4 ms·
For those of us who just don't where MacOS is concerned, what are the prospects for Linux on an M1?
by anigbrowl 6y ago
For those of us who just don't where MacOS is concerned, what are the prospects for Linux on an M1?
- harpratap 6y agoMaybe better to wait for good ARM chips on a PC. Now that there is a demand for it, I'm sure some ARM vendor will step up if not Qualcomm
- postalrat 6y agoThere is some demand but even more demand for non-arm processors on PC.
- zamadatix 6y agoQualcomm has been at the Windows laptop market for a while and has yet to come out with anything nearly as performant. I'd like to see it but they've been behind for many years in the mobile space compared to Apple as well.
- harpratap 6y agoIt's the same what Apple did with wireless bluetooth audio. There were already companies making them but they didn't try their best. When Apple made Airpods, it defined them as a new category and every company started pushing their own take on it. Now we plenty of good options to choose from. ARM was typically making very conservative reference designs keeping PPA in mind but now that they have customers asking for a higher TDP chips on the PC side. And they are already making bigger chips like Apple's with cortex X1 - https://www.anandtech.com/show/15813/arm-cortex-a78-cortex-x1-cpu-ip-diverging https://www.anandtech.com/show/15813/arm-cortex-a78-cortex-x...
- zamadatix 6y agoApple isn't just now entering into this space with the M1 though, it's been this bad for 5 years vs Qualcomm already the change is now even the best power hungry x86 cores can't keep up with it. What Apple is delivering in the M1 continues to be 2 generations ahead of the Qualcomm's best in terms of performance an the +10% uplift on the usual +20% generational increase isn't changing that - Apple has been doing that level of improvement consistently every generation so Qualcomm can't "catch up" by doing the same in some generations. I'm generally not a fan of Apple as a company and own no Apple products but I've long acknowledged what they've been doing in mobile hardware has been miles better than what the competition has been doing - this isn't some sudden upset and entrance just a on-pace continuation of what has been going on for years. I only wish it was decoupled from their software.
- harpratap 6y agoI am not really a knowledgeable person when it comes to CPUs, I just follow what Anandtech posts. And reading his comments on X1 it looks like ARM (and thus Qualcomm) are just being too conservative because there was really no business need for a non-Apple company to make such a large chip. But now there is, so it won't be impossible for them to catch up. Huawei's Kirin 9000 is already scoring close to A14 in multi core benchmarks and this is based on a year old A77 cortex design.
- zamadatix 6y agoQualcomm's best phone chip (the 865) has 56% the single thread performance of the A14 as found in the iPhone 12. I'm just not following how suddenly with the M1 all Qualcomm needs to do is make a chip of the same size and it will be just as performant. The disparity in performance isn't new with the M1, Qualcomm ARM CPUs have been slower than Apple ARM CPUs for nearly a decade now. What was amazing about the M1 is that it beats even the best power hungry x86 chips in many single thread tasks as well, not that it suddenly jumped ahead Qualcomm (Apple was already ahead of Qualcomm). Also the business case isn't new, Qualcomm has been trying to display x86 laptop chips for years and has fallen short on performance every attempt. The M1 does not present a new challenge or new opportunity in this space, just better execution.
- harpratap 6y agoFirstly, single core scores aren't the be all end all of a CPU. Secondly, Kirin 9000 gets 3700 multi core vs 4000 A14, so quite close to that of Apple with a year old A77 cortex. ARM tried making their chips larger with X1 and it resulted in 30% improvement in the first iteration itself, so it's not crazy to think there are so many unrealized gains to be made by ARM and others. Second mover advantage is a thing. And lastly Qualcomm isn't the flag bearer of ARM chips. Nuvia, Ampere, HiSilicon and even old Mediatek & Samsung could take their crown.
- kllrnohj 6y agoProbably not very good, but the recent Ryzen offerings are still pretty strong, as is the very newest Intel stuff. See for example the 4900HS & 4800U on this Anandtech chart comparing spec2017 vs. the M1: https://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph16252/119365.png https://images.anandtech.com/graphs/graph16252/119365.png That's basically just sorted by power consumption. 4900HS is the most power used & fastest, followed by the ~22W M1 with all 8 cores loaded, then the 15W 4800U, and then the M1 with just the 4 bigs was last.
- ben-schaaf 6y agoAnd the thing to remember here is that the 4900HS and 4800U aren't just a process node behind, they're 2 full generations behind. Given the gains from Zen 3 it looks like AMD is in a good position to leapfrog the M1 with the next product cycle, not to mention gains from 5nm in the cycle after that.
- kelchm 6y agoYou say that as if Apple hasn’t been delivering yearly performance improvements in their SoCs like clockwork. They’ve roughly tripled the performance in the last five years between the A9 and A14. AMD has done a great job with Zen 3 in particular, but IMO they are going to really struggle to compete with what Apple is able to do with ARM.
- sliken 6y agoDunno, the zen 3 cores are pretty competitive with the M1. Sure they use more power, so you'll need to make do with somewhat larger batteries and somewhat smaller runtimes. The performance/core is pretty similar, even if the M1 has the edge. I'd rather have a zen 5000 APU (due at CES in Jan), 32GB ram, and a 12 hour battery life and be able to run linux than a M1, 16GB ram, and 20 hour life and only be able to run OSX. Similar the Intel NUC like AMD products are hitting, I expect them to be pretty attractive with the zen 3 APUs. Sure I'd buy an M1, just not sure I want to switch to OSX, even the cut/paste inconsistencies drive me batty.
- 6y ago
- heavyset_go 6y agoPretty slim, ARM SoCs require a lot of work on the vendor's part to support Linux[1], and Apple has said that they won't support running other operating systems outside of virtualization. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25180129 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25180129
- _ph_ 6y agoThere is a good chance to run it inside a VM, already shown at WWDC, so it only depends on Parallels/VMWare releasing their updates for the M1. On the bare machine, it is somewhat unsure. Currently it is not possible, but it is not clear how difficult it would be. In any case, the question would be about driver development, as this is a completely custom computer. But as the Mini isn't expensive and this is a really interesting chip, I could imagine, that a lot of Linux hackers are trying to get it running. Even Linus Torwalds expressed interest in the M1 MB Air.