3 ms·
After the fall of communism in Bulgaria, land was to be given back to people(during the communism everything was owned by the government). Don't know the detail
by mrtksn 6y ago
After the fall of communism in Bulgaria, land was to be given back to people(during the communism everything was owned by the government). Don't know the details but now we have small amount of farmlands and forests.
Turns out, most urban people don't fancy to work the land by themselves and those in the villages really suck at the organisation.
So my grandma is living in a town, she opted out to keep her land in a cooperative and simply receive some cash at the end of the year each year. Not much money but it's free money from her standpoint.
My relatives that live in a village opted out to own and work the lands by themselves like most of the other villagers.
The result? Villagers fail to organize the crop production, if one year potatoes turn to be very profitable, next year everyone do potatoes and prices tank, someone does tobacco and makes the bank.
Cattle production also died out because they failed to integrate into a steady supply chain of a buyer. Companies would be collecting milk and some villagers don't hesitate to add water and the companies stop coming. One year everyone is in milk the other year no more milk, everything becomes meat since some construction business gives more money in short term so they need to get rid of the livestock. Tough luck, the milk buying chocolate factory.
At the ends, most young people opted out to work in a EU country that pays very well during the season and stay jobless for the rest of the year. Those who managed to get good education completely moved out to the cities or even other countries so no one left to actually work their own farmlands with few exceptions of people who do speciality crops and work like beekeeping. Most of the farmland got sold to large companies and those who couldn't get good education become employees of the farms they once owned.
What I am trying to say is, it's probably the way it is because the alternative is not viable. These things need large scale companies, be it private or governmental.
- truckerbill 6y agoI'm not sure that's the only conclusion that can be drawn. What you're describing is simply a lack of education on the matter - there could have been a program to help these people out rather than just assume a monopoly will do a better job in the long run.
- mrtksn 6y agoIf we had self alternating magnets we could have built motor that run without using energy. The reality is not ideal for our desires though, so we don't have free energy motors. Anyway, I don't know what courses will fix the disorganisation problems and make the farmers turn into MBAs while still accept to live in a village and do hard work but if there's an success story of this, I would support it. From my point of view, these things need to be done in huge scale. To achieve scale, owned by single company or governmental body or cooperative is all good by me. Probably proper regulations and governmental programs could be a solution too.
- andi999 6y agoYes. I think you cannot teach people these things fast, it takes decades (and is then actually a culture).
- ainiriand 6y agoExactly, sometimes we underestimate the power of a streamlined process.
- dejv 6y agoThere is a niche for small scale farms, but those had to be run like a business. And let me tell you it is tough business to run with high capital costs and low margins. Huge companies have many advantages in certain production areas, but there are many others like intensive vegetable production, wine grapes, poultry, rabbits (just to name some animal production) and some speciality crops that favor small producers. Farms just need to invest in building their own supply chain.