11 ms·
Oslo got pedestrian and cyclist deaths down to zero. Here’s how
- jhunter1016 6y agoI’ve been to Oslo a couple of times now and both times I was amazed by the quality and cost of public transportation. The busses run frequently and go where you need them to go. There is a train that takes you to the outer areas and the airport. There’s really no excuse for most cities not to follow this model.
- gspr 6y agoYet people complain. I don't get it. I'm quite new to the city myself, but I'm quite surprised by how much people complain about public transit and about cars getting increasingly banned from the city center. I would agree that the train service leaves something to be desired (but then again, I moved here from the train heaven that is Switzerland). But the subway, busses and trams are A+.
- vmception 6y agoThis is my whole experience in Europe. People complaining about their "late" [impeccable] trains. I'm like eehhh, okay, wait till you see the United States! The only culture shock to me is that union strikes can actually have an affect on convenience or quality of life, they're more like mosquitos buzzing in your ear if a protest has gone on for over a week in the US. I don't have an opinion, and that's part of the privilege!
- hypertele-Xii 6y agoEspecially in Finland with a single government-run train company that routinely makes announcements like "the trains are late because we didn't anticipate it raining snow". In winter. In Finland. Try Japan. Trains run on time to the second, so precisely that time tables printed on paper to the second are accurate.
- gspr 6y agoHehe, I remember my first train journey in the US. I believe it was Philly to NYC. I remember thinking "hey, what are they complaining about!? This is totally fine!" before I was told that together with like one other corridor like this in California(?), that's essentially full the extent of usable US rail service?
- prox 6y agoI wonder if Joe Biden “Amtrak Joe” will make a change, since he is such a big fan of trains.
- ghaff 6y agoWell, no. And one wonders to what degree Amtrak plans will be pushed out because of the plunge in travel. It's also easy to be a fan of trains if you live in the Northeast Corridor. More or less uniquely in the US other than a handful of other city pairs.
- vmception 6y agoThat's the full extent of tolerable long distance commuter rail service. The issue is that it can't be modernized to be faster and quieter in an economical way. Actually the issue is that its too uneconomical to do so, the current trains are not economical. This is whether we are referring to that high traffic corridor or to anywhere else.
- ghaff 6y agoThe NE Corridor is actually profitable for Amtrak (in normal times). The problem is that Amtrak then proceeds to lose its NE Corridor profits on pretty much every other train route in the country.
- volkl48 6y agoAmtrak basically is 3 different types of services, especially after PRRIA 2008 changed the funding structure. - Northeast Corridor - Makes a solid operating profit (normally), run by Amtrak. - State-supported corridor services - The states are basically paying the subsidy required to run the service and deciding what they want. If the state wants to upgrade the line for faster service, run more trains, etc, and they want to pay for it, Amtrak will run it. In some cases, the states (WA + CA come to mind) own or part-own the equipment being run as well. This is most other "practical" services (NY Empire Service, WA/OR Cascades, etc) and where you're seeing most improvements/investments. - Long-distance network - They run once a day or less, they're where most of the hours/days late horror stories come from, they almost all lose money, federal government pays and dictates that they run it. Mostly impractical as transportation for people who have any other option for how to get somewhere. That said, the loss isn't that big as a financial number (in part, because there's not that much service), and it's basically a matter of political calculus as well....lots of rural senators who sign off on Amtrak funding in substantial part because of their one or two trains a day.
- ck425 6y agoI mean in the UK ours are terrible. We dream of European efficiency as much as you do.
- neffy 6y agoErm... when the trains are late in the US it can be by hours (NY -- Boston), or even a day or so (on the transcontinental route). Amtrak gets severely outcompeted on most routes by a somewhat informal "chinatown" bus network.
- pmyteh 6y agoYeah. I'm British, and a few years ago spent several weeks travelling around the US by Amtrak. Not one of my trains was actually on time, and the Sunset Limited (LA -> New Orleans) was over a day late. Our trains aren't great for punctuality, but they're nowhere near that bad. Of course, the reasons are somewhat different, too. In the UK the problem is mostly that the tracks are very heavily timetabled with passenger trains, such that there's very little slack: an issue with one service can screw up an entire chunk of the network with effects that last for hours. In the US, freight trains have priority outside the Northeast Corridor, so we would get looped for several hours to wait for a train of oil tankers going the other way.
