3 ms·
You're missing that they picked "robbery", excluding the much larger "burglary" and "shoplifting" and "fraud" categories. They then say "Much bigger problem th
by mlyle 6y ago
You're missing that they picked "robbery", excluding the much larger "burglary" and "shoplifting" and "fraud" categories. They then say "Much bigger problem than other forms of theft"... Implying "Much bigger problem than [all] other forms of theft" instead of "Much bigger problem than [some] other forms of theft".
And, if you're going to go with broadly estimated (and somewhat questionable) numbers, then surely you need to consider the ~$50B estimated lost to retail theft each year. Don't just compare $933 million proven lost to wage theft to the over-precise $340,850,358 aggregated from some robbery reports (really, 9 sig figs?) and call it "other theft".
Not to mention that that $933M "recovered" includes many cases of trebled damages...
Wage theft is important. But make an honest case.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI gave you the FBI's own burglary numbers. You have issues with those?
- mlyle 6y agoIt's also a bit disingenuous to cherry-pick one point without responding to the overall statement. But, sure, I do have an issue with those. Just like you don't think every dollar of wage theft is paid as damages, one might also reasonably believe that not every dollar of burglary losses is reported and captured in those aggregate numbers.
- dredmorbius 6y agoWhich number would you believe to be more consistently underreported? By how much? On what basis? What repercussions might the reporter of property theft face? Of wage theft?
- mlyle 6y agoIf you want to talk, prove your good faith by responding to my overall points above instead of finding smaller and smaller points to niggle with and ask leading questions about. Seriously, the loaded/dishonest article and your antagonistic and pseudo-dishonest mode of argument has done more to erode how seriously I will take arguments in this area than to deepen my concern. If this is your objective, keep going down this path. On the other hand, it's stupid: wage theft is a severe enough concern, deserving of additional advocacy, that it can be done honestly without these kinds of questionable argument tactics.
- dredmorbius 6y agoI'll choose my ground, thanks.
- mlyle 6y agoOK. If your ground is "I think I can slightly defend the estimate of burglary numbers reported to 9 sig figs and not talk about any of the other concerns about the article...," then you may consider me less convinced of the truthfulness of advocates and arguments about wage theft than when you began. Nuance is important; people who advocate for one side or the other, honesty be damned, almost never help the situation.
- dredmorbius 6y agoNot gratuitously misrepresenting others' views counts for something as well, but thanks.
- mlyle 6y agoI'm not attempting to represent anything about your views, but instead your argument tactics. The history is straight above, and I believe my representation of it is accurate. You're free to "fix it" by addressing the broader points, but as long as you don't, this stands.