms of revenue source) than those companies were, prior to their "pivots".