- cr1895 6y agoDoesn't this have something to do with priority given to freight rail in the US?
- Barrin92 6y agoHaving moved from Germany to the UK I'm actually positively surprised by public transport which I rely on every day. (living in London). The only thing I've noticed is that it is quite expensive.
- pmontra 6y ago> union strikes can actually have an affect on convenience or quality of life I never understood why transport unions effectively run their strikes against the passengers instead of against the governments (most of them are state owned or heavily subsidized here in Europe.) They should go to protest in front of the government offices and not jeopardizing the lives of citizens, who could be their allies. Instead everybody ends up hating transport workers. My bet: a traditional strike helps the careers inside the unions. Going against the government doesn't.
- gameswithgo 6y agoI think that part of the human condition is that we are smart enough to quite easily imagine perfectly operating systems. It is simple to imagine the train that is always on time to the second, the politician who is 100% ethical, a good judge of character, works hard, and has broad relevant knowledge. It is possible to imagine the construction company that always finishes the roads on time and with high quality. But for humans to actually do all of these things is extremely hard. We only recently were very much like a primate we see in the wild. We have tons of ambition and imagination but all the flaws of a prototype intelligent creature. We can't always think clearly, emotions often get in the way when we can, we get tired, we have conflicting drives and feedback loops that mean we are never truly satisfied no matter how good we have it. such is life.
- ghaff 6y agoI imagine that there are very few places in the world where people universally love their public transit if they're dependent on it day-to-day. Whether it's cost, frequency, coverage, reliability, frequency, comfort, etc., something that seems perfectly adequate or even pretty great to a sometimes visitor seems less so if you're commuting at rush hour every day in all sorts of weather. You mention Swiss train service for example which seemed pretty great as a visitor--but it sure wasn't cheap as is true of a lot of European train service. Ditto for the Shinkanzen in Japan. My personal experience is Boston. As someone who takes rail into the city and then the subway maybe a few times a year, it seems just fine. When I depended on it for regular commuting, I did not love it.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoTo be fair though you probably wouldn't have loved commuting into the city in a car either.
- ghaff 6y agoI certainly did not. I took the train by preference if I was going into the city "9-5"; my office was a short walk from the station. But the train was useless if I was doing something in the evening because it ran so infrequently outside of commuting hours. Frankly it was not a commute I could have handled long term--about 90 minutes door to door--even though I didn't have to do it every day.
- gspr 6y ago> You mention Swiss train service for example which seemed pretty great as a visitor--but it sure wasn't cheap as is true of a lot of European train service. The thing is, if you're not a visitor, you'd buy an AG or a demi-tarif (perhaps with a contribution from your employer). The former gives you free unlimited use on almost all public transit (including trains and busses), or alternatively, the latter gives you approximately a 50% discount on the price you paid as a tourist. The latter is quite commonly sponsored by your employer – and even if not, both types pay off very quickly if you actually commute by public transit.
- q-base 6y agoThat is probably because you look at it from too narrow a position. Yes, the public transport inside Oslo may be brilliant. That is very good for transporting people around who lives inside Oslo, but chances are that a lot of people cannot afford or want to live there. For probably each kilometer extra you move away from the city center, the difficulty using public transport increases exponentially. Once you get to 50-100km away from the city center, then your options look very bleak. I live in Copenhagen myself, but I grew up 100km outside of Copenhagen. Using a car to go back and forth from there to Copenhagen takes approximately 1 hour each way. Using public transportation all the way takes closer to 2 hours. Using a combination takes 1h 30min on a good day. Some people move out of cities because they want the countryside. But other people are forced to do so because of prices. Banning cars from cities seems to only think of people who lives inside it and not how difficult it will be for a lot of people already "taxed" with hour long commutes because of stupidly expensive housing combined with centralization of workplaces.
