10 ms·
How to Beat High Airfares
- mthoms 16y agoFor Canadians you can add government fees, regulations and lesser competition to the reasons this occurs. I once bought a ticket from Vancouver to London (UK) on Air Canada. Turns out I could have saved over $200 by flying via the same airline out of Seattle and connecting back in Vancouver to the exact same flight going on to London. Absurd.
- hugh3 16y agoSigh. Is there any reliable way to read nytimes articles without having an account, nowadays? I know you can usually do it by googling for a string of text from the article body, but without an extract from the article body there's no way to do that from here. And I'm assuming bugmenot no longer works in the post-paywall world, right? edit: Never mind, I found it by googling "how to beat high airfares" (which I thought wouldn't work). Turns out it's a Nate Silver article and quite interesting. The trick is that sometimes you can get to a hub airport more cheaply by booking a flight to some destination on the other side of the hub and then just getting off the plane... but of course the more people start using this trick (after it's published in the New York Times) the less useful it will be.
- r00fus 16y agoPerhaps I just don't read NYT, but I've never been blocked by the paywall. IIRC, if you use private browsing mode on most browsers, doesn't it defeat the paywall?
- prostoalex 16y agoPulling their RSS feeds to iGoogle seems to work, as they seem to be okay with referrer coming from www.google.com.
- VladRussian 16y agowhy "free market competition" sounds awkward as a mean to beat high airfares?
- georgieporgie 16y agoBook your itinerary as a set of two one-way flights, rather than as a round trip. Every time I have looked, a single one-way is more expensive than a round-trip between the same locations. Maybe I've just been 'lucky'. Edit: no, I'm just ignorant. Turns out domestic one-ways are more proportionally priced versus round-trips.
- DrJ 16y agothis is usually the case especially for international flights. You always end up trading flexibility for price.
- whakojacko 16y agoBut it's usually not the case for domestic US flights, which is what the article is about.
- georgieporgie 16y agoI just checked and you're right. One-way's were just about exactly 1/2 the price of a round trip. Shows how much domestic flying I do.
- gojomo 16y agoMy sense is that this has improved a lot recently, perhaps as a side-effect of trying to stay competitive in the travel-planning portals that can stitch together itineraries from multiple carriers. To wit: when switching in Kayak or Hipmunk from roundtrip to one-way and vice versa, the fares roughly or exactly match what you'd expect from decomposing/recomposing the parts. This was hardly ever the case in the past when using the airlines own portals, or Web 1.0 aggregators.
- alienfluid 16y agoIf your name is even remotely "exotic" (and mine seems to be), good luck checking in online - apparently one way tickets trigger some alarm in the depths of DHS.
- OstiaAntica 16y agoThis is unethical, basically he calls for jumping off of flights at layovers, which violates the terms of the ticket. There's even a security issue for the airlines, because they need to check if your bags are flying unaccompanied. Ironic that the NYT cracks down on people evading its paywall but is selling content on doing the same for air travel.
- r00fus 16y agoUnethical? Hardly. It's just against their specific rules (which only exist so they can gouge you on certain fares). Is it ethical for airlines to charge you more for A->B than a flight going from A->B->C?
- hugh3 16y agoIs it ethical for airlines to charge you more for A->B than a flight going from A->B->C? I don't know. Is it obviously unethical for them to do so? It's a sensible observation that a subset of X should be priced lower than X, but is it a moral one? Or, if the airline can make more money by charging more for A->B than A->C via B then, heck, it's their airplane, let 'em do what they want!
- rhizome 16y agoWhy are ethics and morality being discussed in the context of business? They have their pricing strategy, I have mine. It's my travel money, let me do what I want.
- ghshephard 16y agoNobody who is commenting here cares (or I strongly suspect they don't care) about the Airlines and people making money. It's the hundred or so people who are sitting on the airplane that are being inconvenienced - possibly missing their own connections later on, that our concerns are for. In general, airlines don't like to have people's checked luggage travel separately from them - and they don't know if the missing person checked luggage or not. So, they either have to do a count, get everyone in their correct seat, or delay the plane until the person gets back on. It's a cute hack, but an annoying one for everyone caught up in it.
