3 ms·
This is an interesting study, but there are so many influences that the article can't cover (probably due to its length) that it is a struggle to even draw ques
by roenxi 6y ago
This is an interesting study, but there are so many influences that the article can't cover (probably due to its length) that it is a struggle to even draw questions from it.
Everyone dies of something. The fact that US people die from things at a different ratio from other countries is interesting, relevant and uninformative on the topic of life expectancy. Picking out obesity - the fact that US obesity rate deaths are higher than the comparison countries doesn't tell us anything about life expectancy. Are they old fat people, or young fat people?
The article also can't rule out Simpson's paradox style effects. Hypothetically, say the US is just much better at bringing sickly babies into the world and nursing them on into their 70s it would have better care and worse life expectancy. I doubt that theory could even begin to explain what is going on here, but when comparing average statistics of huge and diverse populations effects like that can creep in very subtly. Statistics can be completely misleading if the treatment is short and only deals with part of the picture.
I'm feeling good about reading an article with lots of data, but this didn't do a good job of addressing the title matter.
- mr_luc 6y agoIt does a good job. It asks “why?” and then shows the causes, with numbers for each cause. Of course, there’s a deeper and more contentious kind of “why?” and it doesn’t go as deeply into that, other than to show some things that seem to correlate. But I think it is useful, because one can’t defensively say the US doesn’t have a problem compared to other rich countries. The Nordic countries save early, sickly babies and nurse them along just as much as the US does, for instance. The only thing I wish they’d have changed would be to indicate relative weight of the causes. Because obesity is an order of magnitude more lethal than homicide, for instance.
- jobigoud 6y ago> Are they old fat people, or young fat people? Do old obese people exist in the first place? What is the longevity record for an obese person?