5 ms·
>Expensive, inaccessible except to the rich I don’t think the data bears this out exactly. US healthcare tends to optimize for access and quality to the detrim
by bumby 6y ago
>Expensive, inaccessible except to the rich
I don’t think the data bears this out exactly. US healthcare tends to optimize for access and quality to the detriment to cost. As the saying goes: access, quality, or cost... you only get to choose two.
The US tends to measure better than any comparable country of its size on those two metrics (and quite poorly on cost...but some of that is because the US funds about 50% of worldwide medical R&D)
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0140673617308188 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S014067361...
Edit: U.S. percentage of worldwide R&D has been waning and, while still the largest contributor, is now a little over 40%
https://data.oecd.org/rd/gross-domestic-spending-on-r-d.htm https://data.oecd.org/rd/gross-domestic-spending-on-r-d.htm
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- coliveira 6y agoThe US healthcare is good only when considering those who can pay to access it. But since large swathes of the US population cannot afford to have access (expensive insurance costs, even with Obamacare support), this becomes a mute point. If that is the metric, then even Brazil (and many other 3rd word countries) also has good medical care, because it works for the small percent of the population with money to access it. And in fact this is one of the big differentiators between 1st world and 3rd world countries: if the population has access to quality services, in health care or other important areas like education and sanitation. The US seems to be designing its systems to become a big 3rd world country.
- bumby 6y agoYour points are baked into the data that I linked. The metric within is "HAQ Index" which stands for "Healthcare Access and Quality". I.e., access is part of the measure. In the US everybody has access, which is part of the problem that drives costs higher. E.g., if you don't have insurance you can walk into an emergency room and get treated even if it's not an emergent situation. If you don't have insurance, there is a higher risk you won't pay. That cost then gets spread to others who do.
- coliveira 6y agoYou probably don't know how the US system works. The only access that is guaranteed by law is to emergency services. If you don't have a paid insurance (through your employer or yourself), then you cannot access preventive care or otherwise normal medical consultation. Millions of people in the US don't have access. For example, if someone needs to treat cancer, it doesn't make any good to go to an emergency unit: they will discharge the patient as it is not an emergency situation.
- bumby 6y ago>if someone needs to treat cancer, it doesn't make any good to go to an emergency unit That's because the ER is meant to stabilize a patient, not cure chronic disease. Which is to my point: people will forgo preventative medicine until their condition deteriorates and they need to be stabilized in an ER. People get their non-emergent conditions treated all the time in American emergency rooms. E.g., if I have diabetes, an ER will not put me on a long-term treatment plan. But if I ignore my disease until I start having hypoglycemic symptoms an ER will treat me until I am stabilized enough to be released. Is this the best system? Absolutely not, but it's much different than saying "only the rich have access to healthcare". FWIW, I used to work in healthcare, including redesigning ER processes
- throwaway201103 6y agoCurious, in your healthcare experience, what would you estimate is the percentage of people who do have good insurance, but don't get preventative care by choice? E.g. for myself, I have good insurance, but I don't have a "primary care doctor." I don't go to the doctor unless I'm injured or sick. And I don't mean a sniffle or cough, I mean sick as in I have felt awful for several days.
- bumby 6y agoI don't think I have a good representative sample because facilities I worked for were a specific sub-population that would probably have a very high percentage that fall into the category of "no need for healthcare until something is broken or bleeding profusely" With that said, it seems to be quite a bit and skewing higher for males than females.
- disabled 6y ago> The US healthcare is good only when considering those who can pay to access it. False: The third leading cause of death in the US is believed to be preventable medical errors. You can go to the best institutions in the US to get care, along with seeing the very best doctors, but you cannot evade a statistic like that, even if you are in the 1%. See: https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/05/03/476636183/death-certificates-undercount-toll-of-medical-errors https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/05/03/4766361... Also, this article: U.S. life expectancy will soon be on par with Mexico’s and the Czech Republic’s: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2017/02/21/us-life-expectancy-will-soon-be-on-par-with-mexicos-and-croatias/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2017/0... Also this: 42% of new cancer patients lose all of their life savings in two years because of treatment. The average amount a cancer patient lost was $92,098.: https://www.insider.com/half-cancer-patients-lose-their-entire-life-savings-2018-10 https://www.insider.com/half-cancer-patients-lose-their-enti... The truth is that you can be in the top 1%, sitting on a mountain of cash, and still lose an unfathomable amount of money, even while insured, if you have cancer or a rare disease. Both of which are actually common. It is not the doctors who are the problem here with respect to the medical errors: it’s the healthcare system. A good read on what’s wrong with the system is the short book Our Malady by Timothy Snyder. If you want to stay alive long term, you may want to consult HealthData.org which analyzes each country’s healthcare systems in depth along with outcomes. The group is world renowned. Ironically, it is also the IMHE group that does the coronavirus statistics that everyone consults. Personally, I am an American culturally, but I became an EU citizen (Croatia) over the US healthcare system. I never plan on working in the US. I do select the country I am working in now due to healthcare.