4 ms·
I _really_ like the idea but stopped short once I saw the IAP subscriptions. I get why subscriptions are good for developers. But I can't subscribe to everythi
by rcarmo 6y ago
I _really_ like the idea but stopped short once I saw the IAP subscriptions.
I get why subscriptions are good for developers. But I can't subscribe to everything, and would prefer a single-shot purchase (even if I were to end up upgrading the year after, I would have the option not to).
Other than that, the app seems to be _exactly_ what I need when compared to, say, Agenda (which I already own and use). So, in a nutshell, I'd likely switch if the pricing were different solely for the plain text storage.
- CharlesW 6y agoSince the developer is here I'd like them to know that, because of subscription fatigue, this is a dealbreaker for me too. (This isn't a critique of the creator or their choice, of course — I want them to be successful!)
- EduardMe 6y agoI thought about it, but one-time payments always have this problem that you need to come up with upgrades to keep the bills paid. And upgrades are in many aspects bad for users and for creators. For upgrades you need to 'save up' features and you need to come up with flashy ones, because bug fixes and improvements are not an incentive to upgrade for many...
- 8fingerlouie 6y agoOthers have face the same problem and solved it by "feature unlocks", i.e. Working Copy (https://workingcopyapp.com/ https://workingcopyapp.com/), which sells 1 year "pro" unlocks, and all features released during that year remains active even if you don't renew your pro unlock. It's not a subscription, as the software will continue to work just fine when the pro unlock expires, but you don't get new features. This of course puts pressure on the developer to keep coming up with new features, but then again that's the developers job.
- davidcollantes 6y agoI would be willing to pay the $60, for the app, no subscription. If the app works well, it is mostly bug free, and it runs on the current OS, there is no need to come up with any flashy features. As long as it is kept up to date to continue to run. If a new version comes each year, I shall buy it as well. I have done that with VMWare Workstation, and Arqbackup, to mention a couple.
- sreitshamer 6y agoPanic has a really nice approach with their Nova app. They keep updating it all the time; you pay once and get free updates for a year. You can choose at checkout time to stay updated for 50% of new-purchase price each year, or you can choose to pay for a new year of updates later on, when/if you need/want it. https://library.panic.com/nova/purchase-faq/ https://library.panic.com/nova/purchase-faq/
- EduardMe 6y agoDo they sell it through the AppStore? Probably not.
- skinnymuch 6y agoI think Agenda App and Working Copy do sell through the App Store with the 1 year of features. They don’t do the discount of course like Panic with Nova is doing which indeed isn’t possible in the App Store.
- skinnymuch 6y agoDoesn’t work with any current App Store unfortunately.
- 8fingerlouie 6y agoJoining the choir. If it's subscription based i'm out. Edit: To clarify, if it was a single purchase i'd buy it in a heartbeat. It looks exactly like what i need and would actually use, but subscriptions on everything is putting me off. If it's not a media platform (news, netflix, etc), i'm not subscribing to anything, and even those platforms are getting too diversified. Subscriptions on software grants me (personally) exactly zero advantages over a single purchase that fullfils a purpose, and no amount of "spin" from developers will convince me otherwise.
- EduardMe 6y agoI tried one-time payments with NotePlan 2, it's not a business model that enables you to grow nor plan anything in advance. That's neither good for the developer, nor the user. Except you don't want any updates, no bug fixes, no improvements, no new features.
- slightwinder 6y agoIF you can't grow with one-time payments, then you will definitly will fail with subscriptions. Subscription are a high risk for users, so they most will avoid it, which is already shown here. This will mean that while the income may be more stable, the overall sum is lower, because there are less users, less advertisment, less community. > Except you don't want any updates, no bug fixes, no improvements, no new features. As A user I care for stability first, everything else comes after. But with subscriptions I don't know anything about what will be next year, or the year after. Updates are a promise, but no guarante. More likely with a stable income the developer has no stress to push out updates and get's lazy at the point. At which point the user is trapped in with a software which he needs to pay for, without getting any aditional benefit for it. It would be different if the app offers a service which justifies subscriptions, like a cloud-service which creates cost. But it seems this app is classical desktop app. No benefit after first install, no change either. Updates might be worthful, or more likely they will be not. Usage alone justifies no fee. Updates are a separate part which should call for separate fees. Everything else is just harmful. Jetbrains, the IDE-developer got this right with their subscription-system (after vocal compains). You pay for the software once and can pay regular again to receive updates. Without the fee, you will stay on the version that you got with the last payment. Additionally payments shrink over time, so good customers get some additional benefit for staying with the company. This is a fair solution, because the user has the safe solution that their software will not become unusable some day, while they still get a real benefit for paying the fee.
- ibdf 6y agosame here... I get why subscriptions are a popular business model, but I can only sign up for so many services.
- FerretFred 6y agoAs soon as I saw the word subscription I regretfully lost interest.
- wakkaflokka 6y agoI feel the same way. To be clear: I understand why subscriptions work well for developers. As a consumer, I'm finding I have an enormous amount of subscriptions and it becomes harder and harder to justify an additional $1/month, $5/month, etc. for an app. Maybe that means I'll be more selective in what I buy, which doesn't hurt. But it does lead to a "well that's a bummer" when I find a cool app I'd be willing to pay an up-front fee for, but realize it's subscription. Right now I'm using Obsidian, which has been awesome, but it doesn't have a native UI feel to me.
- EduardMe 6y agoA one-time payment is a nice financial boost, but it's not sustainable over time. My plan is not to build an app, make quick money and then forget about it. I'm working on this full-time, every day. It's long term and I need long-term users to grow.
- skinnymuch 6y agoWhy this over Agenda? Because of the plain text? Would you prefer Agenda for other things still?