- ghaff 6y agoI'm in the same situation with the nearest major city. The train actually makes sense to go in and out on a work day if I need to for some reason given how bad rush hour traffic is. But it's a non-starter for an evening event. I just wouldn't go in if you made it too hard for me to drive and park. (Which the city can absolutely do of course.)
- bluGill 6y agoWhy wouldn't you use the train for the non-work event? I don't know where you live. What I do know is in many cities they run 2-4 train in for those who start work at 8am, and then run them back out at 5 pm after the people get off work. If this is your case, as it is for many, then I agree. They don't want you to take the train to those evening events. It doesn't have to be this way. A train could run every 5 minutes all day long. If your city did this would you still insist on driving?
- fogihujy 6y agoWell, see my Copenhagen example abuve for one reason. The Metro goes every 5 minutes, but if you need to go somewhere where you need to switch between the metro and some other form of public transport then you'll usually double the time required. The fact that it's cheaper for three people to take a taxi instead of going with public transport doesn't help either.
- jillesvangurp 6y agoPeople always complain. What matters is their behavior. In most bigger cities, getting around by car stopped being a thing as it is time consuming and not much fun. Places like London, Amsterdam, Paris, etc. outright ban cars from a lot of streets and make it stupidly expensive to park. A weird side effect of that is that a lot of the remaining cars tend to be of the expensive/oversized variety. But the reality for most is that people get around by bike and public transport and tend to prefer that to getting stuck in traffic and then having to hunt for parking space. I live in Berlin which is unusually car friendly for a European city because of the German car lobby. You can literally drive up to places like the Alexanderplatz and expect to find a spot to park there (with some difficulty). But even in Berlin, owning a car is not a given for most people that live there. It's just not very practical. I've never bothered owning one and probably never will. With what I save on not owning a car, I can easily afford to rent cars or use taxis/ubers when I need to; which is not that often actually. Berlin is comparatively unorganized when it comes to protecting bike traffic. Coming from the Netherlands, it feels a bit like a third world country on this front. Infrastructure is poor/non existent and Berlin excels at creating safety challenged situations for cyclists where you randomly get to mingle with heavy traffic, deal with delivery vans using the bike lanes as parking areas, etc. Mostly places like Oslo and other bike friendly cities differ from this by separating flows of traffic systematically. Of course compared to the US, Germany is still pretty good.
- npsimons 6y ago> (but then again, I moved here from the train heaven that is Switzerland) I hiked the Haute Route last year, and while we were only on the trains and buses a handful of times, it was flawless every time. Like, they had things scheduled down to the minute, and no, not some multiple of 5 minutes, literal "train arrives at 10:42, train leaves at 10:44". Clean too. So nice.
- bluGill 6y agoSwitzerland is well known for this. Part of this is they run the trains slower than they can go which gives plenty of ability to go faster if needed to meet the schedule. The schedule in turn is carefully designed so that where trains they all meet at the same time, thus ensuring you can switch trains and so you wouldn't want your train to go faster even though it could in theory. There are two good ways to run a good transport system: a carefully planned timetable so that you always know when your train arrives, and once you get on all your connections are easy to make. The other is as fast and frequent as possible, you never know when your next train will arrive but it will be soon enough that you don't care anyway. The second is somewhat better, but vastly more expensive.
- OscarTheGrinch 6y agoCities struggle to build better public transport because car owners complain en masse about any impingement on their freedoms. Car supremacy is a big wedge issue in Norway, which is paradoxically a big oil exporter, and the worlds leader in electric vehicle usage. It even has has its own single issue political party, I wonder if big oil money is behind it? https://www.lifeinnorway.net/norways-drivers-rally-against-road-tolls/ https://www.lifeinnorway.net/norways-drivers-rally-against-r...
