4 ms·
Reducing personal emissions is a red herring. The vast majority of emissions are not coming from individuals, but from industry. And contrary to popular beliefs
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Reducing personal emissions is a red herring. The vast majority of emissions are not coming from individuals, but from industry. And contrary to popular beliefs, there is no way to dismantle an industry by changing your personal behavior - we need massive political and economic overhauls to have any measurable impact.
And telling people that a sustainable world requires them to be vegetarian or vegan is wrong and counter-productive. We do need to significantly reduce consumption of animal products, but there is no need to eliminate them from our diets completely.
- jusssi 6y agoI live in a small country (~5.5M people) that is near the top of the list for CO2 emissions per capita. The usual argument around here for not spending any effort in reducing CO2 emissions is that it won't matter: as a nation, we're so small compared to China and the US that we'll make no difference. Therefore, we should sit on our hands and tell the rest of the world to fix the situation while we watch. By your logic (edit: unnecessarily harsh. "by the logic you present here"), everyone else but the absolute largest single CO2 emitting entity shouldn't do anything (because there's someone who's even worse), and that largest one can point back to the others blaming them for not doing anything either.
- musingsole 6y agoIsn't it an optimization problem though? Focusing on anything but your bottleneck (or largest carbon producer) has minuscule effects. If the largest carbon producer did do enough work to become tied with the 2nd largest producer, there's now an argument for why the 2 largest must do something while the rest watch. Granted, yeah, it'd be better for everyone to do what they can and let's all kumbaya, but it doesn't look like the incentives will ever line up for that.
- Qwertious 6y agoOptimization isn't about focusing on the largest resource consumer, but on the most reducible. (Note that this makes your statement basically tautological) And given that China's main problem is its population (which is basically impossible to reduce much more right now and they're still dealing with negative side-effects from their effective but not-very-nice One Child policy), not it's emissions per person, China doesn't have as much to reduce. Whereas if the US lived at China's level of emissions per capita, then the world's total greenhouse emissions would drop by over 10%.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe problem with this individualistic agenda is two-fold: some people who understand how dire the problem is believe that individual action is the way to go, and don't pay enough attention to the politics of climate change because 'everyone should just offset their own carbon footprint like I do, and then we wouldn't need big government to come in and take our rights'. Then, there are other people who think 'these damn hippies want me to become a vegan and stop using a car, this is obviously not tenable as a way to save the world, let's look at carbon sequestration so we can continue living like today'. I'm not claiming that these are the only two ways people react, but I do believe they are two common ways. I also believe many companies and political parties encourage those two ways of thinking, because they allow them to maintain the current status quo.
- Qwertious 6y agoNorway, Finland, Denmark, or Slovakia? I'm guessing either Norway or Finland.
- kisamoto 6y agoGranted sweeping political legislation will have larger effects but a lot of industry is fundamentally driven by consumers. Like voting a single individual can feel helpless but on mass changes that reduce ones own footprint and focus more on net-zero and sustainable produce will ripple through industry who will react to customer demand.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI think consumption behavior is much more controlled by industry through pricing and advertising than the other way around. There are very few examples of successful campaigns to change behavior on aarge scale, much more so if we are talking about industries with high investments, like animal stocks, or for industries that are far away from the consumer, like power generation, plastics etc.
- triceratops 6y agoReducing personal emissions can help increase political will to take on the industry. Voters who don't eat hamburgers can't be swayed by "Hamburgers will cost $50 if we have carbon taxes" campaigns.