4 ms·
> Who cares? With everything capped at 1 or 1.2TB of transfer per month, there's no point to having internet any faster. My ISP doesn't cap at 1-1.2 TB (Centur
by loeg 6y ago
> Who cares? With everything capped at 1 or 1.2TB of transfer per month, there's no point to having internet any faster.
My ISP doesn't cap at 1-1.2 TB (CenturyLink, Seattle metro area, "gigabit" service plan). Comcast is often a monopoly, but it isn't the only ISP in the US. Your point is certainly valid for Comcast customers, and in other areas where all ISPs cap at some relatively small amount of 'maxBW x hours'.
- ihattendorf 6y agoI can choose from Cox and CenturyLink in my area, both have a 1TB cap here.
- loeg 6y agoThanks. Edited my original comment to clarify that the cap/no-cap status of CenturyLink may be local to my metro, or related to my particular internet plan.
- sedatk 6y agoSonic and Google WebPass don't cap either. It might be a Comcast-only thing.
- keanebean86 6y agoCox and SuddenLink have caps too. At least for some of their plans. In some cases you can pay extra for unlimited.
- filoleg 6y agoYep, we got WebPass, WaveG, CenturyLink, and Comcast/Xfinity in Seattle area, and only Comcast/Xfinity has any sort of caps. I personally tested both WaveG and Webpass, and neither of them have any caps, just like advertised (been watching Netflix and downloading/uploading tons of stuff, on the order of over 1TB a day, no slowdowns/hidden caps either)
- rayiner 6y agoVerizon doesn’t cap, and Comcast doesn’t on most of the east coast.
- ghaff 6y agoThat's apparently changing in January. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/11/comcasts-data-cap-finally-goes-nationwide-in-expansion-to-12-more-states/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2020/11/comca...
- BostonEnginerd 6y agoCaps on Comcast are coming in January.
- outworlder 6y ago> Your point is certainly valid for Comcast customers For $30, you can add unlimited data to your plan. That's not a terrible deal, if you need it. I'm more bothered by the crappy upload speeds. Fixing that would require switching to a business plan.
- jasonjayr 6y agoBut to reiterate what has been stated every where else over and over: for most regions in the US, there are at most 1 provider with usable speeds available, and they get to do whatever they want with their customers. There are many regions with hardly any competition, and the lucky few areas with 2 or more usually comprise of another high speed provider that changes in lock step with the local #1, and a bunch of smaller providers on DSL or some other old technology. Wireless is even more capped, high latency, and, thanks to the FCC, can be more privacy invasive or restricted than land line internet. It's not all roses in the US.
- loeg 6y agoAbsolutely. Hence: > Comcast is often a monopoly I live in Seattle and we had a Comcast monopoly for something like 15 years until 2017 or 2018. I do not mean to suggest that real competition exists in most places or that anything about the situation in general is rosy.
- Retric 6y agoI really wonder how Starlink is going to shake things up. It’s currently expensive, but a continuously improving service could represent a huge risk to otherwise stagnant ISP’s.
- est31 6y agoStarlink has a constant density they can't vary, so likely they'll have lots of unused capacity in the rural areas while having lots of used capacity in the urban areas. Thus, they'll likely want to increase the price in urban areas to reduce the number of customers while keeping it cheap in rural areas. Otherwise they have to come up with some other system that keeps customer usage low. Maybe they'll offer "mobile internet" at a price point somewhere between rural and urban pricing that you can e.g. use in your car. Maybe folks will then hack their parked car and use it as a home uplink, while driving around to keep the "mobile" pricing level. As for the price in the urban area where density is too big for them to serve everyone, likely it'll be modelled after the price the incumbent ISP has, and be a bit cheaper, but not too cheap as they can't serve everyone in that area. TLDR: nothing much will change. So in urban areas they likely won't cause any change, but in lightly populated places there will be a big revolution, and people there will be very happy :). At least if Starlink choses to make internet cheap. Maybe they don't want to, and instead want to orient themselves after the local ISP, being significantly cheaper so that almost everyone switches to them, but not being as cheap as they can be. Entirely possible, brings them more money, but is obviously not very nice for customers :). We'll see a real revolution when we have multiple competing companies in space that try to outbid each other in a fight for market share.