- bradly 16y agoA couple days a found a round-trip flight from Montreal to Paris with a layover in New Jersey for $762. I tried to book the exact some flight, but starting in New Jersey, and it was over $1,400. This sort of this is crazy. Is anyone really surprised that airlines keep going bankrupt?
- whakojacko 16y agoIts not that crazy when you look into it more. Montreal to Paris is a low yielding route filled mostly with price-conscious tourists. New York to Paris has, as a percentage, substantially more business travel, which can sustain higher fares. For each route, the airline (presumably Continental) is trying to extract what it sees as the maximum price the market is willing to bear. As another example, Des Moines to Dallas as discussed in this article. American has the only non-stop flights between those two cities, and any connection is going to add at least 2 hours to your travel time (based on a quick glance). On the other hand, nobody has a nonstop between Des Moines and Los Angeles, so American has no competitive advantage there and cannot command a huge price premium.
- bradly 16y agoThat makes sense, but you could argue that there is a cost associated with upsetting and frustrating your customers that maybe the airlines aren't taking into consideration. Something can't be right with their models if they are going bankrupt again and again.
- ora600 16y agoIt is my understanding that airlines going bankrupt again and again is a direct result of their relationship with their pilot unions: http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines http://philip.greenspun.com/flying/unions-and-airlines
- whakojacko 16y agoThat, $100/barrel oil, and a mediocre economy.
- MatthewB 16y agoHow to beat high airfares...drive.
- rexreed 16y agoAt $4 a gallon, I might even challenge that. I recently calculated the cost of driving from DC to Boston, which is regularly a $240 or so ROUNDTRIP on many airlines. It takes 2 tanks of gas each way (about a 350 mile trip, 20 miles per gallon, 15 gallons per tank). The gas cost alone is close to $240. Even if you managed to burn 3 tanks instead of 4 during the trip, you're talking 45 gallons @ $4 a gallon, which is $180... and that's just gas. The tolls are around $20 each way. So, now you're up to $220. And what about food? Add another $20 or so. More maybe. So, now it costs the same to drive as it does to fly. And that's not even factoring in the cost of your TIME. It takes about 7 hours to drive from DC to Boston. It takes just over 1 hour by plane. Even factoring in the airport wait and transport, you're doing better... and you can do stuff while the plane flies while you can't do anything while you're driving. And then there's traffic. And the wear and tear on your vehicle. And this is for a relatively short trip. So, is driving really economically better? I did the math. I did the trip. It often doesn't make sense. Do the math yourself. Only for short trips does driving beat the cost of flying, and in which case, why you would be flying anyways? On the east coast, I just take the train or a bus. $20 gets you from DC to New York. Another $15 gets you to Boston. You can't beat THAT. So, the cost of gas has completely changed the economics and argument of drive vs. fly. Flying is almost always going to be cheaper, if you can book your flight early enough to get the discounted fares.
- ecuzzillo 16y agoI don't disagree, but to be fair about the time, there's at least an hour in the DC airport and at least half an hour in the Boston airport, and that's assuming there are no delays on either tarmac due to planes being in the way of your gate or your plane needing something inspected or replaced. So it's more like 2.5-3 hours vs. 7 hours. Still probably worth the flight, depending on how much you like driving, but I think most people think only about the actual flying time, rather than the total time spent dealing with the airport process.
- 16y ago
- Osiris 16y agoI have a co-worker that does this on a fairly regular basis even for business travel. He's usually able to save up to 50% off the cost of a ticket.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- sp_ 16y agoJust tried it myself with SEA to MSP (hopping off on a SEA->MSP->DFW route) on July 15th. Direct flight is $230, hop-off route is $150 on exactly the same Delta plane. Now the thing is, if I book SEA->MSP->DFW for Friday and MSP->SEA for Sunday I don't see how Delta could not notice this and block me from flying because of abusing this system. Actually, I have done something like this before. When I moved from Europe to the US I booked a return ticket because it was 500 Euro cheaper than going one way, knowing fully well that I would never be on that return flight.
- tptacek 16y agoThis is really just a variant of the back-to-back ticket trick, which the airlines already have some countermeasures for. In particular: when you don't get on the MSP->DFW leg, any other ticket you had on the same itinerary gets cancelled. When you show up for your 1W MSP->SEA, they may ask you (annoyed) questions. I used to do back-to-backs (I had to fly DTW->LGA a lot) and they did hassle me about it. You obviously will have trouble checking baggage doing this, too.
