3 ms·
The problems with this are more societal ones than technical or practical: It is impossible, for example, to install most popular apps for macOS without identif
by sneak 6y ago
The problems with this are more societal ones than technical or practical: It is impossible, for example, to install most popular apps for macOS without identifying yourself to Apple (and by extension the US government and military intelligence). You can't use the App Store (even for free apps) without an Apple ID, and you can't get an Apple ID without a phone number. (In many countries, you can't get a phone number without a government ID.)
Similarly, if you wish to publish apps widely, you can do so with unsigned ones, but users won't ever figure out how to run those.[1] If you want your app to be widely used, you must ID yourself to Apple, who can deny/censor at will (or under state (or Hollywood) compulsion).
It builds a world in which it is impossible to easily build or distribute tools that the state really doesn't want distributed or used, because Apple is too large to deny them their demands.
I think the phrase used is "turnkey tyranny".
Anonymous publishing is essential to the preservation of a free society.
Imagine if there were one company who could remotely disable printing presses, or televisions/radios.
For those of you who aren't yet worried about this possibility of state compulsion, I ask you this: Dubya is to Trump as Trump is to x? It's not a matter of if these remote censorship tools built by Apple will be used to abuse human rights en masse, but instead a matter of when. Apple is already compromising their crypto due to requests (not compulsion) from the federal police—today.
[1]: https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/unsigned.html https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/unsigned.html
- coldtea 6y ago>The problems with this are more societal ones than technical or practical: It is impossible, for example, to install most popular apps for macOS without identifying yourself to Apple (and by extension the US government and military intelligence). For those kind of problems, I agree. But I think they should be solved in the political and legal level, not some technical fix. If you can't trust the government, if the government wants increasingly more data, the government should be curbed by protests, voting, and so on. The apps not talking to the vendor is just a band-aid. They can still get your moves from your phone, your searches from Google, and so on. And, in any case, Tor is not a substitute for democracy. >It builds a world in which it is impossible to easily build or distribute tools that the state really doesn't want distributed or used, because Apple is too large to deny them their demands. We shouldn't allow the state to have a say on this, like we shouldn't allow censorship. (Of course, many tech people, are all ok for censorship, as long as it happens to the right, that is bad, guys, e.g. those peddling "fake news" -- with the state or the Zuck guaranteeing for them what are "real news", like the WMDs and other establishment truths).
- sneak 6y ago> If you can't trust the government, if the government wants increasingly more data, the government should be curbed by protests, voting, and so on. The apps not talking to the vendor is just a band-aid. And what if you can't discuss protests or protest organization on any of the apps you are allowed to install on your device, as Apple has made the case already in Hong Kong? This all starts with the tools. Without tools, we cannot even begin to effect change: to organize protests, to communicate with other organizers without surveillance and interference (Poitras can probably testify to this), to reach potential voters. In Apple's jurisdiction, there are essentially zero options on the ballot for candidates that wish to roll back US state/military surveillance. Voting is not a useful or practical tool in this fight. Private communications tools (as well as arms) must remain out of the instantaneous reach of the state. Once those are compromised, there will be no way to effect practical change or resistance. If Signal's iOS publishing certificate were revoked tomorrow and Apple temporarily stopped signing self-builds, we'd be there right now with iOS phones. We've already lost this freedom on mobile. We need to fight to preserve it on desktop/laptop.
- coldtea 6y ago>And what if you can't discuss protests or protest organization on any of the apps you are allowed to install on your device, as Apple has made the case already in Hong Kong? What about it? People had protests, and far more massive, at the era of Louis XVI or the Czar, or Pinochet, or whatever. Without IM apps and 10000 electronic alternatives, and with much worse repurcursions if caught... >In Apple's jurisdiction, there are essentially zero options on the ballot for candidates that wish to roll back US state/military surveillance. Voting is not a useful or practical tool in this fight. Sideloading isn't gonna help if that's the kind of problems you're facing...
- sneak 6y agoWars are fought now primarily with information, not violence. I would like to keep it that way; extremely effective systems of state censorship of publishing and communications, such as implemented presently on iOS (remember when the US was about to ban TikTok?) is a good way to force large groups to revert to those bad, old ways if all other options are removed. I don't want the majority of the population to only have immediate access to devices that are similarly censored, centrally controlled, and able to be remotely surveilled (such as the unencrypted OCSP data leak extant in macOS the last two+ years, and all of the telemetry built into Windows by design). Privacy and freedom and peace are all deeply interlinked. It's an ecosystem, and damaging one part can have deep consequences for the others.
- spijdar 6y agoThe problem with this line of thinking regarding Macs is, well, there are just so many good alternatives to Macs. Now, it is worth giving consideration to the possibility that Macs will become so much better than the competition that they could become like iPhones, and develop more of a stranglehold over people's lives. As it stands now, and in the immediate future, I don't see this as a valid concern. There are just too many good alternatives, if your concerns are limited to the above. (now, I wish open hardware became way more prevalent -- not PC open, but open source with libre firmware. I'm concerned that window is permanently closing, as the market is consolidating on very literal monopolies with highly restricted firmware. Almost every company I'm aware of is now using Synopsys IP for their DDR4 PHY trainer -- a CPU which has direct access to memory, and writable, signed, encrypted firmware...)
- sneak 6y agoAs for the average person, phones have already taken over, and things like laptops and desktops are mostly irrelevant except in the workplace. We've already seen total vendor control there. There's nothing to suggest that those same vendors won't do the exact same things on all of their platforms. Already it's basically impossible to distribute unsigned mac apps.