7 ms·
If you are a US company, or have a US user base, politics is non-optional. How do you deal with "hateful" user-generated content? Hate is now politics. How d
by sandworm101 6y ago
If you are a US company, or have a US user base, politics is non-optional. How do you deal with "hateful" user-generated content? Hate is now politics. How do you deal with employees expressing thier opinions at work? Basic fashion is now politics (masks). Which health care plan do you adopt? There are right and left-wing plans (birth control etc). The holidays are comming. Do your employees say "merry christmas" or "happy holidays"? Dont think you can avoid that one. Letting them pick is still taking sides. What is your policy on weapons? Can guns be sold/discussed on your platform? Then politics comes knocking on the door directly. To which parties or candidates will you donate? Will you create special rules for well-connected users? (Facebook). Will you turn off a politician's account when it violates your rules? (Twitter). Will you accept a political party as a customer? What if they insist you then turn away a different party?
Politics cannot be avoided. It is part of the US tech landscape. The only option is to plan and engage thoughtfully.
- cscurmudgeon 6y ago> How do you deal with "hateful" user-generated content Consistently. Whatever you policies, apply them as consistently as possible.
- danarmak 6y agoThen all political camps will be against you, as you violate each of their norms in turn. Once at least one major (political) group calls views held by tens of millions of people hate speech, there is no way to avoid being in someone's black book. This is why many companies are aligning with one party - they can't have both, and it's better than none.
- m0ck 6y ago>black book Careful with those metaphors!
- spiderfarmer 6y agoPeople shouldn’t care if trying to do the right thing makes you end up in someones black book. There will always be people who are on the wrong side of things. Just do what you think is best for our society.
- judge2020 6y agoBut "the right thing" differs from person to person. A 10 person company [say, running a local grocery store] comprised entirely of conservatives will think it's right to allow customers to decide if they want to wear a mask, while the same company comprised entirely of liberals will think that it's right to make customers wear masks and otherwise refuse servicing them. Who decides which company is doing the right thing? You?
- spiderfarmer 6y agoYes. And you're allowed to be wrong. To make mistakes. Own up to them if you do. But never stop trying to do what you thing is right because it's unpopular in certain circles. You'll be very unhappy if you do.
- cercatrova 6y agoThat is fine. Consistently being on no one's side is better than being on someone's side.
- danarmak 6y agoThen you'll have to withstand at least one party: twitter mobs, editorials, maybe employee protests or resignations. Both you personally, and your company. It's not surprising that many companies give in. They want to make a product and make money, not to make a political or moral stand.
- cercatrova 6y agoThat's also fine, Coinbase is doing that, and giving generous severence packages to leaving employees as well. There will always be detractors but most people won't really care.
- nullc 6y agoConveniently not mentioned in the article, though it saw fit to point out that "About 60 Coinbase employees, or 5 percent of the work force, have resigned,"
- sandworm101 6y agoThen the side you take will be determined by whatever content you move against first.
- dredmorbius 6y agoThe law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread. -- Anatole France
- sandworm101 6y agoAnd when short of bread, both rich and poor alike are free to eat cake.
- disposekinetics 6y agoI’ve never gotten this quote. On the face of it it seems like a high priority that the law should not respect the station of a person. If a society has made something illegal it needs to apply from the least to the greatest, or the law is unjust.
- dredmorbius 6y agoEqually-applied law sustains inequity.
- thesuperbigfrog 6y agoInequity is a natural state. Should discrimination be applied to achieve "equity"? If so, how is that fair to those being discriminated against?
- dredmorbius 6y agoInequality sustained or increased by the law of man is entirely artificial. Discrimination has long been applied to achieve inequality. I'm willing to try the opposite as a countermeasure. https://www.newberry.org/newberry-and-restrictive-covenants https://www.newberry.org/newberry-and-restrictive-covenants
- disposekinetics 6y agoAny sort of bettering that is not globally experienced equally sustains inequity. To go to an absurd place the improvements I made to my garden this year sustain inequity since I now have and enjoy them and others do not, but they would if I had donated the same amount of time to a community garden. That alone should not be a compelling reason to act.
- octoberfranklin 6y ago"our policies are a living document" -- Twitter
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- carapace 6y agoNot to mention the whole, "to 'not do politics' is itself a political stance [in favor of the status quo].", eh? (I'm not "that guy" myself, but I bet he'll show up. edit: There we go: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25179187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25179187 Thank you zabhi. ) - - - - > The only option is to plan and engage thoughtfully. FWIW, I feel that that begins with getting real clear on one's deepest values and motives. I think what we're seeing in the USA is kind of like when a kid from a small town goes to the big city for the first time. US culture even after WWII has always been kind of insular and provincial. (As a kid, my world was divided into SF, the East Bay, and the rest of it.) Now with the Internet everybody is up in each other's faces (also driven by those clicks, gotta get those clicks) and we're a bit shocked, collectively.
- freshhawk 6y agoIt's a bit weird from the outside, as a non-american. When I was growing up there was a very narrow window of acceptable ideas in the US, anything else was "unamerican". "The two parties are basically the same" was a cliche when I was a kid. The reaction to a relatively tiny number of new acceptable ideas in the discourse has been pretty surprising, even to someone who thought they already had a low opinion of American culture. And yeah, sure, the ad-generated enragement feeds don't help. But it is clearly mostly the small town kid getting exposed to more ideas thing, no question.
