6 ms·
Incoming possible Silly, Stupid and Lazy Questions, 1. Are there any vaccine ( of any Disease ) that are 100% effective? Or do we operate ( as I would assume )
by ksec 6y ago
Incoming possible Silly, Stupid and Lazy Questions,
1. Are there any vaccine ( of any Disease ) that are 100% effective? Or do we operate ( as I would assume ) something like 5 Nines effective rate and call it 100%?
2. Across all type of Vaccine, what are the average or median effective rate? i.e Should we expect Vaccine to be 90%+ effective in the first place? Or is that a wrong expectation to make?
3. What happens in the case of 10% ineffective, do they take a third dose?
- dragontamer 6y ago> 2. Across all type of Vaccine, what are the average or median effective rate? i.e Should we expect Vaccine to be 90%+ effective in the first place? Or is that a wrong expectation to make? Sometimes, vaccines are only 30% or 40% effective, leading to terrible flu seasons. I don't really know the mean/median/mode, but 90% is really high for a vaccine. > 3. What happens in the case of 10% ineffective, do they take a third dose? How do you know if someone is one of those 10%?
- ksec 6y ago>How do you know if someone is one of those 10%? I would assume everyone have the vaccine and they still get caught COVID afterwards? Or do I misunderstood what effective means?
- austhrow743 6y agoIf they already got Covid then a third dose of vaccine is pointless.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe point of a vaccine is to give you immunity WITHOUT getting the virus. Your immune system naturally becomes immune after it fights off an infection. But because of the risk of long-term effects and/or death when you're infected with COVID19, people want a safer solution that provides immunity. A vaccine provides immunity, but at a lesser rate than the actual virus. But 90% (or even 70%) effectiveness is a good thing: it means 90% to 70% people do NOT spread the virus anymore. You'd think that means 90% or 70% fewer deaths, but that's mistaken. That 70% is compounded over-and-over every generation. If everyone else is vaccinated: you infect 70% fewer people. Those people infect 70% fewer people, and those people infect 70% fewer people. After 3 generations, a 70% vaccine would wipe out 97.3% of possible infections. And a "generation" in COVID19 terms is roughly 1-week. --------- So yes, even a 70% vaccine (if everyone took it) is a very, very, very good thing. But the two vaccine trials that finished first were 90% effective, so I think people will prefer the higher-efficacy (at least, if they have access to Dry Ice / -80C storage).
- BurningFrog 6y agoThe flu vaccine problem is mostly that there are always several strains floating around. A vaccine that is 90% effective against one strain may only be 40% effective against the collective.
- Gibbon1 6y agoYeah. Influenza is also a segmented virus. The RNA is composed of eight segments. The virus can produce new strains by shuffling segments between to different strains when a cell is infected by both. Influenza can mutate very quickly. Simple single stranded viruses like Covid19 are vastly more stable. A good vaccine as long as we force everyone to take it will wipe out covid19.
- twic 6y agoThis has been downvoted, but it's absolutely true - see the table here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Influenza_vaccine#Effectiveness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Influenza_vaccine#Effectivenes... The best effectiveness of a flu vaccine in the US since 2004 was 60%.
- singingfish 6y ago1. Smallpox vaccine is 100% effective 2. 90% is high. 3. Probably not. Immune systems are weird and incredibly complicated (think even more complicated than the brain).
- bawolff 6y agoI dont think its true that smallpox is 100% effective
- bjoli 6y agoIt isn't. It is comparable to the measles vaccine. Smallpox has a lot lower R-value which means the vaccine is very good at preventing outbreaks. A vaccinated individual will also have milder symptoms. Together with how rare adverse reactions are to the vaccination, the smallpox vaccine is really a wonder.
- robbiep 6y agoThat’s not really true about smallpox - it’s R is somewhere between 5-8, SARS-CoV-2 is about 2.5. Higher R0 means you need a greater percentage vaccinated population to achieve herd immunity
- 6y ago
- photon-torpedo 6y agoNot an epidemiologist, but I think the goal of mass vaccination if to make R drop to well below 1. If everybody is vaccinated with a 90% effective vaccine, then R drops by a factor of 10 (I think) so that sounds pretty good?
- MagnumOpus 6y agoYes, R is at 1.3 with WFH and other restriction. In March, R was 3-5 without restrictions. If everyone got vaccinated with 90% effectivity (or even 70%), it would be enough. However, availability won't be sufficient to get to 100% within a year, and compliance seems to be somewhere around 50-70% at most given polls. (There are a huge number of people even in this forum who are antisocial - "I won't get vaccinated until I have seen super-long-term effects, and screw the people who I superspread the disease to".)
- skocznymroczny 6y agoAntisocial? Let me decide about myself. How did it go, "my body, my choice"? Also, I find it interesting how everyone suddenly trusts 100% every claim made by big pharmaceutical companies, even though most of them don't have a good history. Volkswagen was also complying to all the laws and standards, until it turned out it actually didn't.
- Tepix 6y agoIf enough people get a vaccination that is >50% effective, Sars-CoV-2 should peter out.
- bjoli 6y agoSuperficially regarding number 2: on a population scale a lot depends on how contagious the disease is. The measles vaccine is very efficient (over 95% after two doses), but still requires something like a 90% vaccination grade to prevent outbreaks. Measles is very very very contagious. Covid is not nearly as contagious, so to prevent outbreaks it doesn't have to be nearly as good at the same vaccination grade. For an individual, however, 70% would not feel very reassuring, which is why we need a lot of people getting vaccinated. Edit: fixed some autocorrect issues. I feel I should add: measles is not at fun, even if you don't have any complications. You become very sick. Serious complications are _a lot_ more common than adverse reactions to the vaccine. Don't rely on other people being vaccinated unless you have a compromised immune system in any way.
- ageitgey 6y ago> For an individual, however, 70% would not feel very reassuring, which is why we need a lot of people getting vaccinated. Agreed, but keep in mind that no one in the Oxford trial who got the vaccine got a serious case of COVID or needed to go to the hospital. So it's only 70%-90% effective (depending on dose) at keeping you from getting infected, but so far 100% effective at reducing severity and keeping you from dying or going to the hospital. So that's a huge positive to keep in mind and yet another reason to get vaccinated.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sgt101 6y agoOn 1 : I think that measles vaccines have to be 95%+ effective, or basically you have no herd immunity to prevent an outbreak and protect (for example) infants not yet immunized. Because, measles is so amazingly transmissible. Other vaccines are much less effective (ie. yellow fever?) but because the diseases are harder to catch they can be suppressed in the population just as well.
- Symmetry 6y agoThe sort of polio vaccine used in rich countries is almost 100% effective after three doses. I did some spot checking of a bunch of vaccines I'd heard of and most seem to be between 90% and 99% effective so Covid-19 vaccines seem to be in line with expectations. The flu is worse but that's always a guessing game of which strain will be prevalent when they're making the vaccine. I think that's because more doses tend to be more effective and if a single dose doesn't get you there they just give you more doses, like the two doses for the mRNA covid vaccines. Effectiveness here is how many people get sick. You don't know in this circumstance that they're going to get sick until it happens, though maybe you could keep track of everybody's antibody levels compared to what they should be and guess. That would be way more expensive than just giving everybody the same schedule of doses though.