3 ms·
If the DHS had a legal leg to stand on they would have delivered their request via official channels.
by rhizome 16y ago
If the DHS had a legal leg to stand on they would have delivered their request via official channels.
- pavel_lishin 16y agoThey didn't actually mention what channels they went through. What would an "official channel" look like, in this case? Also, perhaps they didn't want to spend the $5k on a lawyer to draw up an official document, hoping that a simple request would suffice. Understandable, and laudable - as is Mozilla's refusal to comply with what is nothing more than a request.
- jarin 16y agoI would imagine DHS has their own lawyers on staff?
- cellis 16y agoWouldn't that fall to the Department of Justice?
- redthrowaway 16y agoNo, all government agencies have a legal staff. The DoJ's mandate doesn't include screening all government actions for legality.
- VladRussian 16y ago> Also, perhaps they didn't want to spend the $5k on a lawyer a government bureaucrat letting pass a chance to send more work to his lawyer friend? Nope. They just do not risk yet to attack Mozilla on such a shaky ground as declaring such an add-on as a paraphernalia of copyright infringement. Yet, it is just a matter of time. They will start with somebody less popular than Mozilla.
- rhizome 16y agoWhat would an "official channel" look like, in this case? Though nobody concerned is revealing the actual delivery method, it would look something like a process server and it wouldn't be called "asking."
- gscott 16y agoThey don't need official channels... they can just take the domain name for providing a plug-in that links to pirated content. The Mozilla domain might pull up a DHS graphic any day now! (it would be interesting if the DHS would go so far as to take down a site used by millions... but you never know as it appears DHS is above the law)
- asadotzler 16y agoa site used by hundreds of millions, actually :-) and a site that helps ensure the security of every Firefox user across the globe.
- VladRussian 16y ago>If the DHS had a legal leg to stand on they would have raided the mozilla's offices and as GP mentioned seized the domain. When they can - they do.