9 ms·
> True black tends to look pretty unnatural, so start with a really dark grey I wish this myth would die. #000 is already dark gray on any normal real-life scr
by crazygringo 6y ago
> True black tends to look pretty unnatural, so start with a really dark grey
I wish this myth would die. #000 is already dark gray on any normal real-life screen anyone uses because of ambient light, halos, etc. It's nowhere near "true black".
There is a good reason to avoid pure black or pure white in an interface, but it's nothing to do with "naturalness" or even legibility.
It's simply so that images or content which do include the full brightness gamut from #000 to #FFF "pop" in comparison. You want the darkest shadows and brightest highlights to catch your attention, and not have them compete with browser or interface chrome.
An interface is generally intended to "recede" next to actual content. But if your interface is star of the show? Use pure black and pure white. Go crazy. It's been used to great effect before.
- coldtea 6y ago>I wish this myth would die. #000 is already dark gray on any normal real-life screen anyone uses because of ambient light, halos, etc. No, it's not. And with OLED, mini-LED etc, it will be even less so.
- manmal 6y agoOLED ghosting is another thing to consider - using a very dark gray instead of 000 prevents pixels from switching off, and prevents ghosting.
- ddingus 6y agoTechnical performance is an entirely different matter. The "unnatural" black argument is not valid, as others are making clear. Avoiding display artifacts is something different. And it is not "unnatural" black. It is better to discuss black, as in 0, in those terms that have a basis in reality. "Unnatural" black is not reality.
- manmal 6y agoI agree. In my case, my art teacher told us, almost 20y ago now, that we shouldn’t use pure black in digital design because it‘s unnatural. He failed to explain why though, and I never found an argument that didn’t sound dogmatic, so I‘ve filed it under cargo cult.
- ddingus 6y ago20 years ago, pure black on a CRT, for example, up against pure white would have generated artifacts on many displays. Similar things happened with TV programs. NTSC has low color resolution and much higher luma resolution. Large shifts around the color wheel, at higher resolutions, smaller pixel sizes, generated undesirable artifacts. Luma changes generally didn't. This kind of thing drove art direction toward more broad swaths of color, luma and gentle hue changes to imply texture and detail, rather than actually forcing detail. Frankly, these subtle limits in display tech are all over the place. 4k HDMI does not have 4k pixel perfect color, or didn't last time I looked. Discussing art in these contexts makes great sense! For that matter, one might also say to avoid high saturation colors... many displays cannot even render them. CRT displays can, plasma TV can, and some new OLED apparently can. LCD, generally can't. Nature does present these colors to us, so... yeah. I much prefer to talk about these things in terms of display capability, potential artifacts and such myself. It is a far more useful discussion.
- Firadeoclus 6y agoHDMI 2.0 can do 4k at 60Hz without chroma subsampling, though not all devices support it. HDMI 2.1 can go much higher.
- ddingus 6y agoGood to know. I qualified my statement because it had been a while since I reviewed HDMI specs. Thanks for the quickie update.
- sellyme 6y agoIf you've found an OLED screen that doesn't reflect ambient light I'd recommend trying to sell that to phone companies.
- kitsunesoba 6y ago> I wish this myth would die. #000 is already dark gray on any normal real-life screen anyone uses because of ambient light, halos, etc. It's nowhere near "true black". I would say phones would be an exception to this rule, since a large number, perhaps even the majority, use OLED panels which are capable of displaying true black. This is becoming true for TVs as well.
- crazygringo 6y agoNo it's not, this is what people misunderstand. An OLED or LCD panel, even one that is entirely turned off, isn't "true black". If you put something like Vantablack next to it, it would become very obvious that it's merely dark gray. It's still reflecting a significant amount of light from the environment. And then it appears even lighter when you've got "black" text on a white background, because on our retina the white background "bleeds" into the black as well. Painters, photographers -- these people are very aware that with real-world common objects, "black" is never actually black. Unless you're literally in a room with no light at all, it's only ever dark gray. Computer screens are nowhere near capable of producing any kind of "unnatural true black". It's not a thing to worry about.