- kristofferR 6y agoThat's a weird conspiracy theory, the FNB actually has valid complaints, although I disagree with them overall. The way the green change has been implemented here in Norway has unfortunately often been extremely conservative (instead of progressive) - the well-off living centrally in the cities gets massive subsidies for purchasing their Teslas while the less fortunate needs to pay hefty tolls for their old gasoline cars.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- npsimons 6y ago> impingement on their freedoms. It's funny what terms we choose (framing) can do. "death tax" instead of "inheritance tax", "driver's rights" instead of "driver's privileges." People all too often forget that driving in public places requires a license, it's not a right, it's a privilege that has to be earned.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hhjinks 6y agoFNB is about "bompenger", basically a fee paid when crossing certain spots with your motor vehicle, often used to pay for road maintenance etc. Usually you have to cross one or more of these spots before getting into any major city. Since it's a flat fee, it disproportionally affects less affluent families, who often need their car more than the average family. These fees are often quite expensive. You might have to pay €5-10 to deliver the kids to kindergarten, and then get to work, if you live outside the city. That can be as much as €400 a month, just passive, unavoidable expanses for a lot of families. The reason FNB was founded is because these fees have increased substantially in recent years. The camel's back finally broke, and FNB became an actual political block in like a year. I would argue FNB is a prime example of democracy working for the people. The two established ruling parties kept wringing money from people using bompenger until they had enough and took a lot of power for themselves.
- jariel 6y ago"t. There’s really no excuse for most cities not to follow this model." Norwegian Sovereign Wealth Fund owns 2% of the entire world's publicly traded stocks. They have so much money the fight over what to do with it. They are an Oil rich state, like Qatar, Kuwait. When you have that kind of surplus, a lot of things become easy. For the rest of the world, the issue is money: either you raise taxes, increase fares, take on more debt (or invade a rich country), none of which are good options.
- addicted 6y agoYeah but Oslo is in dense Europe not in undense USA so obviously the greatest country in the world cannot achieve this. /sarcasm
- cbmuser 6y agoNo, but Oslo is tiny compared to most US cities. It is actually comparing Apples and Oranges.
- cbmuser 6y agoIt’s actually not that good. I lived in Oslo for a year and the main problem is that service stops at around midnight so you either have to walk or take a taxi which is incredibly expensive. Luckily, the city isn’t that large so walking works most of the time.
- klunger 6y agoI live in Oslo and have to say it is pretty great if you are able bodied. If you have trouble walking for any reason, it is really hard because cars have a hard time getting to many places you might need to go. As someone who is periodically in and out of crutches, I have a love-hate relationship with the city. Anyway, this is 2019 data. It should be noted that there was a tragic accident in early 2020 when a 2-year-old was struck and killed. If there were others this year, I have not heard about it, but I don't know for sure. So, it still happens. But, it is rare enough that it is really big news when it does.
- PixelOfDeath 6y agoShould electro bicycles not make such issues easier to handle?
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoPossibly, if you're able bodied enough to ride one of those.
- alisonkisk 6y agoMotorized wheelchair/scooter? The savings from not building car infrastructure should easily pay for personal scooters.
- romanoderoma 6y agoIt's quite cold in Norway. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Vigdis_Vandvik/publication/251878198/figure/fig2/AS:601749442285579@1520479655143/Map-of-Norway-indicating-mean-annual-temperature-and-the-sampled-populations-as-well-as.png https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Vigdis_Vandvik/publicat...
- bluntfang 6y agoJust curious, does cold affect people with disabilities more than people without, beyond the obvious non-linear difficulty increase for people with disabilities (ie something thats *2 difficulty increase for a person without disabilities is ^2 difficulty increase)? The only thing I can think of would be battery life of the mobility tools.
- ejolto 6y ago> London show 73 pedestrian and six cyclist fatalities in 2019 London has a 13 times the population of Oslo, so they are on the same order of magnitude in regards to pedestrian and cyclist deaths.
- Ottolay 6y agoIf you take the average Oslo deaths over 2019 and 2020, which is 0.5, then London would have one order of magnitude more deaths per capita than London.
- MrRiddle 6y agoMaybe cities of different size cannot be compared 1 to 1 and due to it’s size it’s London being orders of magnitude better? We don’t know that, so it doesn’t really make sense yo compare them.
- ReptileMan 6y agoNot that simple. I have a hunch that network effects play huge role too. Chances of london having two orders of magnitude car/pedestrian interactions more than also are not low. So the chances of fatality per interaction could be comparable. But you have shitload more of them in london since everything is bigger there so you clock more miles.
