37 ms·
Google Is Testing End-to-End Encryption in Android Messages
- est31 6y agoGoogle whitepaper is here: https://www.gstatic.com/messages/papers/messages_e2ee.pdf https://www.gstatic.com/messages/papers/messages_e2ee.pdf
- varispeed 6y agoWell, it does not say what kind of metadata they'll be collecting and it seems like they send the phone numbers in plain text. No thanks.
- username90 6y agoThis goes via the phone network and not Googles servers, so you have to ask that question to your phone number provider and not Google.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- timeimp 6y agoSo... when does this become an anti-patriotic thing to have? You know, when a country's police can't unlock the phone then convince everyone that a "little bit of a backdoor" is a good thing? /s
- est31 6y agoThese end to end encrypted systems are subverted through backups that devices put into the cloud in the clear. Officially they are "encrypted" in Android [0], but typically the key is extremely weak so it's easy to brute force. iCloud is officially "encrypted" as well but Apple holds the keys. [0]: https://security.googleblog.com/2018/10/google-and-android-have-your-back-by.html https://security.googleblog.com/2018/10/google-and-android-h...
- bergstromm466 6y agoIt’s scary how few people know and understand all this, and, proportional to the amount of tech we use in our daily lives, how little we learn to use and program our own technology. I think we’ve got nothing to blame but the digital enclosure of knowledge through patents and copyrights. People aren’t ‘stupid’ at all, they’re disinherited and disempowered, starting at ‘school‘.
- dragonelite 6y agoYeah whatsapp kept asking me do you want to backup your chat history so we can easily recover it. To the point it became so annoying i almost deleted whatsapp. I just assume there is no privacy on the internet. If i wanna keep a secret i will keep it in my mind.
- sneak 6y agoI believe that that blog post indicates that Google uses custom HSMs to do the backup pin check to access the actual backup encryption key, ruling out the likelihood (but not possibility) that Google is able to casually decrypt the data. Google writes and signs the firmware for the Titan HSMs in question, though. I would be surprised if it is actually 100% technically impossible for Google to decrypt backups.
- est31 6y agoYeah the HSM idea is good, and it likely helps preventing malicious insiders from hacking user's backups, but I wouldn't trust it as it's not verifiable from the outside.
- blackrock 6y agoThe other problem, if you try your best to avoid backing your stuff up to the cloud, is that other people will back up their stuff to the cloud. So, your messages with them, will get sucked up also, and forever saved on the cloud.
- blackrock 6y agoWhat do you have to hide? If you don’t have anything to hide, then what’s wrong with a little backdoor into your smartphone, so that the “good guys” can help to keep an eye on you, and keep you safe. -wink -wink
- corty 6y agoWhy do they bother? Whatsapp can do all of that right now. Has done successfully for a few years. And the article sounds like it would need support by the mobile carriers: being deeply in the pocket of governments, they won't switch on E2E, just like all the intentionally vulnerable crappy mobile encryption. Also, being mobile carriers, they will bill huge amounts per message, making it unacceptable to consumers used to "its hidden in the cost of the data plan". Oh, and being a Google project: when do we expect RCS to be abandoned?
- fakedang 6y agoChill, let some Google PM have his ego boost and bonus while it lasts, before Pichai McKinseys it out. Honestly, I don't see an outward difference between this and Hangouts (which is being shut down come December), apart from the end-to-end encryption. Moreover, the Android Messages section is for all the crap I get from nearby outlets advertising their "best deals", or scam artists targeting the vulnerable. I cannot honestly see myself or my peers switching out from Whatsapp to this, especially not when Whatsapp has become a verb in most of the old world. As I've said before, Whatsapp is trusted so much that autocratic regimes such as the KSA, Russia, UAE and Venezuela used it to discuss OPEC production limits. People in all of these countries trust Whatsapp far more than Android, in spite of them being known to be owned by Facebook, and in spite of said people being very wary of using Facebook for messaging (most Arab Spring countries for instance).
- username90 6y ago> Whatsapp can do all of that right now. No it can't, this is about sending end to end encrypted messages via the phone network and not the internet. Phone networks have much better coverage than internet providers. Sending E2E encrypted messages via internet is already possible on Google services. Edit: Or Google might have shut those services down. Anyway, this isn't about a chat app but making e2e the new standard for SMS.
- corty 6y agoRCS uses the phone network data channel. So more internet than phone in that aspect, it's not at all like SMS hiding in the free space in beacon frames. Therefore coverage won't be any better. The only possible minimal difference would be using authentication via SIM/carrier instead of the Whatsapp method of sending a confirmation code via SMS/call. But that is a very minor difference.
- richardARPANET 6y agoI'm 100% sure both Google and Whatsapp have received nice letters from the NSA ensuring all of their messaging tools have backdoors.
