3 ms·
Yeah, I looked at it and this seems completely normal to me as someone having grown up somewhere (Norway) where comics were a far more integral part of the cul
by vidarh 6y ago
Yeah, I looked at it and this seems completely normal to me as someone having grown up somewhere (Norway) where comics were a far more integral part of the culture (US comic book artists often tour Scandinavia, as even newspaper strips often get monthly ensemble books in the Scandinavian countries, and some comics sell more in even individual Nordic countries than the US at times).
Comedic comics often do this kind of thing, though the specific patterns may differ. Especially coloured versions of newspaper strips because they were often originally published in black and white, and so there were often no clear guides on colour from the original artists and it's easier to then have the colouring follow some rough set of patterns than to spend time agonising over it, and focus of often far more on making it easily and quickly digestible than particularly artistic.
There's a reason Calvin and Hobbes was such a major revolution in the newspaper strip market - with few exceptions newspaper strips were not considered to really be focused on the art; it was about the gag. You had strips where the artist very obviously cut and pasted and reused panels multiple times, to the point where some strips included meta-jokes about how little effort went into the art of some series.
Returning to the colouring, Hagar the Horrible is one example, which while more constrained than Garfield, it took me just a couple of clicks to find examples where the interior wall of a house changes colour between panels back and forth with the dialogue.
EDIT: Here's a Hagar strip where that is particularly noticeable, as the background colour changes very specifically to emphasise an outburst:
https://www.facebook.com/hagarthehorrible.net/posts/-31-new-comics-december-are-added-on-httpwwwhagarthehorriblenet-all-strips-of-20/782736271926581/ https://www.facebook.com/hagarthehorrible.net/posts/-31-new-...
- toyg 6y agoI agree. Generally speaking, I found it difficult to empathize with the writer's marvel for recolored strips, in sentences like "The notion that a strip might have been colored differently from paper to paper opens up a whole new world of imagination". Dude, this has been done all over the comic industry since coloring existed, there are entire series dedicated to doing exactly that to specific bodies of work. Sure, newspapers strip are their own little niche in many ways, but this is hardly unique or original in Garfield. I'm somewhat surprised a fairly famous strip artist in his own right (David Malki of Wondermark) wouldn't know that.
- dmd 6y ago> You had strips where the artist very obviously cut and pasted and reused panels multiple times The end-state of which, of course, is Dinosaur Comics, which is the same art [almost, 99.9%] every single strip.
- tokai 6y agoI read a lot of old donald duck comics as a kid. The European ones made by Italian Disney and Egmont. The strips from the 70s were absolutely wild in their colouring, with objects changing colour throughout the story and with a palette would fit right in with an acid trip. Only half of the pages were coloured to save money. So in my experience you're right. It's a very normal thing for comics.
- anthk 6y agoDitto in Spain with the infamous Bruguera comics (Mortadelo y Filemon are as known in Spain as much as Don Quixote, if not more). Have an example: http://museodelcomic.triguerostudios.es/2018/05/la-escuela-bruguera/ http://museodelcomic.triguerostudios.es/2018/05/la-escuela-b... Later in the 90's the colours got right and with far more tones, and the old comic books has been reprinted at least twice, and a lot of reprinted volumes today have a much better colouring and inking. I mean, the exact same volumes, but with a far better colour pallete, a much bigger one.
- anthk 6y agoThose colour shifts happened with cheap comic books in Spain in the 70-80's, done with a crazy colour pallete with just consistency for the characters, furniture and the sky. Those were in the Spanish slapstick comedy media. If any Spaniard read this, for sure he knows the Bruguera school. And, yes, Frenchies, we copycated you several times.