10 ms·
I don't see any Apple apologists here in the comments. Who are you referring to? All I see is the fact that the Apple employee didn't initiate the bribe, the s
by crazygringo 6y ago
I don't see any Apple apologists here in the comments. Who are you referring to?
All I see is the fact that the Apple employee didn't initiate the bribe, the sheriff's office demanded it (extorted it) and the employee was put in the unfortunate immediate situation of either not getting their lawfully permitted license, or paying the bribe.
At the end of the day it's bribery so of course the employee deserves to be charged (and Apple if it approved it in any way), but the sheriff's office officials deserve much harsher punishment quite clearly.
- pmoriarty 6y ago"the employee was put in the unfortunate situation of either not getting their lawfully permitted license, or paying the bribe" ...or immediately going to the FBI.
- giantg2 6y agoThese permits in CA are may-issue, not shall-issue. The sheriff can deny for any reason (of course they aren't supposed to ask for a bribe).
- wolco2 6y agoWhy give police the power to decide these permits? Power corrupts
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoAgreed, this makes 0 sense to me. There should be an explicit list of reasons for which police should be able to deny these permits, and the police should have to show their evidence as to why they believe one of these reasons apply.
- Spooky23 6y agoThe problem with this is pretty obvious. When some scumbag like a pimp or similar without a conviction goes for a permit, you end up in a situation where the police are enabling certain types of undesirable behavior. IMO, discretion for this sort of thing should be with a judge, not a cop.
- giantg2 6y agoHow are they enabling undesirable behavior? Wouldn't the behavior occur anyways? Most people would be stupid to create a paper trail for themselves if they plan to use a weapon in a crime. Hence the reason close to 50% of guns recovered from a crime were stolen. How would a judge or a cop have any impact on a situation without a conviction? They wouldn't know any better without additional data.
- tengbretson 6y agoDenying permits may not be as effective at thwarting career criminals as you may think.
- makomk 6y agoUsual think of the children stuff. Basically, someone who shouldn't have a permit could hypothetically get one and then go on a killing spree, so we need to give police and sheriffs full powers to deny them. If I remember rightly, one of the main things the American gun control movement has been campaigning for is the removal of shall-issue policies which require police and sheriffs to issue permits like these unless they have a specific legally-defined reason not to, and replacing them with the kind of may-issue policies that allow arbitrary denials and this sort of corruption - and they're quite happy to point at dead kids and accuse anyone who gets in their way of supporting child murder to achieve this.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago>Why give police the power to decide these permits? So that they can make an end run around the 14th amendment, deny all the blacks, deny all the mexicans, deny all the chinese while the state looks the other way, or at least that's what the tacit understanding was ~70yr ago when people were voting for politicians who supported these policies.
- yowzadave 6y agoExactly—this is the same reason cops have discretion over who they fine for traffic violations vs. who they let off with a warning: so that the "right" people don't end up having to pay fines.
- o-__-o 6y agoHaving been recently subjected to an invalid traffic violation, it seems discretion means they go after the easy target that will most likely pay (someone caught dead to rights, or looks like they don’t have time or money to fight the case). I watched who the cop pulled over after me and every person was someone who had the means and likelihood to pay the fine rather than fight what was a bogus trap (based on the perceived value of their cars; recent model year, none less than 40k) I simply went to court and the officer never showed up, but I didn’t see any of the other people pulled over that day in court either (while reasons could explain this away I find it hard to believe of the 7 people I observed none of them paid the fine or took a driving course from the comfort of their own home to be done with it)
- josefx 6y ago> (of course they aren't supposed to ask for a bribe) Oh they just weren't "supposed" to ask for bribes. Nothing illegal here, just a honest guy going above and beyond on his job to keep America safe.
- nl 6y agoSoliciting bribes is explicitly against the law, and that has nothing to do with "may" vs "shall" issue.
- giantg2 6y agoPlease explain how this same scenario would work under a shall-issue scheme? Edit: Since you wouldn't respond... denying a permit under a shall-issue scheme would require proof that they didn't meet the statutory requirements instead of providing the issuer with the ability to hide their reason behind an arbitrary excuse.
- nl 6y ago> Since you wouldn't respond I didn't respond because I was asleep (??) > Please explain how this same scenario would work under a shall-issue scheme? It doesn't matter: Soliciting bribes is against the law. Everything else is just arguments about if a particular arrangement makes bribery more or less likely.
- kennywinker 6y agoDeniability. i.e. the sheriff can say the permit wasn’t issued because its at their discretion, not because someone didn’t pay a bribe. That said, even with a "shall" situation there are hoops to jump thru that can be used to set this same kinda situation up.
- throwawaygh 6y agoMay-issue doesn't legalize bribery. See: the indictment.
- giantg2 6y agoYeah, I'm not saying it makes it right. I'm saying it makes it possible.
- sigzero 6y agoSoooo extremely poor judgement?
- nl 6y agothe employee was put in the unfortunate immediate situation of either not getting their lawfully permitted license, or paying the bribe He was the chief security officer of the biggest company in the world. He absolutely had many other options. I don't see any Apple apologists here in the comments. Who are you referring to? You do realize that your comment here is exactly what "apologists" means, right?
- randallsquared 6y ago> He absolutely had many other options. The only legal option I can see is "move out of CA", which probably means get another job. Which, you know, people sometimes do if they feel strongly about the right to carry, but likely wasn't in his set of considered options. > He was the chief security officer of the biggest company in the world. Oh, you're suggesting he use Apple to, uh, "lean on" the sheriff? That seems much worse. One might even hope that was not one of his possible options, even as CSO...
- cgriswald 6y ago> The only legal option I can see is "move out of CA", which probably means get another job. Which, you know, people sometimes do if they feel strongly about the right to carry, but likely wasn't in his set of considered options. You didn't consider "report it to the DA, state police, or FBI" as an option? > Oh, you're suggesting he use Apple to, uh, "lean on" the sheriff? That seems much worse. One might even hope that was not one of his possible options, even as CSO... I absolutely did not read this in the GP's post. Whether it is what he meant or not, it's an ungenerous take. A more generous take is that with the resources available to him, reporting a bribe solicitation to the appropriate authorities is much less risky than it would be for (say) a random citizen of San Jose.
- randallsquared 6y agoI think both of your responses can be cleared up by noting that @nl was responding to, and quoted: > the employee was put in the unfortunate immediate situation of either not getting their lawfully permitted license, or paying the bribe In this context, "options" mean "options to fulfill the CCW licensing goal". Reporting it to the DA, state police, the FBI, or anyone else wouldn't further the CCW licensing goal (though it might fulfill others, and I'm certainly not arguing against it!). Similarly, saying he had other options (for "getting their lawfully permitted license") because he was the CSO of the biggest company in the world may well have other meanings I didn't catch, but reporting bribe solicitations is not one, unless the dialogue had already veered from it's previous aim.
- diebeforei485 6y agoThere are two categories of bribes. If you bribe someone to get something that you're not qualified for, that is clearly wrong on the part of both the applicant and the permit approver. But if you're being denied something you should get, unless you bribe them, I am more sympathetic to the applicant.