5 ms·
I think what GP is referring to is C++ not supporting C's designated initializers, restrict qualifiers, or flexible array members features. These are roughly th
by jcranmer 6y ago
I think what GP is referring to is C++ not supporting C's designated initializers, restrict qualifiers, or flexible array members features. These are roughly the only C features not in C++ that are worth supporting (the STL in C++ works better than VLAs, and templates work better than type-generic macros). All of the other new C features are either backported C++ features with different spellings, or new functionality (mostly library) that C++ adopts.
- pjmlp 6y agoVLAs are gone, were made optional in C11, thus every compiler that jumped from C89 to C11 never bothered with them. Google even sponsored a massive effort to clean the Linux kernel of their use. A subset of designated initializers is supported in C++20.
- yakubin 6y ago> A subset of designated initializers is supported in C++20. Took them only 21 years... And this standard being so recent, most projects won't have that for years to come.
- pjmlp 6y agoDoesn't matter, the point was what C subset does C++ support today. https://godbolt.org/z/GW59rM https://godbolt.org/z/GW59rM
- vitus 6y agoC++20 designated initializers must be specified in definition order, whereas they don't in C99. In your example, Point point = {.z = 2.0, .x = 1.0}; produces a compilation error. This is annoying, but workable. And at least it's a compile-time error, rather than a bug that perniciously sneaks into production.
- pjmlp 6y agoWhy do you think I wrote "A subset of designated initializers is supported in C++20."?
- flohofwoe 6y agoThere's a surprising amount of perfectly valid C code that's not valid C++ (not even taking regrettable design warts like VLAs into account). The "common subset" of C and C++ is both a subset of C, and a subset of C++, e.g. C++ has forked C and turned its C subset into a non-standard dialect. It's interesting that the other C descendant Objective-C has decided to "respect" its C subset instead of messing with it, with the result that new C standards are automatically supported in ObjC.
- pjmlp 6y agoA descendant that would be dead by now wouldn't Apple decided to buy NeXT. VLAs are dead, a broken design fixed in C11 by removing it from the standard, no idea why everyone keeps referring to them.
- saagarjha 6y agoThe one good use of VLAs I know of is casting a buffer into a multidimensional (variable-length) array to allow for subscripting to work.
- pjmlp 6y agoWhatever good uses VLAs might actually have had, they are gone with C11.