3 ms·
How the Biden Administration Can Free Americans from Student Debt
- fortran77 6y agoI get sad and angry when I read about this. All the missed opportunity because of the low-cost options I chose--the first two years at a community college, living at home, taking a public bus to school, and then doing the last two years at a low-cost private college, still commuting from home by bus while working 30 hours a week. I'll be damned if my tax dollars will pay for someone's Mills College Russian Literature degree, or someone's Stanford CS degree.
- eesmith 6y agoIs there any college debt that you would like your tax dollars to help repay? FWIW, Mills College doesn't seem to offer a degree in Russian Literature - https://catalog.mills.edu/undergraduate/majors-minors/ https://catalog.mills.edu/undergraduate/majors-minors/ and https://catalog.mills.edu/graduate/programs/creative-writing-literature/index.html https://catalog.mills.edu/graduate/programs/creative-writing... .
- fortran77 6y ago> Is there any college debt that you would like your tax dollars to help repay? No. And the "smarter" the student, the less sympathetic I am. Certainly, those who were in the 90%th percentile of SAT scores shouldn't get "forgiveness". They should have been smart enough to know how loans work.
- eesmith 6y agoIs there any debt that you would like your tax dollars to help repay? For example, do you want to get rid of bankruptcy? FWIW, Mills college doesn't require SAT or ACT scores.
- fortran77 6y agoNo. I don't want to get rid of bankruptcy. And for the most part, the cost of bankruptcy is baked into the cost of private loans.
- eesmith 6y agoStudent loans are not usually discharged by bankruptcy, which means students take on almost all risk and the cost for the lending agency is not "baked in". Your view seems to be that students in general (but especially smart student) should be more knowledgeable about risk than anyone taking out regular loans, and more knowledgeable than lending agencies. Which doesn't seem right. Surely your ire should also be directed towards the laws which encourage lending agencies to lend to obviously financially irresponsible teenagers, yes?
- BitwiseFool 6y agoIt's a long article, but it starts off talking about student debt and then increasingly moves towards the concept of cancelling many other kinds of debt. "In June, the Movement for Black Lives called for the absolution of student loans, medical debt, mortgage payments and rent". The article is still worth reading if you want to learn about the "Debt Jubilee" concept they are advocating. I've read many articles lately encouraging Joe Biden to unilaterally cancel student debt. This one says "any American President, should they desire, can make every penny of federal student debt disappear without consulting Congress". And it's clear most of these articles utilize a "Just Do It" kind of attitude that completely ignores the real and legitimate concerns many citizens like I have about the fairness and practicality of just forgiving (by making the government pay it instead) billions of dollars of voluntarily taken loans.
- fortran77 6y agoI was surprised that Astra Taylor didn't propose any solutions to the issue of preventing debt from simply piling up again. While I'm opposed to "canceling student debt," at least if we're going to do it, the Government needs to get out of the business of underwriting student loans. (And I certainly wouldn't mind more free and low-cost public Colleges.)
- BitwiseFool 6y agoAgreed. Any discussion of student loan debt cancellation is a non-starter if there isn't some proposed reform to address tuition costs. And, here's some food for thought, why not fund the forgiveness by taxing the universities and colleges who got the students into this mess? If you do a deep dive into university finances, their endowments are run like hedge funds and they're given extensive tax advantages.
- eesmith 6y agoWhy not get rid of the law that says tuition cannot be discharged during normal bankruptcy? The law that Biden helped pass - https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/dec/02/joe-biden-student-loan-debt-2005-act-2020 https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/dec/02/joe-biden-st... . https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_Abuse_Prevention_and_Consumer_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_Abuse_Prevention_an... - "BAPCPA amended § 523(a)(8) to broaden the types of educational ("student") loans that cannot be discharged in bankruptcy absent proof of "undue hardship." The nature of the lender is no longer relevant. Thus, even loans from "for-profit" or "non-governmental" entities are not dischargeable." Get rid of that law, then everyone deeply in debt can declare bankruptcy just like they would any other debt. Instead, lenders get to shift nearly all of the risk onto inexperienced teenagers and young adults.