4 ms·
The mainstream doesn't care because it's at all-time highs. The value of a bitcoin is driven entirely by speculation. There's no news driving prices. The only n
by jfengel 6y ago
The mainstream doesn't care because it's at all-time highs. The value of a bitcoin is driven entirely by speculation. There's no news driving prices. The only news is ever about the price itself.
Every purchase is also a sale. Every vigorous post about how much you should be buying bitcoins is also a statement that somebody wants to sell theirs off. It's no surprise that mainstream investors have no interest in that.
Not that investors are above cheering on stock market bubbles and other speculations. But they at least know that there's some value there setting a floor for what a stock is really worth. A bitcoin has no way for me to evaluate its real worth, and all I hear in "bitcoin at alltime high" is "bitcoin getting ready to crash again".
- inquirerofsorts 6y agoThe best thing about HN is that comments like these can never be deleted. I collect them like Pokemon. It's been nearly a decade now and there's certainly many to look back on. From experience people either double down or feign ignorance years later, which path will this one take?
- jfengel 6y agoYou should absolutely come back in a few years and discuss it with me. I'm entirely prepared to be wrong. I can see an end-state in which Bitcoins reach a tipping point that they would become a default for transactions. That would give them a basis for value, the total value of all the world's transactions divided by the total base if Bitcoins (yadda yadda velocity of money and other hand-wavey stuff; I'm not doing the math here since that's not the point). I consider that unlikely for a number of reasons. Some are technical (the weight of Bitcoin is so high that most people end up using an online provider, which is no easier than just using any other spending app) and some economic/political (if blockchain really works for currency, a government could easily set one up by fiat without rewarding speculators in any existing cryptocurrency). While that end-state could happen, a stablecoin gets there faster. People could buy and use a stablecoin today, without making every transaction a speculation. Of all the cryptocurrencies, Bitcoin attracts the most attention, and is most driven by speculation rather than any kind of store of value. While Bitcoin's notoriety could be the reason it becomes the one that stands out, I believe that it's more likely to be a different one (most likely a stablecoin, probably backed by a government). So there, I explained my reasoning. It could be wrong, and if so, it will hopefully be clear where. There will be no reason for me to either feign ignorance or double down: I'd be more interested in learning the lesson of what I missed than defending my ego. It costs nothing to my ego to be wrong, only in failing to learn.
- midas 6y agoHow do you explain that gold is worth so much more than bitcoin and is barely ever used in transactions?
- analreceiver 6y agoI would like to read some of your personal favorites.
- trixie_ 6y agoBitcoin's value based on how much people use using it to store value. You can't store billions of dollars without the price of Bitcoin being high. More and more people are using it to store and transfer value. Why? Because as a currency it's good. There's nothing like it and I challenge you to give me an alternative. Here's the requirements you need to meet - * Unable to be manipulated - this rules out most fiat currencies. The recent pandemic shows governments have no self control and will print trillions on a whim. * Fast to transfer - I can send thousands of dollars worth of bitcoin around the world in under 30 minutes. It takes days for ACH transfers. It takes hours for a wire transfer if you're lucky. * Cheap to transfer - Compared to wire transfers, transferring bitcoin is cheap. * I can hold it - I can't store large sums of cash or gold in my pocket (or even my house) safely. Large sums of bitcoin I can securely hold in my phone with my private keys backed up elsewhere. * Open source - This entire system is out in the open for inspection. No company controls it or can mess with it. * Battle tested - The fact that people have been trying to break Bitcoin for 10 years now and it still works gives people more confidence to use it as a store of value. It doesn't matter if it has no value to you. But it has a lot of value to myself and others. If you have an better way let's hear it.
- jfengel 6y agoThe same logic applies to dozens of other cryptocurrencies, and new ones are offered every day. Any one cryptocurrency has a fixed base, but the set of currencies together expands every single day, brrrrrrrr. To justify Bitcoin specifically you'd need to explain why it in particular should be the one-and-only (or at least, one of a fixed and finite set). A government could do it by fiat, and it wouldn't surprise me to see a government bless some cryptocurrency as its default transaction mechanism. A stablecoin could do it by piggybacking off a government fiat. It's not impossible that the population as a whole could simply land on Bitcoin, much the way a government exists by the collective consensus of the people living there. But I don't see that as being very likely, since there are too many alternatives. It has the first-mover advantage and might just succeed, but I consider other cryptocurrencies more likely.
- trixie_ 6y ago
- monokh 6y agoBitcoin doesn't appreciate on news. It's not a company and it doesn't necessarily have a product that is being constantly worked on. There is the odd software upgrade every few years but the core function never changes. The value to which people are bidding is primarily 2 things. 1. Tolerance to threats, social or technological. This reduces with time. 2. Its increase in demand (yes, a lot of speculation) relative to the constant reduction of supply. I.e. scarcity.
- shrimpx 6y agoI will take pure speculation over a stock ticker influenced by a CEO tweeting random shit.
- jfengel 6y agoThat's why you should ignore CEOs tweeting random shit, and buy a stock that you can just leave in a drawer for years on end. Ultimately that stock has a value, a share of the company's profits and assets. If you find a stock that you can purchase at a reasonable price for your expectation of those profits and assets, it doesn't matter what that CEO says. If value investing doesn't appeal, you can absolutely play speculation games against all of the other people playing speculation games. Value investing is dull and plodding, and to be honest, the usual advice about index funds feels hollow on a day when the S&P 500's P/E is pushing 40. But I, personally, would rather leave my money in a bank account than play speculation games in any asset. I just don't have the stomach for it. If you do, I wish you the best of luck.