30 ms·
Amazon here is effectively bootstrapping their own global mesh network. Fun and scary in equal measure. I wonder if this was in the original plan for the Echo
by toyg 6y ago
Amazon here is effectively bootstrapping their own global mesh network. Fun and scary in equal measure.
I wonder if this was in the original plan for the Echo all along, or just evolved organically. It definitely has potential for being another well-paved road to total-surveillance hell.
- grey-area 6y agoI think a global mesh network is inevitable - every thing is going to talk to the devices around it (and eventually to wired humans) all the time wirelessly. It'd be nice if it were not in the control of any corporation. How can we make that happen?
- the_other 6y agoStop giving Amazon money.
- andrepd 6y agoAlready doing that. Unfortunately it's not so simple. We can't expect The Market to solve everything.
- the_other 6y agoI'm not a free market capitalist, so I'm surprised I"m about to write this... but we should try to get The Market to solve this. If those of us who're privacy conscious stopped paying Amazon money, we could use that money to create/buy privacy-focused alternatives. I'm not talking about Amazon the shop (although that's a good avenue of attack too), I'm talking about AWS. Stop using AWS. Loudly take your money to another cloud supplier. Amazon competes on volume, so remove the volume. Leave them with warehouses of redundant servers until they have to sell them off. And then buy one.
- noncoml 6y agoStop giving Amazon money. Don’t buy stuff from eBay. Don’t use Google, Gmail, Chrome. Don’t give Comcast your business. Don’t use Windows. Avoid Apple and their predatory App Store fees. Don’t buy stuff from Walmart. Don’t give Sony your money. And the list goes on.. You see where I am going? This will never work. David cannot win over Goliath every single time. That’s why we need another giant, the government, to fight for us. But we don’t want the government to interfere with capitalism, do we? We want to have our pie and eat it too.
- andrepd 6y agoUnrestrained capitalism is not compatible with freedom, it's as simple as that. Without hyperbole, Amazon/Google/etc have more power than most countries on earth. This power is almost completely unaccountable to democratic control. Is this really what we want?
- bob1029 6y agoNot sure about the fun part. Nothing about what Amazon is doing is fun for me anymore. I've got a drawer full of unused echos, chromecasts, etc. I haven't had a prime subscription for over 2 years now because every time I order something its a 50/50 that I will get a shitty ripoff from China. I am desperately looking to get off of their cloud offerings too. I wish more would recognize the convenience of Amazon for the dystopia that it truly is and then act with their wallets. Shopping at 3 different online retailers vs 1 isn't that much of an added inconvenience, and I personally find that when you order direct from the manufacturer (when possible) that your success rate on getting high quality, non-fake stuff nears 100%. AWS is a harder sell because of how wide the feature set is, but there are options for any scale. This isn't even scratching the surface on how they treat many of their employees. Who is working in an amazon warehouse right now and actually having a good time of it? Amazon could easily automate away many jobs they never wanted in the first place, but sacrificing lower-skilled humans do the last mile of messy pick & place turns out to be more friendly to margins.
- ctvo 6y agoI agree that Amazon isn't good for competition, and some of their business practices are troubling. I'm just tired of seeing some of the points you made pop up in every Amazon topic. > I haven't had a prime subscription for over 2 years now because every time I order something its a 50/50 that I will get a shitty ripoff from China. Were you ordering expensive sneakers and purses regularly? You'd think if this was the experience of even a minor fraction of their customers (beyond the HN commenters who claim this is wide spread in every Amazon topic), they wouldn't be breaking record sales every quarter. > This isn't even scratching the surface on how they treat many of their employees. Who is working in an amazon warehouse right now and actually having a good time of it? Who is doing manual labor of any form and having a good time of it? Amazon to their credit gave a minimum wage of 15 USD to these workers, often ahead of the states they're located in, and the workers get full health care and benefits. I'm not saying they can't be paid more or shouldn't be paid more, but I'm going to acknowledge their agency. Over 800k of them picked Amazon over say Walmart or Costco or some other warehouse job. > Amazon could easily automate away many jobs they never wanted in the first place, but sacrificing lower-skilled humans do the last mile of messy pick & place turns out to be more friendly to margins. Companies hire people to do work if it's profitable is the essence of this objection? There are complex systems that lead people to accepting these jobs -- America's failing education system, the lack of upward mobility and opportunity for many citizens, lack of focus on trade / manufacturing jobs in school, etc.. You take the easy route of blaming a corporation doing corporation things.
- freedomben 6y agoAmazon has been aggressively giving Echos away, surely at a loss. Is the grand strategy becoming apparent? The data alone will more than pay for it? My son got a free Echo and plugged it in in my house. When I saw it I was a little bugged but played around with it before putting it up. Now I fear my reaction will be more like, "Good God son, what have you done?"
- hnburnsy 6y agoDid you know that when adding the Echo, that Amazon stores your wifi password and then shares it among other devices? Will Sidewalk share around these passwords? Will Amazon share them with authorized third parties eventually? https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=201730860 https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=...