4 ms·
There is a cost to that though, the reality is Windows has become rather bloated because MS can't let anything go. It doesn't help that they have never been abl
by tonyedgecombe 6y ago
There is a cost to that though, the reality is Windows has become rather bloated because MS can't let anything go. It doesn't help that they have never been able to say no to anything and everything getting included.
- eganist 6y ago> because MS can't let anything go. To be clear, this isn't really up to them. It's what market forces have dictated. Tons of old corp apps exist all over the place that necessitate this level of backwards compatibility.
- blackrock 6y agoOne crazy thing I read about, was of a bug from some 3rd party company’s application. On some Windows update, the application no longer worked. But since Microsoft wanted to ensure a seamless transition during upgrades, they changed their OS code to perpetuate the bug from that application, to allow it to continue working. Kudos to them for doing so.
- watermelon0 6y agoThat's nice of them, but it does needlessly bloat OS code, specification, and tests. In the long run, clear specification and implementation is a lot more desirable, than needing to support various hacks and workarounds for 3rd party software.
- danaris 6y agoIt's totally up to them. If Microsoft wanted to, they could say tomorrow that Windows 11 will no longer maintain backwards compatibility with X, Y, and Z ancient technologies. This would anger some of their corporate customers. Possibly even enough that they could get together and fund some kind of Windows Legacy effort. But realistically, if Microsoft decided to stop being backwards-compatible, where are their customers who are stuck with ancient Windows software going to go? Macs? Linux? Neither of those will have the kind of guarantees their purchasing departments require for compatibility. Maybe, just maybe, if Microsoft stopped supporting everything ever written for one of their OSes, some of the godawful legacy cruft would actually have to be replaced by new software, and some poor corporate IT people's lives would improve immensely...
- pjmlp 6y agoThey tried that with WinRT, and despite many of us actually liking those efforts, it failed as those customers did not accepted it, now there is Project Reunion to unroll the path taken since Windows 8 introduction.
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> this isn't really up to them. It's what market forces have dictated. This is a symmetric process. Microsoft chose its marker and set its customers’ expectations. That influences both who buys its products and how they structure their own dependencies.
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThat said, they are moving in a direction; they've stopped trying to make IE work in favor of a rewrite, keeping IE around for older apps. Honestly wouldn't be surprised - actually I AM surprised this isn't a thing yet - that they would run older Windows apps in a VM / emulator. Actually they may already do this but I'm just not aware of it. One thing they have been doing is turn Windows into an evergreen operating system (together with Edge), so that few people will still be running older versions of their operating system.
- neogodless 6y agoIn Windows 7, they had "XP Mode" which was just a VM for running Windows XP. (I do not recall if it was available in Vista - they did not include it in Windows 10.) https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=8002 https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=800... > It uses virtualization technology such as Windows Virtual PC to provide a Virtual Windows XP environment for Windows 7.
- vagrantJin 6y ago> ..rather bloated because MS can't let anything go. Ah. This comment seems off the cuff and not well thought out. I think you may be underestimating the scope and scale at which Windows OS operates[0]. Outside of cool techie agencies and SV type companies, the default OS for any organization from churches to charities to governments to schools, the world over, is Windows. MacOS may be sleek and shiny apex predator but our world would grind to a halt, an absolute standstill if WindowsOS suddenly got wiped. It's not a whale. It's the ocean itself. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_systems https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Usage_share_of_operating_sys...
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoAh. This comment seems off the cuff and not well thought out. I know how pervasive Windows is, I've made my living writing software for it for the last twenty five years. That is why I know that it is a bloated and over complicated mess. The reality for most corporates is the only software they want on their desktops is Office and a web browser. This has been the case for a long time. There are laggards of course but taking too much notice of them has crippled the system.
- thekyle 6y agoI really applaud Microsoft for their backwards compatibility efforts and I'm sure organizations love it. But I personally don't need to run Windows software from 20 years ago. For me, there is no reason to use Windows over any of the more modern lean and mean operating systems available, and I know a ton of blue collar workers in the U.S. who only have a smartphone and maybe a tablet. Windows is just not very easy to use by 2020 standards because of all its baggage and consumers care a lot more about that kinda thing compared to organizations. Most of Microsofts attempts to modernize (Microsoft Store, UWP, sandboxing, etc.) seem to have stalled or failed unfortunately. Honestly, at this point it might make more sense for Microsoft to just milk Windows for as long as possible while minimizing costs and investing in their other businesses (like Azure). Trying to modernize Windows would be like trying to modernize Edge to be competitive with Chrome.