- comradesmith 6y agoI think you are being a bit too finicky here. "true black" is generally accepted to mean #000 in digital media. We're talking design here, not physics.
- crazygringo 6y agoMy point is that it's now a common misconception that #000 is an "unnatural" black -- that's literally the word the article uses. That it's blacker than anything natural, i.e. blacker than objects in real life, that it becomes an "unnatural" level of contrast. It's a bizarre idea that started gaining traction maybe around 5 years ago, that using #000 in designs is therefore bad because it doesn't occur in nature. That's what I'm pushing back against. The #000 on your screen does occur in nature, because its output on your screen is just a normal household black like lots of other objects.
- j45 6y agoThis relative black / dark grey you speak of would appear differently on each display. Finding a grey color range that more accurately reproduces seems like a more fruitful undertaking.
- ImprobableTruth 6y ago>#000 is already dark gray on any normal real-life screen So? The contrast between 'black' and 'white' is still extreme relative to what people normally have around them. The same goes for the neon colors. They are 'diluted', but they're still incredibly garish and generally look unnatural. If you don't like the word 'unnatural' just replace it with 'digital looking'. Now, looking 'unnatural' isn't necessarily bad (especially for a website interface) and something like text should definitely have a high contrast, but it's definitely something to keep in mind.
- crazygringo 6y ago> The contrast between 'black' and 'white' is still extreme relative to what people normally have around them. It's actually the opposite. The truth is, our eyes are able to easily register extreme levels of contrast -- clearly taking in a bright sunlit day through the window next to a dark but still clearly visible interior. Computer screens (and film and camera sensors) don't achieve anything close to the level of contrast our eyes can take in, which is why things like exposure and blowout require so much careful attention -- why you simply can't take a photo of a bright landscape in the window of a dark room without artificial-looking HDR. If you stand in an office and look around, it's not like computer screens stand out as blazing white with inky black figures on them. To the contrary — they fit in rather harmoniously in terms of brightness. (And in dark rooms, we tend to reduce brightness in order to keep the harmony.) The idea that computer screens have extreme levels of contrast in comparison with the surroundings is simply not true — it's entirely the opposite.
- visarga 6y agoIt's more of a personal feeling - black on white text seems jarring. I prefer to attenuate both a bit.
- ImprobableTruth 6y ago> our eyes are able to easily register extreme levels of contrast >Computer screens (and film and camera sensors) don't achieve anything close to the level of contrast our eyes can take in And I didn't say anything to the contrary. It's about what people are used to, not to what is physically possible. Again, digital neon colors are definitely not even close to the most extreme you can get - that doesn't mean they're not garish and ugly. > clearly taking in a bright sunlit day through the window next to a dark but still clearly visible interior Do you think most people would call that 'natural' and pleasant lighting conditions? >If you stand in an office and look around, it's not like computer screens stand out as blazing white with inky black figures on them If you look at them from their intended viewing angle, they're absolutely going to stand out (unless your display is just really dumpy). >The idea that computer screens have extreme levels of contrast in comparison with the surroundings is simply not true Feel free to name all the items in your (normally lit) office that have a higher or even just comparable contrast to your screen.
- andy_ppp 6y agoI think people scale their perception when looking at a screen, looking at white on black is too harsh for most uses with text these days. I personally think it looks really unprofessional and uninspiring going for the most possible contrast in a design.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> "pop" What do designers mean by 'pop'?
- radley 6y agoStand out from the background
- dj_mc_merlin 6y agoGrab attention.
- trilinearnz 6y agoMy interpretation: Contrast, vividness, attention-grabbing.
- sundarurfriend 6y agoIt's funny seeing this question because in the early 2000s it was designers complaining "what the hell do clients mean by 'pop'?" Now it seems designers have adopted the lingo and it's others asking designers this question.