- carapace 6y agoHeck, when I was growing up, just being a nerd was enough to catch flak. I was once literally called a "poindexter" by a shirtless yokel while travelling by train though the Midwest! Granted, there's always been an undercurrent of counter-culture in America. The Puritans had their witches. But by the 50's at least it was all buttoned up tight, and then exploded in the 60's and 70's, recoiled in the 80's, then everybody took a decade off in the 90's, and somehow in the 00's and 10's we all lost our fwcking minds. The thing about mainstream American culture is that it pretty much had been under the thumb of mass media and religion. That's why the whole "fake news" attack is so devastating: our news has been fake. I read Noam Chomsky at an impressionable age and I recall the realization that we (in the USA) were living in what I called a "media blackout". Anything "they" didn't want you to know was simply omitted. It worked so much better than the Russian system. But only until the Internet hit...
- mantas 6y agoAs non-american... I don't get offended when somebody mentions halloween or that green thing day. If people ask how was the celebration, I've no issues telling that I don't participate in said holidays and maybe introduce to my culture and what we do instead. I'd expect same response from me telling "merry christmas". As for political donations - one of the best things in my country is that non-personal political donations are banned, period. And personal donations are capped. There're safeguard to prevent bums from suddenly getting lots of money and donating that too.
- stazz1 6y agoThat sounds sensible and Scalia in the court said he didn't think such rules would make much difference. Still not happy about his call there.
- sandworm101 6y agoBanning commercial donations is a good idea, but difficult in reality. How do you handle commercial speech? What if a corporation wants to express its opinion using its own money? That is common in the US. Can a company come out for/against a new law, a proposed project, a pipeline?
- mantas 6y agoSpecifically donations to political parties and individual politicians are banned. If a corporation wants to run a media campaign on social issues - that's fine. But if an ad features a politician, especially leading up to election, that'd be treated as illegal political ad. The legal way to do is through legal lobyist. Companies can pay them and certified lobyists can talk to institutions/individuals/parties. But meetings are semi-public and the public is +/- aware of what is lobying what. Lobyists can't give gifts to politicians, otherwise they risk their license. There's a workaround though. Politicians love to establish NGOs, then corporations donate to NGOs and politicians go on speaking tour in the name of NGO to cash out. But at least that limits use of corporate money for over-the-top election campaigns.
- 6y ago
- manfredo 6y agoIs a whiteboard political? If I buy a whiteboard from Staples, and draw a confederate flag and some hate speech it does not get erased automatically. Have the whiteboard manufacturers made a political statement because their products do not censor hate speech? I'm skeptical of this claim they everything is political. A forum they hosted any and all content will definitely host political speech, but those are the politics of the users not the site. Your kind of rhetoric seems like an attempt to say that hosting something is equivalent to an endorsement of it. This is not at all the case.
- sandworm101 6y agoWhere was the whiteboard manufactured? Did the frame use Canadian aluminum?
- zo1 6y agoThen there is that pesky issue of it being a Whiteboard.
- sandworm101 6y agoMost stuff from canada comes in white these days. The country is litterally covered in snow at the moment.
- bird_monster 6y agoIf content is posted onto a site that is obviously hateful, the site has the choice to keep it up or take it down. The outcome of that choice is a political act (to not act is to act). The severity of the hate speech might matter, but ultimately regardless of which path they take, they've taken a path. In your whiteboard analogy, if you were giving an interview to a candidate and walked into a meeting room that had a swastika on a whiteboard and opted not to erase it, as a candidate I would assume that was an endorsement. Not taking a side is taking the side of whoever is being most aggressive. "I don't want to get involved" is getting involved.
- 6y ago
- leetcrew 6y agomost of this only applies to social media companies. there are business models, even in tech, that simply don't revolve around user-generated content. but yeah, if you host mass UGC and have moderation, you can't really escape the political implications. > How do you deal with employees expressing their opinions at work? have a policy that work comms are only for discussion of work-related topics. keeping politics outside the permanent record is probably beneficial for everyone, and people are usually less nasty in person anyway. you'll probably end up with only a handful of employees who routinely start arguments over non work-related topics. after a couple warnings, it's time to "separate" them from the company. > There are right and left-wing plans (birth control etc). this is currently not an issue for the company. per ACA, employers are required to cover birth control in their health plans. > The holidays are comming. Do your employees say "merry christmas" or "happy holidays"? I really don't believe many people care about this. I work with people of every major faith, and it has literally never been an issue. if you want to be extra neutral, you can get rid of company holidays and just give everyone a little extra PTO. this way the company doesn't have to play the delicate game of deciding which faith's holidays to recognize. tl;dr: I don't think any of this stuff is terribly hard to sidestep. many tech companies choose not to; I suspect they feel they benefit from playing the game.
- sandworm101 6y agoThere are exceptions to the ACA mandate. Small/closely held corporations (most startups) can opt out if they have religeous objections. Last time i looked there was no price difference between such plans. So if you are a small business, by not opting out you are taking a side. The system abhores indecision and so will make them for you.
- dk775 6y agoA lot of b2b firms deal with political issues - Axon, Microsoft, hosting companies, etc. many of them are in the position where they will be approached to do a function for a government entity at some point and their decision, if not compelled, will have political ramifications.