3 ms·
It would be really useful for the 3D printing and CNC Communities if someone on the Blender team could review the NURBS update patch: https://developer.blender
by justinclift 6y ago
It would be really useful for the 3D printing and CNC Communities if someone on the Blender team could review the NURBS update patch:
https://developer.blender.org/D6807 https://developer.blender.org/D6807
It's been waiting for review for about 9 months. :(
If this gets reviewed and merged (probably with some hopefully minor fixing), it'll put the foundations in place for Blender to start competing with CAD/CAM packages.
Which would be a really good thing (as a CAD/CAM and otherwise Blender user). :)
- dagmx 6y agoIn my experience watching friends PRs, the way to get patches in faster for Blender is to build hype around it in the user base first
- nneonneo 6y agoThis patch is very short: https://dev-files.blender.org/file/data/dyx4giga47ol4633ba2p/PHID-FILE-neecnfacbzyz5o2anp2x/D6807.diff https://dev-files.blender.org/file/data/dyx4giga47ol4633ba2p... Am I looking at the right thing? Could you maybe elaborate a bit on why this will help Blender become competitive in the CAD/CAM space?
- justinclift 6y agoUh oh, I thought that was the correct one. We might need to ping the patch author "xueke pei (yuzukyo)" to make sure I have that correct... and make sure I'm pointing at the correct thing. :) https://developer.blender.org/p/yuzukyo/ https://developer.blender.org/p/yuzukyo/ --- Blender doesn't really have any presence in the CAD/CAM space because (my understanding) is the geometry Blender uses isn't "solid geometry". Because it's not solid geometry, Blender isn't able to export to any of the widely used file formats in CAD/CAM. eg STEP, IGES, 3DM, etc. Nor even to other OSS packages (eg FreeCAD), as they too use solid geometry. --- Solid models are used in industry (CNC, plasma, waterjet, etc), somewhat similar to how STL files are used in 3D printing. With 3D printing, the model file (eg STL) is turned into a gcode action plan for printing by a slicer. eg Cura (https://ultimaker.com/software/ultimaker-cura https://ultimaker.com/software/ultimaker-cura) In industry, the model file (eg STEP) is turned into a gcode action plan for the machine cut out the part by CAM software. eg MasterCAM (https://www.mastercam.com https://www.mastercam.com) --- With that branch (D6807), my understanding was it enables proper in-depth NURBS (solid geometry) support. The commit comments in that branch indicate it also allows importing of Rhino (3DM) and subdivision surface (subd) files. If that's the case, it's the needed foundation piece to allow for creation of importers and exporter for widely accepted CAD/CAM formats. The second an even basic STEP exporter is functional in Blender, it will start pulling users across from the expensive proprietary CAD/CAM systems. As almost no-one actually wants to use them, it's just a "lack of choice" problem. ;)
- ingenieros 6y agoI use both Rhino and Blender and I for one am glad that both packages exist. Part of the problem (from my POV) w/ Blender is that it tries to do a bit of everything and understandably ends up coming up short on those other things it tries to do. Sure, it's somewhat convenient to have it bundled with a video editor, but besides some really basic functionality what purpose/segment does it really serve? Before the release of 2.80 it even shipped with a built in game engine which very few people ever really used so why devote valuable engineer resources for such a small niche user base? Why not focus on improving its core features rather than try to compete w/ specialized tools such as Solidworks or Catia when their core user base is not interested in modeling planes or rockets which can actually fly?
- justinclift 6y agoPersonally, I'd rather use Blender instead of having to fork out many thousands of $ for Solidworks, or Catia (where even available). Especially when the other parts of Blender (animation, grease pencil) are already very complimentary to modelling and already support the right workflow(s). You personally might prefer to use Rhino. But the vast majority of new users who come to the CNC places I frequent (eg PrintNC Discord) would easily choose a functional Blender over any non-OSS modelling package.
- justinclift 6y agoI've looked for an email address for the patch author, but haven't been able to find one. :( That being said, I don't have an account on developer.blender.org. Is someone with an account able to contact them somehow?
- throwaway9d0291 6y agoDoes it really make sense to use Blender as a CAD/CAM package? CAD is all about building mechanical parts with features that match needed specifications. For example you need a block with holes in it with particular spacing, particular diameter and particular depth. CAD packages like Fusion 360, SolidWorks, FreeCAD etc. are all dedicated to this task and make features like constraints and measurements front and center. Blender on the other hand is, at least in my experience of it, all about bringing somebody's artistic vision into a 3D environment. It's usually not important to somebody's vision that parts meet dimensional constraints, it's more important that it looks "right". And so Blender is full of tools that allow humans to change things to arbitrary dimensions. Does it really make sense to try and fit both of these use-cases into one tool? I can't help but think that Blender would come out worse for it. And that's CAD, I really can't come up with any reason why CAM would make sense in Blender. Is there something I'm missing?
- justinclift 6y agoJust to point out, Blender already has basic NURBS capabilities. They're just so many years outdated, that they're pretty much unusable which is probably why you're not aware of them being there. ;) This patch is to update the NURBS capabilities in Blender, so the "artistic vision" objects people create can then be turned into real life objects via industry standard processes (eg CNC machining). If you personally don't want to use the NURBS pieces, then feel free to ignore them. But please don't block other people from doing so. :)
- throwaway9d0291 6y ago> If you personally don't want to use the NURBS pieces, then feel free to ignore them. But please don't block other people from doing so. :) I'm not saying NURBS shouldn't be fixed/updated, I'm just debating whether "so that Blender can be a CAD/CAM package" is a reasonable motivation for it.
- justinclift 6y agoNo worries. I suspect people thought the same about Grease Pencil, but that (for me at least) was what got me to really start using Blender. :)
- Narann 6y agoNot a valuable comment, but I remember a joke of (IIRC) Maya developer: "NURBS: Nobody Understand Rational B-Spline".