11 ms·
I'm not sure if fraudulent is the word but there seems a trend to apply physics like models (you apply energy x to an object and the temperature increases by y
by tim333 6y ago
I'm not sure if fraudulent is the word but there seems a trend to apply physics like models (you apply energy x to an object and the temperature increases by y say) to human behaviour (increase interest rates by x and spending increases by y). But human behaviour isn't like that - people do what seems a good idea the time which is a way more complex thing.
- eru 6y agoEconomists are aware of these problems. And many other problems we can come up with while philosophizing from our arm chairs. The economic modeling principle of 'rational expectations' is one attempt to deal with exactly the thing you pointed out. Basically it says that you have to assume that in aggregate people in your model economy are at least as smart as your model. But rational expecations' got a bad rep amongst non-economists.
- tim333 6y ago>In economics, "rational expectations" are model-consistent expectations, in that agents inside the model are assumed to "know the model" and on average take the model's predictions as valid. Still seems to be overdoing the rational bit when something like 1/3 of americans believe in ghosts, UFOs and so on.
- eru 6y agoWikipedia explains it thus: > Rational expectations theories were developed in response to perceived flaws in theories based on adaptive expectations. Under adaptive expectations, expectations of the future value of an economic variable are based on past values. For example, people would be assumed to predict inflation by looking at inflation last year and in previous years. Under adaptive expectations, if the economy suffers from constantly rising inflation rates (perhaps due to government policies), people would be assumed to always underestimate inflation. Many economists have regarded this as unrealistic, believing that rational individuals would sooner or later realize the trend and take it into account in forming their expectations. Even people believing in ghosts might be able to acquire the necessary cynicism.