4 ms·
It doesn't feel like Newsom should get any credit for California outcome. His policies have been irrational and "reopening" plans intended to mollify alcoholics
by jeffbee 6y ago
It doesn't feel like Newsom should get any credit for California outcome. His policies have been irrational and "reopening" plans intended to mollify alcoholics and commercial landlords led directly to resurgence of the disease. The credit should fall generally on the people of California, not their government.
- asciident 6y agoPoliticians are constantly claiming credit for positive outcomes. In our state, the governor was celebrated for early success in keeping rates low due to their policies enacted (one of the best in the nation). They didn't change any of the policies or have a major change in heart about anything, yet the pandemic then got drastically worse (and now we're one of the worst in the nation). They're now trying all sorts of policy changes, none of which have any effect on the real data. What's more likely, that them staying the course led to a drastically opposing outcome all of a sudden, or that their policies have minimal effect in the first place, and it's really about human social nature in the state?
- jeffbee 6y ago> it's really about human social nature I agree completely, and this is why I think it is futile to argue about aspects of the pandemic in Sweden, because the behavior of people is much more important than the policies of their government. So unless your state is actual populated by Swedes, arguing about those policies makes no sense. This also, in my opinion, accounts for the great variety of outcomes between jurisdictions within California.
- rconti 6y agoI believe you're overstating your case. Of course he doesn't deserve all the credit (or even most of the credit?), but the reality is, "the people of California" take cues from their leadership; not just the Governor, but all leaders. Of course not everybody respects the leadership, at any level, or at all levels. And it shows, in areas that levied death threats against people for daring to suggest that they wear a mask, for example. Newsom was clearly not being completely honest when he said "we'll let the science dictate the reopenings" and then immediately turned around and said "science says we can reopen!" when folks in Orange County were threatening to execute their public officials. Obviously you can poke holes in any policy; some of them were overly broad, some were overly narrow. Some exemptions made no sense. Some tradeoffs made no sense. The goal is to get it as right as possible, not to be perfect.
- jeffbee 6y agoI guess my main beef is that the outcome in California is objectively bad. It only seems creditable graded on a curve against morons like South Dakota. By global standards California is doing very poorly with 100+ people dead every day, while people in Taiwan go about their normal lives.
- rconti 6y agoObjectively bad in that we have, what 1 million cases, and over 19,000 deaths? Absolutely! Compared to the rest of the US, where CA is 42nd in cases per 1M population with about 30,000, and 38th in death rate with 484 deaths/1M population, we don't look so bad. On the global stage, if CA was a country, in deaths we'd be 32nd (where Luxembourg is); better than Sweden, France, UK, Italy, and Spain, but worse than Portugal, Ireland, Canada... In cases (probably harder to figure due to testing rates), we'd also be in the low 30s in terms of places, but we'd be worse than some of those countries above; in particular, Sweden and Italy. I don't see how this fits your description of a state that is doing awful on the global stage. (worldometer)