4 ms·
I wonder how hard it'd be to serve this data via DNS, like "dig -t TXT 0xdeadbeef.ocsp.apple.com". Then you get a nice, distributed architecture with lots of bu
by kstrauser 6y ago
I wonder how hard it'd be to serve this data via DNS, like "dig -t TXT 0xdeadbeef.ocsp.apple.com". Then you get a nice, distributed architecture with lots of built-in cache handling, and since the data is currently served via HTTP, it wouldn't expose any more data to your ISP than already is today. It would also mean that if you have 100 people in the office and a local DNS cache, then each OCSP query would be made exactly once and then its answer shared among everyone else in the office.
- saagarjha 6y agoThat still tells people what you’re running, though.
- kstrauser 6y agoImagine you have a shared office DNS resolver (which is pretty common). That resolver would aggregate all of the requests into one shared, cached stream. Then the question becomes "hey Apple, one person of how ever many thousand are behind me would like to know if Adobe's certificate is still valid". That's reasonably anonymized, I think.
- nickodell 6y agoThen the question is, "how much do I trust my ISP/DNS provider?" Those DNS lookups tell your ISP 1) that you use a mac and 2) that you have an application from a specific developer installed. I think I trust my ISP less than I trust Apple, here. Am I wrong to do so?
- kstrauser 6y agoWell, back to the state right now where your ISP can see your plaintext HTTP packets if they want to, so it wouldn't be any worse than the current situation. I guess you could get much the same effect by configuring your company Macs to point at a shared Squid server to cache the GET requests from the OCSP server, but in practice almost no one does that.
- nickodell 6y agoApple says they're going to move to an HTTPS based system, so the relevant comparison is between HTTPS and DNS, not HTTP and DNS.
- saagarjha 6y agoThat only helps if you have a shared resolver.
- kstrauser 6y agoPretty much everyone has a shared resolver at some point. Almost no one’s running a local resolver on their laptop these days.