3 ms·
> Case to the point: online signature check was a technical decision, to fight malware. This is an oversimplification. It also helps protect Apple's business m
by sneak 6y ago
> Case to the point: online signature check was a technical decision, to fight malware.
This is an oversimplification. It also helps protect Apple's business model: you must pay Apple a fee for services (and show ID) to be able to sign your apps for distribution on this platform. Imagine if you had to show ID to get a TLS certificate for your website.
Don't conflate the issue - this is also a move to protect certain streams of Apple services revenue, in addition to protecting users from malware, and it always has been.
- valuearb 6y agoWithout facts, your thoughts are merely conspiracy theories. There is no difference between them and claims the US presidential election was stolen.
- sneak 6y agoI've not posted any theories, only widely-accepted and recognized facts.
- valuearb 6y ago“ this is also a move to protect certain streams of Apple services revenue” Citation needed please, Mr. Giuliani.
- crazygringo 6y ago> this is also a move to protect certain streams of Apple services revenue That's a theory, not a fact, nor is it widely recognized. By any reasonable accounting of costs, the $99 Apple Developer Program fee isn't meant to be a profit center that Apple is trying to "protect". It mainly helps prevent spam accounts and helps offset the cost of reviewing and distributing free apps in the Mac and iOS app stores.
- shadowfiend 6y agoI see you asserting this over and over. What I don't see is you providing any real evidence that this is a core part of the decision-making process. Apple isn't particularly incentivized to find a different way that avoids the tools they already have that already make it harder and costlier for parties to get around their security mechanisms. That is not the same as making decisions because they protect the business model. Which is to say, it appears that you're the one oversimplifying and conflating (btw, I do not think that word means what you think it means) some very different motivations.
- sneak 6y agoApple charges 10x the market rate for credit card processing on the purchase of mobile apps on iOS. Why do you think this is possible? Take it from dhh if you don't believe me: https://mobile.twitter.com/dhh/status/1328339591389175808 https://mobile.twitter.com/dhh/status/1328339591389175808
- shadowfiend 6y agoSorry, you seem to have deviated into an unrelated axe you're grinding. Try again, this time with the axe you were originally grinding, which I'll help with: > [Online signature check] is also a move to protect certain streams of Apple services revenue, in addition to protecting users from malware, and it always has been. To restate and avoid drifting into another non sequitur, this ascribes intent; that is, it suggests that part of the reason online signature check was added, and part of how it has been evolved, is to protect certain streams of Apple services revenue. That would be your argument, which has no evidence to support it, but you suggest is backed by “facts”[1], which appear to be nowhere to be found. Are these facts somewhere to be found? Or are you stating hypotheses as facts? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25210475 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25210475
- sneak 6y agoI have no axe to grind with Apple. I'm a happy Apple customer and have been for most of 30 years. The same code that keeps malware from running on a mac (or iphone) keeps non-app-store apps from running on an iphone, or prompts you to move non-notarized apps to the trash on a mac. It's not some separate thing: the exact same code path that protects the consumer store revenue and developer notarization service revenue also protects users against malware. EDIT, for clarity: I am speaking of Apple-developed, Apple-owned platform security code, where root keys are not held by anyone other than Apple, not generic crypto primitives or the concept of code signing in general (where we have a P-as-in-public PKI).
- Spivak 6y ago