5 ms·
Apple, as with many other companies, does not understand that it has to release the source simultaneously with the program using it. Despite the articles claim
by Macha 16y ago
Apple, as with many other companies, does not understand that it has to release the source simultaneously with the program using it.
Despite the articles claim, Apple has not released the source in s timely manner for previous versions of iOS, instead waiting for it to be pointed out or for version N+1 or N+2 to be released first.
- skidooer 16y agoThey are only required to provide the source upon request. If they are rejecting those requests, that is another matter, but that doesn't seem to be the case here.
- bobds 16y agoThe problem is when they take 6 months to respond to such requests. What if they decide to wait a year next time? The ambiguity of "timely manner" in the license isn't helping, perhaps it's time for an improved version of the license.
- yason 16y agoDoesn't say anything of "timely manner" in the license text. It just says that besides distributing the sources with the binary it's sufficient to accompany "a written offer to give any third party the source code". Thus, they're on clear only if they give the source code to anyone who asks. Apparently they don't: giving it "soon" is not giving the source code but merely stating a promise to do so which is not allowed by the license. Ditto for not responding.
- bobds 16y agoYou are right, I can't find "timely manner" there. I was reading through various comments and it was mentioned multiple times so I didn't check. See this thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2521911 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2521911 "You may obtain a complete machine-readable copy of the source code for the LGPL-licensed portions under the terms of LGPL, without charge except for the cost of media, shipping, and handling, upon written request to Apple." My point is that if it takes a year to "process" such requests, it renders their promise to share the source kind of useless. Now we can argue about how many months would be acceptable, but I'm not sure there's much of a point in that. So a license that has some more specific rules regarding how such requests should be handled, would be an improvement.
- halostatue 16y agoNothing about the GNU family of licenses requires simultaneous -- or "timely" -- release of source for a binary. Just because it's usually done that way in the OSS operating system world doesn't mean that it must be done that way. (In fact, it's usually the other way around for OSS: the source precedes the binaries.) Nor, by the way, are they required to release it to any random user out there; they are only required to release it to people who receive the binaries (it's not clear if this must be honoured if the binaries aren't received legally, but I suspect it does).
- archangel_one 16y agoI'm not a lawyer, but I'm pretty sure it implicitly requires reasonably timely release of source for a binary. There's nothing in the license about any period of time that you're allowed to leave it before providing source, so I assume it's supposed to be fairly immediate. To put it another way, the license would be useless if they were allowed to wait 100 years before providing source. Since that's clearly not okay, why should waiting 6 months be okay either?
- edw 16y agoFairly immediately?! What the hell does that mean? We all need to spend less time talking out of our asses, playing armchair lawyers, and more time either heads-down coding or going to law school.
- makmanalp 16y ago... and maybe we all need to spend less time being aggressive asses. They made it pretty obvious that they were speculating, and were not trained in law. What, is that illegal now? Is it bad form? Is it offensive? They make a fairly good point about allowing an infinite period of time, which adds to the discussion. You, by insulting the poster needlessly and grossly missing the point of the post, have added nothing to the discussion. I usually try to refrain from doing this, since I'm also adding nothing to the discussion, but this is becoming an alarming trend.
- dedward 16y agoThis is true unless you are the copyright holder, in which case you can do whatever you want.
- cma 16y agoThey aren't "the" copyright holder.