3 ms·
All of these IoT products mentioned that work with some but not all systems (and mainly work with their own) really have no interest in selling hardware; they w
by Cthulhu_ 6y ago
All of these IoT products mentioned that work with some but not all systems (and mainly work with their own) really have no interest in selling hardware; they want you to get a subscription, they want buy-in with more products that work on their network, because each one adds more loyalty.
It's a very cynical industry, one intent on selling subscriptions with minimal cost on their side.
I mean I got a smart thermostat a few years ago because I was living alone and it turning off when I left the house was pretty smart, but it was a 25 / year subscription, my girlfriend moved in, and we're home all the time now. I don't have the subscription anymore, so now it's "just" a very complicated thermostat that probably depends on the company's server just to turn my heat on.
The one bonus function it does have is a chart of temperature and humidity, so I can for example check how effective heat-limiting measures are vs last year.
- baybal2 6y agoIndeed, I call this model "Product as a Service" You buy a house, but the seller still demands you to pay rent to live in it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23486325 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23486325
- jve 6y agoJust yesterday I "launched" my fist Sonoff S20 power outlet.... before purchasing, hooked up I can eventually control it from home assistant if I burn tasmota firmware on that device. I stumbled upon SonoffLAN https://github.com/AlexxIT/SonoffLAN https://github.com/AlexxIT/SonoffLAN which I'm gonna try first. However there is a comment on github that gets me thinking: > Local only mode (manual get devicekey) > I don’t understand who needs it, but you never know. You must manually get devicekey for each device. Only works with devices on 3rd firmware. I mean, he is thinking: why non-cloud access. While I'm thinking - having a power outlet depend on some 3rd party service, having internet access, having some app on android, which asks for location access to setup wifi and having account on manufacturer site just to control power outlet......... I just cannot wrap it in my head and glad I did some googling before buying.