2 ms·
> Second, the system of meritocratic admission that Conant promoted did not lead to the classless society he hoped it would produce. Inequalities of income and
by rayiner 6y ago
> Second, the system of meritocratic admission that Conant promoted did not lead to the classless society he hoped it would produce. Inequalities of income and wealth have deepened since the 1940s and 1950s, and the social mobility that Conant saw as the remedy for a stratified society has not come about. The haves and have-nots have not been trading places from one generation to the next.
This is demonstrably untrue. First, the article’s use of a family making $200,000 is telling. If you look around that people who are billionaires today, most did come from upper middle class families, but not necessarily wealthy ones. Mark Zuckerberg’s parents are a psychiatrist and a dentist. Opening wide the class of the most elite to the children of upper middle class professionals is in fact a huge societal achievement. Few societies have that kind of mobility.
Another example is the economic mobility of Asians raised in the bottom 20% of income. These people lack both financial resources and social connections. But they have a 27% chance of ending up in the top 20% of income as adults. Test-based meritocracy like the SAT is a huge enabler of that.
- akhilcacharya 6y ago> Opening wide the class of the most elite to the children of upper middle class professionals is in fact a huge societal achievement. Few societies have that kind of mobility. I have trouble agreeing with that, especially given the tendencies of pulling up the ladder. The billionaires are basically irrelevant because they're too small in number, the upper middle class and everyone else is the chasm that is widening by the day [0]. It's absolutely becoming or has become a stratified structure. [0] https://www.brookings.edu/book/dream-hoarders/ https://www.brookings.edu/book/dream-hoarders/