3 ms·
I think the situation in France is probably hopeless. Even Muslim-majority countries are having a difficult time reconciling themselves with the rise of Islamic
by rayiner 6y ago
I think the situation in France is probably hopeless. Even Muslim-majority countries are having a difficult time reconciling themselves with the rise of Islamic separatism. In countries like Bangladesh, where I’m from, or Turkey or Egypt, the separatism takes the form of reaction against the moderate secular regimes of the 20th century. Here is the President of Egypt in 1958 recounting his conversation with the leader of the Muslim Brotherhood. He and the audience laugh at the leader’s request to mandate headscarves in Egypt, observing that the leader’s own daughter, a medical student, doesn’t wear a headscarf: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZIqdrFeFBk https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_ZIqdrFeFBk. Back then, few women in Egypt wore a headscarf. Today, 90% of women do (and Muslim Brotherhood was recently in control of the country). In Bangladesh there are objections to our legal system, which is based on British common law, and our western-style constitution that embodies principles of secularism: https://resolvenet.org/system/files/2018-08/RSVE_03BangladeshBrief_ShariaDemocracy2017.pdf https://resolvenet.org/system/files/2018-08/RSVE_03Banglades....
People don’t give the United States enough credit for how well we have assimilated our Muslim immigrants. In France and Germany, Muslims suffer from generational poverty. In the US, they have higher incomes than average within a generation. I think our religiosity had a lot to do with it. We are a country founded by people who got kicked out of Europe for being religious fundamentalists. Our society functions smoothly with Mormons, Jehovah’s witnesses, Amish, etc.
Our society is accommodating on multiple levels—religious immigrants aren’t exclusively reliant on the goodwill of a segment of cosmopolitan liberals who like the idea of diversity for its own sake. Mormons and Southern Baptists took an active role in legal challenges to Trump’s “Muslim ban” (a tepid reaction compared to what’s happening in Europe). They have likewise challenged municipal actions denying construction permits for mosques. George W. Bush saw Islamic terrorists kill thousands of Americans and days later gave a heartfelt speech—coming from his own experience as a man of deep faith—about how Islam is a “religion of peace.” Meanwhile in France even liberal people strongly support stripping schoolgirls of headscarves. Macron is calling Islam a “religion in crisis.” French society barely manages to accommodate Christianity. How can it be expected to accommodate Islam?
- raverbashing 6y ago> People don’t give the United States enough credit for how well we have assimilated our Muslim immigrants Maybe because they are way fewer, having higher burdens for immigration (even given the geographical distance) and comimg from more tolerant generations/timeframes.
- rayiner 6y agoThat’s a major part of it, but not the whole story: https://www.fpri.org/2016/04/us-doesnt-muslim-problem-europe/ https://www.fpri.org/2016/04/us-doesnt-muslim-problem-europe... > My uncle was an educated and a skilled worker who climbed the ranks of German’s fledgling space agency to hold a senior scientist post. While he was professionally successful, his children, who were both born in Germany, struggled. They still feel they are outsiders, not quite German but definitely not Pakistani — a feeling that is repeated as they have children of their own. This experience juxtaposed with that of my father shows a clear difference. Even though I was raised in a predominantly white New York City suburb, I was never considered anything other than American. It is treatment that is extended to my children who, like the subsequent descendants of immigrants, are only aware of the ethnic roots as a distant fact. This is the fundamental difference between European and American Muslims: the ability for American Muslims to assimilate. Note that while the US doesn’t take as many Muslim refugees as Europe, unlike Canada or Australia it has an immigration system based on family reunification, not points. So while the first person in a family may immigrate based on say an H1-B, siblings and other family might immigrate significantly lower on the economic ladder. (This was true of for example my uncle, aunt, and cousins, who came over on a family reunification visa sponsored by my dad, who himself came over with a white collar job under an H1-B.)
