3 ms·
> WW2 being a "regression to the mean" so to speak with regards to brutalizing civilians It wasn't, though. The level, and degree of planning, of genocide in c
by rsynnott 6y ago
> WW2 being a "regression to the mean" so to speak with regards to brutalizing civilians
It wasn't, though. The level, and degree of planning, of genocide in conquered territories was historically _very_ unusual. Medieval armies, say, were not generally followed by specialist murder units. Even in, say, the Reconquista, there was no real equivalent of the Einsatzgruppen, nevermind what came after occupation.
This isn't to say previous wars were clean; lots and lots of civilians died, but there was rarely an organ of the military whose explicit purpose was in massacring civilians until WW2.
I think there's a reasonable case that the Nazi military really did have a special, virtually unique brand of evil.
- ThrowawayR2 6y ago> "Medieval armies, say, were not generally followed by specialist murder units." Wasn't sacking of cities in antiquity and medieval times basically looting of all valuables and either the killing or enslavement of the population, mixed in with considerable brutalization during the process? The entire besieging army took part in that. > "I think there's a reasonable case that the Nazi military really did have a special, virtually unique brand of evil." Nope, I'd say the Imperial Japanese Army had them beat on that score easily: they spared themselves the need for specialized units by simply having the entire military commit atrocities. Much larger scale than the Nazis too.