- fuscata 16y agoBe sure to include the cost of the extra time it takes to accomplish this when you calculate your savings.
- strooltz 16y agoI just tried the following route - EWR->DES->SFO on 6/10 and returning on 6/18 via the same route back. The price each way was ~$420 (which included 2 layovers). I priced out EWR->SFO and United/Continental had a direct flight for $369. Maybe I'm the aberration but I think NYT should have done a few more case studies before publishing their results.
- RyanGWU82 16y agoI think you got it backwards. The trick works when you're ending your trip in a hub -- you take the first leg, but skip the connection. So, for example, say you're trying to fly to Chicago (ORD). The article's point is that it may be cheaper to buy an EWR-ORD-STL ticket, because there's actually more price competition when flying to St. Louis.
- travelemployee 16y agoI worked for airlines and one of the big 3 for many years. They have complex algorithms that try to determine the lowest price. They're competitive, and want to be the cheapest they can. They're not trying to "hide" any prices. Doing what the author says will get you banned from the airline. If you don't fly the itinerary listed, they will tear it up in front of your face as it's in the terms and conditions. My point: there's no real secret - the sites like Kayak and any ITA-based search product are pretty much doing so many creative things to minimize the price that it's rare to find an exception without cheating. Finally, the pricing is crazy, but being in the tornado there's a method to the madness.
- rinkjustice 16y agoWhat's wrong with paying pilots and airline workers a decent wage? Beating high costs of some consumer goods and services is reasonable, but must we 'nickel and dime' trained professionals who safely transport your loved ones? Pretty screwed up priorities if you ask me.
- flyosity 16y agoYou do realize that by doing this technique you're not physically taking money out of airline pilots' wallets, right? Airlines already screw over pilots (WSJ says average starting salary for a commercial airline pilot is ~$30k) so I don't think this technique will really impact wages of airline employees either way.
- Jach 16y agoThe second way to beat high airfares: buy early. I'm going on a trip next week. About three weeks ago a round trip 2-hour flight trip was $250, a week later it was $350, but I found a 6-hour round-trip flight (that overshoots my destination, has me wait a while, then backtracks) for $256.
- vandalizeit 16y agoCounter example: my next flight. I check fares one month ago - $599. Two weeks ago - $549. Yesterday - $499. Tulsa to DC.
- flyosity 16y agoYup, there's not a distinct correlation between buying early and getting the best price. Sometimes the best price doesn't show up until a week before the departure. Sometimes the best price is attained when purchasing months prior to departure. The only thing you can bet on is that the cheapest fares are usually attained when you fly out on a Wednesday. Monday flights are more expensive as it's typically for business travelers, and Friday/Saturday flights are expensive as well because of vacationers. If you can fly to your destination on a Wednesday instead of a few days later, you'll usually save a bunch of money. Re: when to purchase a ticket, Farecast (now owned by Bing) was the best predictor I've seen.
- vivekian 16y agoI have used this strategy twice, to get off at ORD while buying tickets till MKE. Both times I have approached airlines representatives to let them know that I will not be taking the last leg to save other passengers the inconvenience of waiting. Both times I have been told politely that I will be considered a no-show and it doesn't matter and they refuse to notify the boarding gate.
- AlexC04 16y agoFunny thing, my Father used to own a travel agency. This is exactly the sort of thing that travel agents were paid to know AND search for. Before the rise of all the internet discount travel sites, travel agents earned their keep by doing all this for you. For better or for worse, that world changed over time. People would come into the agency, sit down for 1 to 2 hours to gather advice and information... then when it came time to book, they'd say somethign to the effect of "well I can book it myself online and save 15%". (Then he'd lose the sale). That or they'd come in, grab one of his travel brochures then book online. I'm not trying to bemoan anything here. He did well with the agency for a number of years and sold out to someone at the end who picked up the 'business travel' (where agents still earn commissions for doing it all for you). Just trying to shed a bit of light on the story from my real life observation of the travel industry. Anyways, kinda interesting way the world has changed. (edit, oh ... I don't think his travel agents ever advised hopping off mid-journey, but then I think they knew how to book it so you'd not have to do that.)