3 ms·
Take all interpretations of French politics/laws from American journalists with a good amount of salt. This week there was already a massive wave of disinforma
by raverbashing 6y ago
Take all interpretations of French politics/laws from American journalists with a good amount of salt.
This week there was already a massive wave of disinformation by the part of WP and NYT saying France was going the way of a famous 20th century authoritarian regime.
- crocodiletears 6y agoI wonder what precipitated this slew of coverage. In my subjective experience, when Western European states do something creepy or authoritarian, publications like the WP and NYT seem to ignore or downplay it. Never gets much play here in the US unless you're reading fringe publications. Are France and the US in a policy dispute? Or is it just the strike against academia and critical race theory?
- littlestymaar 6y agoIt used to be the same about France (France has been on this slope for a decade), but now the French political situation has become more than just “something creepy or authoritarian”, and is becoming really scary even by American standards. In a law proposal discussed today, facial recognition via drones will be deployed and filming the police will get you in jail for up to 48h without seeing a judge, and your phone/camera will be taken from you for up to six month, again without judge intervention.
- littlestymaar 6y agoYesterday night: An homeless immigrant being thrown from his tent https://twitter.com/RemyBuisine/status/1330979314272178185 https://twitter.com/RemyBuisine/status/1330979314272178185 Then, the journalist who made this shot (Remy Buisine) is beaten by the police https://twitter.com/Marco_cgr/status/1330997295618416643 https://twitter.com/Marco_cgr/status/1330997295618416643. He was assaulted three times in one hour (https://twitter.com/RemyBuisine/status/1330993051263791104 https://twitter.com/RemyBuisine/status/1330993051263791104) And the government is currently passing a law that will allow the police to arrest anyone filming their intervention (journalists included). The direction taken by France is indeed really concerning.
- raverbashing 6y agoThanks, I am aware of the events of last night, where an NGO moved a camp and set up multiple tents on a main square for theatrical purposes and the clearing of the square was completely justifiable (though the means are certainly questionable) > The direction taken by France is indeed really concerning. I'm more worried about teachers being killed for showing drawings to students
- littlestymaar 6y ago> where an NGO moved a camp and set up multiple tents on a main square for theatrical purposes and the clearing of the square was completely justifiable It was indeed a happening, by activists. A bit of context: the state is required by law to provide emergency housing to these people, but failed to comply, so this NGO organized this happening to attract attention on this problem (and the non-respect of the law by the government). Reacting to such happening by assaulting the JOURNALISTS covering the event is unjustifiable in a democratic country, sorry. > I'm more worried about teachers being killed for showing drawings to students It was ONE teacher, not teacher, and it was indeed a tragedy. And it also has no link with the police assaulting journalists (Samuel Patty was defending free speech, assaulting journalists is as far as you can get from that…).
- raverbashing 6y agoFrance has no obligation to give free room and board for anyone that shows up. If any country disagrees they are free to pay for transportation and lodgement themselves. > It was ONE teacher And the ones that were stabbed in front of the Charlie Hebdo office "by mistake" this year. And the other attacks this year. And the previous attacks on CH and/or for other Cartoons So no it's not just "one teacher" (as if it was fine being just one)
- littlestymaar 6y agoFirst, the French State has obligations which are written in the French laws. I didn't write them or vote for any of those, and the government can change them if they will, but those are the current laws in my country. If the government doesn't respect laws, then we're out of the State of Law and closer to Venezuela & Russia than to UK or Germany. Second, you said “teacherS”, when the murder you were talking about was of one teacher. You were deforming facts to push your agenda, which I pointed out. And by the way, if you're willing to accept a handful of murders (or even a thousand, as a matter of fact) as a good reason to make our country an authoritarian state for its 65 millions inhabitants, you are much, much closer to the supporters of the “famous 20th century authoritarian regime” that you are willing to admit.