5 ms·
Google, Facebook: "do not track" bill a threat to California economy
- yanw 16y agoThey are absolutely right. And last time I checked the internet was global and not micromanaged on state level.
- MatthewPhillips 16y agoThat era is slipping away. More and more the internet is becoming like everything else; controlled by people who's job security depends on having something to crow about. There are already several means of stopping tracking: clearing your cookies and cache, using private mode, not visiting the sites that record this information.
- orangecat 16y agoclearing your cookies and cache, using private mode, not visiting the sites that record this information I don't necessarily support this bill, but those methods are not nearly sufficient.
- MatthewPhillips 16y agoPlease explain.
- orangecat 16y agoIP matching, supercookies, browser fingerprints (http://panopticlick.eff.org/ http://panopticlick.eff.org/)...
- earl 16y agoSupercookies, at least inside flash, are unlikely to be used following the lawsuit against quantcast and clearspring [1]. Full disclosure: I work for quantcast. This is nothing more than my personal opinion, and should not be taken as company policy. For company policy, feel free to review the settlement [2]. [1] http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/07/zombie-cookies-lawsuit/ http://www.wired.com/threatlevel/2010/07/zombie-cookies-laws... [2] http://www.quantcast.com/inside-quantcast/2010/12/reaffirming-our-commitment-to-consumer-choice-and-control/ http://www.quantcast.com/inside-quantcast/2010/12/reaffirmin...
- nobody_nowhere 16y agoCompanies who control enough net infrastructure or have visibility into enough sites can do a reasonably good job of tracking you without using cookies. One way is to fingerprint a browser. EFF has a nice demo of this using HTTP headers. If you're operating at the packet level, you don't even need that. So in that sense it's not a matter of avoiding certain sites or managing cookies properly, because the tracking is pervasive. Current ftc discussions seem like they center around cookies, and personally identifiable information (PII), and do nothing to address other forms of tracking. That will favor large corporations and eviscerate startups in the adtech space. The key thing that legitimate players in advertising want to do is understand which ads work well and which don't. Targeting users based on which sites they visit and based on offline demographic and shopping is very trendy right now, but it's not as necessary for keeping ads ROI-positive for advertisers in my opinion. None of it really involves identifying individuals or PII, at least in the sense that people would be creeped out by. Hopefully there'll be a reasonable outcome to this which will allow this kind of legitimate use, since it finances so much of the net now.
- rbranson 16y ago^^^ This. The big Internet companies should take this as a clue and start campaigns to inform users on Internet privacy and actively push for more user friendly privacy management.
- earl 16y ago"not visiting the sites that record this information" is, in fact, perfectly sufficient I have to run, so: @falconas: of course this is a sacrifice. But if sufficient people feel similarly, over time, one would expect companies to act accordingly. @nobody_nowhere: damn, I totally forgot about cdns. But I can't imagine cdn contracts allow the cdn to use visit information from clients... or do they?
- falcolas 16y agoLet's pretend, for a minute, that you did not want Google to have your surfing habits. How many sites would you have to avoid in order to prevent them from getting any whiff of your information? I believe that "any site which uses adwords, google analytics or links youtube videos, or ..." is a good definition of insufficient.
- MatthewPhillips 16y agoEven if you're browsing in private mode on Comodo Dragon? http://www.comodo.com/home/browsers-toolbars/browser.php http://www.comodo.com/home/browsers-toolbars/browser.php
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- ams6110 16y agoJust 127.0.0.1 google-analytics.com (and others) in your /etc/hosts
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- yanw 16y agoGoogle offer opt-outs for their stuff. Bu that's not the point, the point is that if people are really that concerned about internet privacy they could install privacy software the same as with parental control software so their is no need to pile more restrictive innovation stifling laws.
- neutronicus 16y agoI'm of two minds about this. I want my browsing habits to be a closed book to everyone, period, and I doubt I have the necessary technical savvy to achieve that goal. I'd therefore love to dump the responsibility on the government, and damn the consequences to the California economy. I am afraid, though, that letting the government get a regulatory foot in the internet's door will send me out of the frying pan and into the fire, privacy-wise.