- unpopularopp 6y agoOn the other hand the US is very much responsible for escalating the Arab Spring, just look at Syria and Libya. It's easy to bomb a country 6.000 miles away and then just watch what happens later. That was one of the biggest mistake of the Obama administration no matter what, admitted by himself too [0]. Illegal immigrantion to Europe wasn't that bad before 2010. 0, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-36013703 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-36013703
- rayiner 6y agoI agree those were mistakes, but the US didn’t undertake those interventions unilaterally. Both were international efforts. France was actually the first to say “Gaddafi must go.” France was also one of the leaders in the Syrian intervention: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2015/11/19/why-france-is-so-deeply-entangled-in-syria/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/monkey-cage/wp/2015/11/1... > France’s hawkish stance towards Syria contrasts with the reluctance among many U.S. policymakers to expand American involvement in the conflict. This is the latest move in a long history of French resistance to American foreign policy decision-making.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoExcellent analysis, and one I hadn’t considered. I wouldn’t have made the connection between strong religious liberty and reducing the likelihood of islamic separatism.
- ramblerman 6y ago> People don’t give the United States enough credit for how well we have assimilated our Muslim immigrants. To be fair, the US also got a lot of Lebanese, and Iranians to come over. A lot of these people were Doctors and Lawyers back home. European immigration has been mostly from North Africa.
- rayiner 6y agoI don’t mean to downplay that distinction, but it’s worth nothing that being a doctor or lawyer back home is worth little after you immigrate. A lot of my aunts and uncles immigrated from Bangladesh to Anglo countries, and you have doctors, judges, and engineers working retail. They were starting back at 0. A few of the younger ones spent years getting advanced degrees and eventually professional jobs, while many didn’t. But the next generation, my cousins, are pretty uniformly college educated professionals: doctors, lawyers, accountants, bankers, and engineers. And they’re fully socially integrated. Obviously coming from an educated family has certain intangible advantages. But the economic mobility and pathway to integration is critical. And it doesn’t exist in every developed country.
- littlestymaar 6y ago> Even Muslim-majority countries are having a difficult time reconciling themselves with the rise of Islamic separatism. You got it backward. Unless you live in a country with a majority of Muslims, radical Islamism is not going to be an issue except for the Muslims themselves. They are never going to be politically powerful enough to enforce any kind of Islamic inspired law on the whole population, so their power of nuisance is limited to the Muslim community (especially young liberals in this community, women, gays, etc.) but as long as the society as a whole provides an escape from those Islamic circles, most Muslims will be fine. The ultra-orthodox Jewish community and traditionalist Catholics are other instances of Radical religious subcommunity in a liberal country, doing not much harm outside of their own small groups (where they do, like Radical Muslims). The big issue in France, is that many (most?) Muslims live in ghetto-ized suburbs and have lots of difficulties to join the rest of the French society. This makes the nuisance power of the Islamic groups much bigger than it should be. And the state bears a lot of responsibility is this : both passively, by not taking strong stance on discrimination (for employment, studies, and housing), but also actively, by setting-up its own kinds of discrimination in an attempt to appeal far-right electors.
- cpr 6y agoOh, "traditionalist" "radical" Catholics (I'm one of those) are doing harm in their own groups, and even some outside their own groups? How, pray tell? By advocating for the traditional Tridentine Mass? By praying the Rosary? Dangerous folk are we!
- littlestymaar 6y agoAt least 300 hundred gay teenagers are kicked out of their home every year in France, most of them for religious believes (Muslims, Christians and Jewish alike). When they aren't just pushed to suicide[1]. And how about physical violence in religious school?[2] So yes, like Islamists, some Catholics are doing harm in their own group (namely, their family). [1] https://tetu.com/2018/12/03/nantes-collegien-homosexuel-defenestre-echapper-pere/ https://tetu.com/2018/12/03/nantes-collegien-homosexuel-defe... [2] https://www.ladepeche.fr/article/2018/09/06/2863588-coups-batons-gifles-nuits-terre-trois-profs-ecole-integriste-condamnes.html https://www.ladepeche.fr/article/2018/09/06/2863588-coups-ba...