7 ms·
> If a provision as clearly drafted as [the First Amendment] may be subjected to political interpretation, what legal provision may not be? It's not clearly dr
by comex 16y ago
> If a provision as clearly drafted as [the First Amendment] may be subjected to political interpretation, what legal provision may not be?
It's not clearly drafted at all, nor "the clearest, most definite legal language"; the term "freedom of speech" is quite vague (insofar as it isn't interpreted literally, voice only, no writing, which certainly wasn't the intent), but there's no reason a law couldn't be written that specified in great detail what sort of activity is protected and what is not. It's just that we'd have to frequently amend such a law to account for changing mores, which is currently done on a more case by case basis.
> The very notion of a free market in legal services conjures up the image of anarchic gang warfare or rule by organized crime.
Are they not examples of such a market?
> One advocates a free market not because of some moral imprimatur written across the heavens, but because it is impossible for human beings to amass the knowledge of local conditions and the predictive capacity necessary to effectively organize economic relationships among millions of individuals.
This kind of hand-waving is usually used to justify the idea that the free market works best with as little regulation as possible. Unfortunately, the prevalence of harmful monopolies in history suggests that this is not true; state regulation is necessary.
> Although I am tempted to give this response, I never do.
You just did.
> This is because, although true, it never persuades. Instead, it is usually interpreted as an appeal for blind faith in the free market[...]
This is a somewhat disingenuous way of avoiding the point.
> A final example may be supplied by the many commercial enterprises that voluntarily opt out of the state judicial system by writing clauses in their contracts that require disputes to be settled through binding arbitration or mediation rather than through a lawsuit. In this vein, the variegated "legal" procedures that have recently been assigned the sobriquet of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) do a good job of suggesting what a free market in legal service might be like.
It's a good time for this to come up, because AT&T and their contract requiring each defrauded customer to negotiate individually is a pretty good example of how private justice can be perverted. What if similar practices were allowed in criminal law?
> In disputes over consumer contracts, the parties might well be satisfied with the current system of litigation in which the parties present their cases to an impartial judge or jury who renders a verdict for one side or the other.
The consumers would be and the corporations would not. Guess who has more bargaining power?