3 ms·
This assumes economics has something approaching the truth to the level that it can foresee something about the future. If this were true, it would be used to
by mensetmanusman 6y ago
This assumes economics has something approaching the truth to the level that it can foresee something about the future.
If this were true, it would be used to predict stock prices, ergo, economics is a field that can likely only learn about long term historical trends and potential long term future trends, and can tell us mostly nothing about short term effects of policy in the 1-2 year future.
- MagnumOpus 6y agoEconomics has a hard time predicting economic markets due to the Lucas critique -- if people know the predicted environment, they will change their behaviour (redirect investments/savings/etc) based on it and the prediction becomes inaccurate. Economics has a nearly impossible time predicting stock prices - the Lucas critique applies hundredfold here, if market participants learn of more accurate economic predictions, they would immediately incorporate in their models and stock prices would have already adapted. (Not to speak of the randomness that a market with a billion participants exhibit, much of which is not really random but unexplainable by a a broad-strokes economic model...)
- tenkabuto 6y agoThanks for describing the Lucas critique in this way. I went to look into it more and the wikipedia page[1] doesn't spell this out nearly as clearly as you put it, so thank you for the added context. [1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique