6 ms·
Let me state up front that I'm an RMS fanboy. I love the guy and think he's dead-on prophetic about 95% of the time. That said, RMS seems to demonstrate a poor
by kstrauser 6y ago
Let me state up front that I'm an RMS fanboy. I love the guy and think he's dead-on prophetic about 95% of the time.
That said, RMS seems to demonstrate a poor understanding of how his messages will be received. Time after time, he's said things that are perfectly reasonable and defensible when you actually think them through, but on the surface sound awful and turn people away. A big component of communication is tailoring your message so that it will be heard, and I just don't think he's very good at that. In political terms, he's great at speaking to his base but not so hot at converting non-believers.
Let me invent a purely fictional example of something he did not say. Suppose you open an article with "Hitler wasn't completely bad." That's defensible! By all accounts he loved his pets, and it seems like he was nice to his officers' kids. But really, that doesn't matter: that opening sentence has lost an enormous part of the audience, even if the rest of the article built a case that would make sense to people who read the whole thing. Most ordinary people would see that and say "that's crap and I have no desire to hear what else this person has to say", and that's perfectly understandable because most authors who open that way are going to end up saying something absolutely despicable.
Well, when RMS wants to say things implying that maybe pedophilia isn't always bad and perhaps it gets a bad rap because some parents aren't OK with their kids growing up, he needs to be exceedingly careful how he phrases every word of it because he's commenting on an extremely charged subject. And yet, he doesn't. It doesn't matter whether you have a good point to raise if your wording makes most people shut down and reject your idea immediately.
Again, I dig RMS. He's an incredibly smart guy who has some brilliant ideas. But wow, I sure wouldn't want him defending me in front of a jury. I don't think he's a pedophile, but I absolutely see how easy he made it for some people to claim that.
- Fice 6y agoRMS probably has an autism spectrum disorder.
- kstrauser 6y agoThat seems very likely to me, and would explain this seeming blind spot in his otherwise brilliant career.
- Fice 6y agoYes, and it's painful to see him being harassed for it by Wingo and others.
- kstrauser 6y agoAlright, I'm not a doctor, and I certainly not Stallman's doctor. I think it's likely that he has Asperger's based solely on comparing his actions and words with those of my friends who've been diagnosed with Aspergers', but I don't actually know that he does. With that out of the way, I haven't heard of anyone harassing him for having Asperger's. However, I think it's possible that he has it and that it has led him to saying things in untactful ways, and it's those things he's said that irk people. I can empathize with people who wouldn't want someone who says those things to represent an organization that they work with, regardless of what caused the person to say them.
- Fice 6y ago> I haven't heard of anyone harassing him for having Asperger's I may have worded this badly (not a native speaker, it takes a lot of time for me to find the right words and formulate my thoughts in English), but what I meant is that they are using Stallman's peculiarities (which are likely ASD-related) against him to destroy his character. See the message I linked earlier where Wingo refers to multiple posts on stallman.org suggesting his very biased interpretation of their meanings and of Stallman's behavior. And it could be painful for RMS: https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/guix-devel/2019-10/msg00418.html https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/guix-devel/2019-10/msg004... > I can empathize with people who wouldn't want someone who says those things to represent an organization that they work with, regardless of what caused the person to say them. But GNU is Stallman's project (and it is not an organization), he started it. They could just leave and continue working on Guix independently. Some projects join GNU, some leave, no one is forced to work under Stallman's leadership. But it appears to me that Guix maintainers feel so attached to the GNU identity, that they want to hijack it instead.
- nsajko 6y agoI agree with you, but I'd wager there was an alternative way to get rid of Stallman that would be both kinder and less harmful to GNU and FSF causes.
- kstrauser 6y agoYeah, that too seems likely. I'm not going to weigh in much on that because I wasn't there and don't have an in-depth understand over everything that happened, but it does seem like there might've been a better way to handle that. That said, the parent comment made it sound like it was unreasonable to take RMS's comments as meaning he was pro-pedophilia. And while I think I understand what he was trying to say, I can completely understand how reasonable people could interpret his words in a very bad way. That's the part I was really replying to, not how his dismissal was handled.
- davexunit 6y agoAnyone that's been close to the FSF knows that RMS has been burning good will for a very long time.
- gypsyharlot 6y agoIncredibly well put. Hats off to you sir. I don't think it's simply the unwillingness to think things though that make people attack him though. I think that halfway through writing their heated response, people realize their mistake. However, in today's climate, a lot of people are frothing at the mouth in anticipation of finally having found "a nazi", "a pedo" etc. So much that they see them everywhere.
- kstrauser 6y agoI don’t think it’s fair to chalk it up to “unwillingness to think things through”, though, and that’s my point. RMS doesn’t seem to me to fully appreciate the emotional landlines in some of the subjects he discusses. When you’re talking about software licensing there’s some wiggle room, but when the subject at hand is pedophilia, successful communication requires a degree of tact and nuance that I’ve not often seen him use. If you say something that 1% of the audience completely misunderstands, so be it. There’s always going to be some contrarians; haters gotta hate. But if the majority of the people have a different interpretation than you meant, then maybe the problem is in how you said it.
- _emacsomancer_ 6y agolandmines?
- kstrauser 6y agoYes. Some subjects are very tricky to discuss. I have an example earlier: you wouldn’t want to come across as a Hitler fan. You can discuss these things in public, but have to be exceedingly cautious to avoid people misunderstanding your position.
- _emacsomancer_ 6y agoI get that, I just meant that your text has a typo/autocorrect "landlines". (Apologies for my earlier laconic comment.)
- generalk 6y ago> Well, when RMS wants to say things implying that maybe > pedophilia isn't always bad and perhaps it gets a bad > rap because some parents aren't OK with their kids > growing up, he needs to be exceedingly careful how he > phrases every word of it because he's commenting on an > extremely charged subject. I hear your initial thought here, that talking about sensitive topics requires a sensitive hand, and RMS may lack one. And that's a valid point. For some topics. RMS has a history of defending or being actively supportive of pedophilia. This isn't just a matter of RMS being incapable of speaking about a sensitive topic with grace. If I start raising questions about how smart non-white folks really are and supposing that perhaps only white folks can be in leadership positions, multiple times in multiple venues -- well, folks are going to think I'm a white supremacist. And the harm I'll have done to the non-white folks in my community will have already been done. And no amount of (pp.) "carefully phrasing every word because it's an extremely charged subject" is going to change that.
- kstrauser 6y agoThat's fair. I haven't gone down the rabbit hole of reading everything he's said on the subject, and that was mainly in response to https://www.stallman.org/archives/2006-may-aug.html#05%20June%202006%20%28Dutch%20paedophiles%20form%20political%20party%29 https://www.stallman.org/archives/2006-may-aug.html#05%20Jun... . And I do get (and agree with) your analogy, too. For full disclosure, I think you can make a reasonable case for at least some of what he said in the link I just posted. For instance, an 18 year old having sex with their 17 year old partner doesn't automatically make it non-consensual, and lots of states have so-called "Romeo and Juliet" laws that agree. That's where the call for caution and careful phrasing come in: does he intend to mean it's OK for an 18 year old and a 17 year old to date (which I'd agree with), or for a 40 year old and a 15 year old (which I'd vehemently not agree with)? If what he meant was the former, I wish he would have clearly stated so and avoided the whole issue. If it really is the latter, then there's no way I'd attempt to defend that or be willing to consider the nuance (and more than I'd be willing to consider your analogy).
- cogman10 6y agoI'd probably state it this way. It's one thing if someone makes an offhand comment like "Oh yeah, Hitler wanted to be an artist!" You'd be like "Ok, interesting tidbit but whatever". It'd be a whole 'nother thing if one multiple different occasions you start talking about positive hilter attributes. I think it's reasonable for people to be pretty uncomfortable with the number of times and frequency that RMS seems to want to talk about underage sex. That certainly does not make him a pedophile. It is, however, pretty off putting. All this makes me feel very much like the Hans Reiser case. I was internet active at the time and remember all of his fans swear up and down about how innocent he was and how much he was a victim of the corrupt judicial system. Then that fateful day happened when Reiser was convicted and basically said "Ok, if you'll give me a lighter sentence I'll show you where the body is". Stallman did a lot of good for the opensource community, which makes him a hero to many. I think, however, it's unhealthy to try and justify his statements on pedophilia. It's ok to talk about the nuance of the laws (Certainly there are major issues with the way CP laws work. It's a bit crazy that teens are getting convicted of it over normal teen behavior). Stallman has been really icky here. He talks not about age difference but instead how "voluntary" the acts are. Trying to read in "Romeo and Juliet" scenarios when he himself doesn't even mention that is trying to paint a more rosy picture of what stallman wrote. All of this, frankly, can also be cleared up by clarifications from Stallman (which he's not published). He could say pretty much exactly what you've said here "When I was talking about X, this is what I meant". He's not done that and I think that's really telling. Maybe someone told him to STFU, but then again, he's not really been silent on his positions on sex throughout the years, so why start now?
- jangid 6y agoMoreover, no one, I mean /no one/ in this world is 100% perfect. I respect RMS as I respect Nelson Mandela or Gandhi. Think of anyone else from the past. RMS has done so much for the computing world. And I firmly believe that he isn't a pedophile. And he doesn't even support pedophilia. Just that he has uttered something, doesn't make him a criminal.