- theonionknight 6y agoHere's a good comparison. Portland has a population of ~600,000 and there were 50 traffic deaths in 2019: https://www.oregonlive.com/commuting/2019/12/vision-zero-portland-saw-most-traffic-deaths-since-1997-many-out-of-our-control.html https://www.oregonlive.com/commuting/2019/12/vision-zero-por... What Oslo has been able to accomplish is truly astonishing.
- readingnews 6y agoCould it possibly be the well educated populous that drives with sense and caution? Just asking, as in the states we have people going 50mph (80.4kmh) on residential streets in front of parks full of kids, people running, etc. I live near a park. The speed limit is 25mph. I have been driving down that street at 29mph, and had people _pass_ my car, blowing the horn and yelling (on a completely residential two lane) like I was standing still. This is a common, everyday occurrence.
- pornel 6y agoMaybe the road has been (mis)designed for faster speeds? Wide, straight roads have a "natural" high speed limit. The slightly counter-intuitive solution is to make residential roads narrow and winding, which makes drivers slow down. Or at least it should have road bumps.
- wil421 6y agoSpeed humps make a huge difference. I lived on a road where it was 25 but naturally you would want to go 35. After installing speed humps people would slow down instead of coasting down a hill gaining speed.
- throwaway0a5e 6y agoIt takes two to have a mulit-party accident. You can have the best educated drivers and the most draconian enforcement in the world but if everyone else acts like it's a college campus you're gonna get a lot of red road paint. The cities without a lot of traffic fatalities tend to have traffic that behaves a lot like the industrial facilities where there aren't a lot of traffic mishaps (and industry has been studying this a lot longer because they have an obvious stake in the issue). Namely classes of traffic have to interact with each over only minimally, interactions only happen in defined places and all classes of traffic behave very conservatively. Also, if people are getting so bent out of shape as to pass you and honk at you with any sort of regularity that's a good heuristic for the speed limit and/or your adherence to it being inappropriate for the construction and conditions of the road.
- oftenwrong 6y agoThere have been some related threads on this subject: "Oslo made its city center basically car-free" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19000076 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19000076 "Oslo had 0 pedestrian, 0 cyclist, 0 children and 1 driver traffic deaths in 2019" https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21933868 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21933868
- goldsteinq 6y agoOslo is, like, quite small. You can't really get somewhere without transport in London or New York.
- kiliantics 6y agoI get around New York almost exclusively by bicycle and it's easily the fastest way to get around, even if I'm going from Central Brooklyn to Harlem or further
- da_big_ghey 6y agoNew York City is the worst example of an American city you could have chosen. Because it's bounded by water on all sides, it's the one American city that has developed in an extremely dense manner and is thus walkable. You are right for essentially any other American city, though.
- ghaff 6y agoYeah, a lot of people visiting NYC never leave a relatively small area of Manhattan. I don't mind walking relatively long distances (and I'm fine with taking the NYC subway) but on my typical NYC visit I never use anything other than my feet to get around. The same is somewhat true of London though I'm more likely to get on the tube there. Added: It depends too on where you're going in the city. There are a fair number of US cities where walking works fine so long as you restrict your travel mostly to the city core, which people often do on a short trip.
- aplusbi 6y agoPerhaps I'm being a little pedantic here, but NYC is not bounded on all sides by water - the Bronx is part of mainland NYS. But yes - for the most part NYC is geographically constrained.
- dr_faustus 6y agoThey switched many inner cities to pedastrian-only zones in Germany decades ago. What becomes more and more apparent now is that it seems to slowly but surely kill retail in inner cities. It starts with people getting their groceries at the outskirts of cities. More and more retail then is attached to those supermarkets and people only do clothes and specialty items shopping in the cities anymore which incidentally are the categories most people buy on the internet by now (its just more convenient then spending a fortune on parking and then walking for 15 minutes to get to the shop you want to get to). In the end, while it sounds nice, in the age to the internet people are too lazy to keep a pedestrian-only inner cities viable from a retail perspective.