- yoavm 6y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted. I don't know about the 100% part, but it doesn't seem crazy or impossible that they'll do something like that, and we should all be well aware of the possibility.
- pulse7 6y agoHe is getting downvoted by the folks who either 1) know this is true or 2) who will deny this is true even if it is true. And I will burn a bit of my karma for this comment too... :-)
- artvark11 6y agoYou would hope that the NSA would only have tools to collect the messages of targeted users, but seeing their other programs, Id assume they just dragnet everybody.
- schmorptron 6y agoSounds interesting, seems like they're basing this on the Signal Protocol again. I wonder if the ease of access for this will lead it to replace Whatsapp in Europe, which would just be moving from one tech giant to the next. Is there any chance they'll implement something in Android itself so other apps like Signal can use RCS to send messages?
- richardwhiuk 6y agoDoubt people will move from Whatsapp to Android Messages. Whatsapp is deeply cross platform, which means it captures a much larger fraction of the userbase.
- samoa42 6y ago> Whatsapp is deeply cross platform it requires a smartphone with android, ios or kaios. so, no.
- lozf 6y agoPretty sure the only one of those platforms that supports RCS is Android (with Google's newly updated default app, rather than any of the many third party SMS apps).
- schmorptron 6y agoThat's true.
- samoa42 6y agohow can it be true when almost everyone works on a platform that cannot run it without piggyback to a smartphone?
- est31 6y agoFrom the whitepaper it still seems to use RCS for the transport, just encrypting it and using a special mime type. I know that carriers have various RCS apps, but they likely have special access. Cross-carrier apps like Signal would require OS support for RCS APIs. IIRC there are plans to add such APIs to Android. I've found old threads [0] that it may be included into Android 11 but nothing in the official docs [1]. So maybe it'll be added to Android 12? [0]: https://www.reddit.com/r/UniversalProfile/comments/g6r4av/android_11r_developer_preview_4_today_rcs_apis/ https://www.reddit.com/r/UniversalProfile/comments/g6r4av/an... [1]: https://developer.android.com/about/versions/11/features https://developer.android.com/about/versions/11/features
- keraf 6y agoJust as the Five Eyes, India, Japan and the EU are calling for backdoors in E2EE.
- mtgx 6y agoCurious to see if law enforcement agencies will complain about this specifically over the next 2-3 years as it rolls out to a billion users. If we don't hear a single peep about it, I'd just assume Google gave them a way to spy on whatever conversion they want, at will. Come to think about it, we haven't heard manycomplaints about WhatsApp's encryption from governments lately either, have we?
- tuyguntn 6y agoPlease Google, stop creating/updating anything related to messaging, you are probably going to replace it with something new anyway in 3-5 years
- samoa42 6y agothe spec is over then years old already and not from google. so there is that. google is just the one to drag their feet the fastest seeing its other attempts to enter the messaging market failed completely.
- jason0597 6y agoWhat's the point when the Android keyboard is essentially a glorified keylogger?
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agoI don't remember exactly but essentially I read about zuckerberg and e2e and something along the lines of "before we encrypt the link or message, we would send a hash for verification and if passed, e2e would be go ahead and sent." Dont remember if it was something to be done in future or existing tech because there was talks of misuse and this article had come. I know if multiple Foss apps like Delta chat I think which uses existing infrastructure.
- zadjii 6y agoA lot of people in the comments are wondering how this could possibly compete with WhatsApp, but I don't think competing with WhatsApp is the goal at all here. While WhatsApp is super prevalent across Europe, in the US, most folks are still just using SMS with whatever their phone's default messaging app is. For iPhone users, that's iMessage, and for Android users that's Android Mwessages. There's just far too much inertia on SMS for that to change in the US - everyone's already got a cell phone number that can be used to send SMS messages to, but WhatsApp accounts are few and far between. And I gotta say, when the person you're chatting with is also on Android Messages, the silent upgrade to RCS has been great. It finally feels like texting in the 21st century. So if Google can start rolling this out as the default experience for US-based Android users, it's gonna make a lot of people happy without them ever realizing it.
- swiley 6y agoThis absolutely sucks when you switch OSes and can't participate in your groups anymore. With imessage pirating OSX will let you connect again (although it's a major pain, and you have to go generating serial numbers and trying to log in.) Is there something like that for Android? Or do you just not get to talk to your friends if you take the sim card out of your old phone.
- tantalor 6y agoWhat are you talking about? SMS has groups.
- pmontra 6y agoIs RCS supported by iOS phones or it's going to be an Android only thing?
- samoa42 6y agofwiw i would not hold my breath for adoption from apple and this in turn probably means it wont gain any traction. edit: the rcs spec is over ten years old
- blackrock 6y agoI heard it was far easier to hack Android instead, and exfiltrate the decrypted messages at rest, on the local phone itself.