- earl 16y agoNever forget the US government's horrid track record at civil liberties, and always remember the corporations have better lobbyists than you.
- falcolas 16y agoI've always found it sadly ironic that the people who elected our representatives have less say in how our representatives act than corporations with lobbyists.
- earl 16y agoThen support public funds plus a ban on all private funds for elections. For example, look at the recent senate campaign in CA, Boxer vs Fiorina. Boxer spent $28MM and Fiorina $22MM [1]. The math is you must raise $2.8e7 / (52 * 6) = $89,743 PER WEEK for your entire term to finance your next campaign. There's simply no way that comes without strings. [1] http://flapsblog.com/2010/12/03/ca-sen-barbara-boxer-outspends-carly-fiorina-in-senate-race/ http://flapsblog.com/2010/12/03/ca-sen-barbara-boxer-outspen...
- yummyfajitas 16y agoYou'll probably also need to support a new constitutional amendment: Amendment 28 - Congress may now pass a law abridging the freedom of speech, the freedom of the press, and the right of the people to peaceably assemble and petition the government for redress of grievances. But they should only do this to prevent rich people that I don't agree with from expressing their opinions on elections.
- kovar 16y agoI found the most interesting part of this article the following quote: "... and would make them more vulnerable to security threats." Allowing users to opt out of tracking increases their security threat? I'd like to see more detail on this.
- Goronmon 16y agoSites such as a banking site, track user location to help determine whether it's actually you logging in, or some account phisher overseas. Allowing users to opt-out of such tracking would make those sites less secure.
- DrJ 16y agoor it might make it more secure by opt-in to being tracked where you are accessing it from.
- eddieplan9 16y agoExactly. I find glorifying user-tracking like that really disgusting.
- Goronmon 16y agoCan you try rewording this? As I'm having zero luck trying to figure out what you meant to say. :(
- dkl 16y ago"... and would make them more vulnerable to security threats." This claim has nothing behind it. Is it just FUD? If not, what's the argument?
- MatthewPhillips 16y agoFraud identification becomes much harder. Gmail, for example, logs which IPs you log in from and warns (locks out?) if the timing of log in locations is suspicious.
- yanw 16y agoWhy pile new laws? if people are really that concerned about internet privacy they could install privacy software, the same as with parental control software. There is no market failure to justify new regulations and advertising is what pays for the internet, new laws will just increase the barrier to entry and stifle innovation as everyone will need their lawyers present before launching anything. Also this do-not-track concept doesn't make much sense, with phone marketing people didn't get anything in return here they get free content.
- killerswan 16y agoUnless the bill prohibits loyalty cards at VONS, too, this is just old business astro-turfing against internet businesses.
- mirkules 16y agoLoyalty cards at VONS are opt-in. Which means you, the consumer, have to sign up for the card, and then choose to use it when you make a purchase. This law is targeted against the equivalent of walking into a store, someone putting a tag on you, and tracking what you do now, and forever after you leave the store, _without your knowledge_.
- atacrawl 16y agoSecond, the letter points out that the four leading Web browsers—Internet Explorer, Firefox, Safari, and Google Chrome—already offer various means of preventing advertising companies from tracking users. Perhaps I'm wrong, and please correct me if I am, but I don't think this is true -- is it? I thought that features like Private Browsing (Safari) and Incognito (Chrome) only prevented the browser from recording page and search history (or using form autofills) on your local machine. This is the first I've heard that it affects user tracking by advertisers in any way, shape or form. EDIT: And the more I think of it, the stupider this "solution" becomes -- basically, they're asking users to forego recording their own browsing history to avoid being tracked! Well, where do I sign up?
- keltex 16y agoThey also don't store regular cookies. But that doesn't prevent other techniques such as evercookie to track the user.
- tantalor 16y agoI think the article was referring to "do-not-track" features such as "Keep My Opt-Outs", https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/hhnjdplhmcnkiecampfdgfjilccfpfoe https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/hhnjdplhmcnkiecamp...