- tobltobs 6y agoDo pedastrian-only zones or the internet kill retail?
- swimfar 6y agoIf retail still exists, just not in inner cities, then it wasn't the Internet.
- Laarlf 6y agoBoth. It’s enjoyable to go shopping once in a while. If you get treated properly and it’s easy to go there, why not? Even a small increase in price is totally acceptable. But if none of those things apply, Amazon it is. This seems to have happened with my rather small city next to the Ruhrgebiet
- ghaff 6y agoPedestrian-only zones probably help specific types of retail--"tourist" (using the term broadly) type of stuff for people walking around the pedestrian area for fun. But, honestly, cities aren't great for heavy/bulky shopping anyway. I normally go into the tourist area of my nearest major city maybe a few times a year and mostly because my company has an office nearby. But I appreciate pedestrian zones when I travel. (Last time I was in Brussels, the new pedestrian zone almost made that area of one of my least favorite European capitals almost pleasant.)
- xliiv 6y agoAll dead have assigned covid death ;) ?
- seph-reed 6y agoThe first I heard of this concept was in a book called "Eco-topia". Since then, I've seen it in a few places but they are always extremely touristy. I would like to see things like this further from downtown, and less large.
- throwawaysea 6y agoLike most articles on this topic, this one also ignores the most basic question, which is whether a goal of 'zero deaths' is desirable. Any such goal must be considered against the tradeoffs. Life in general, is not safe. If someone desires perfect safety, they would need to shelter themselves aggressively, avoid people, avoid activities, and minimize risks from all angles as much as they can. This is of course, unrealistic and undesirable for most people. Everyone is assuming risks all the time for purposes they think are worth the risk. The Vision Zero goal of 'zero deaths' isn't a more virtuous balance between risk and reward than any other goal. Now onto the tradeoffs: Cars have many advantages over walking, cycling, and public transportation. If you avoid the tipping point of building too much density, cars are simply much more convenient and faster. You don't have to build your life around public transportation schedules. You don't need to wait for a bus or train to arrive. You don't need to plan walking time to/from the bus stop or train station into your schedule. You can avoid the harassment, filth, and hazards (like uncapped needles) that come with public transportation. Cycling has its own inconveniences from dealing with steep slopes, to arriving sweaty at your destination, to weather exposure, to rampant bike theft, and more. In terms of raw speed, cars are are simply much faster than either public transportation or cycling unless the city has purposely made driving significantly worse (with poor road design, by eliminating parking spaces or lanes, building too much density, setting artificially low speed limits, etc.). Another element that I often see ignored is what life is actually like in the pedestrian/cycling-heavy Northern European cities that are so often painted as utopias. As someone who has spent lots of time in these cities/countries, I have to disagree with the notion that quality of life is somehow better there. Self-reported happiness surveys are not good evidence. Life there felt boring to me. It feels like you have a playpen within which you can move around and live, but that's it. If you want to have full/productive days where you can visit friends, go out of town for a hike, do your shopping, shuttle kids to a game, and so forth - it's simply not possible. Any travel outside the playpen (city centers) is difficult and inconvenient, and you simply don't have time to go do things to the same extent you would in many US cities. In part due to transportation choices and city design, but also due to other things that add up to "culture", life there is distinctly less social and more introverted relative to American cities. This doesn't have to be your set of values and preferences, but I feel it's important to recognize why many of us value cities and countries that have great infrastructure for cars. Often times, I see comments that express incredulity that others may value these things and bemoaning the slow adoption of [their preferred modes of transportation]. The reality is that many of us simply value different things.
- hikerclimb 6y agoGood a kid died...
- todd8 6y agoI like the elevated walkways present in central Hong Kong, I’d never seen a system like that to keep pedestrians away from the cars passing below for congested areas. It’s not like Las Vegas where there are a few bridges over the large streets; in Hong Kong one can walk blocks on walkways above the streets in the busy areas. This was especially nice for US visitors since the traffic comes from an unexpected direction. In contrast to this, I find Amsterdam, one of my favorite cities, to be full of street crossings with cars, bikes, and trains to worry about.