5 ms·
I have a pet theory on why tipping remains popular in America. It goes something like this: Americans want the illusion of choice, even if they repeatedly make
by keiferski 6y ago
I have a pet theory on why tipping remains popular in America. It goes something like this: Americans want the illusion of choice, even if they repeatedly make the same predictable choices. So, even if most people just add 15-20% (whatever the local norm is), they, in theory, have the ability to pay more or less, depending on the service. If the tip was factored into the price, the customer would lose that ability, even if they don’t actually use it very often, if at all.
- cmdshiftf4 6y agoAmericans also use tipping as a status signal, despite it being socially grotesque. Even here on HN we'll regularly witness people proudly proclaiming that they've tipped 50% or more for "good" service. Not content with showing off their status to whoever had the poor fortune to be dining with them, and the waiter/waitress that served the group, they also relish in the opportunity of soaking randoms online in their lavishness post-factum.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoThe amazing thing I’ve seen is tipping makes people feel better just like charity makes them feel better. The little aspect of having the power to treat someone with your funds is a nice ego boost. Paying more in taxes or increasing the minimum wage doesn’t have the same effect, even though it would result in a more egalitarian society. The power to select who received the benefit from you is important.
- cmwelsh 6y agoIs there something wrong with tipping 50%? I didn’t realize my actions could be considered “socially grotesque”. Hospitality staff absolutely don’t mind extra money - I know from experience.
- Dayshine 6y agoIf you have the money to give away, perhaps use it more efficiently and give it to charity. Deliberately overpaying is a bad thing when you're either feeding a company or gifting a stranger, neither of which need the money anywhere near as much.
- bobbean 6y agoPeople don't need to spend their money on the most optimal thing that benefits society. They can spend their money however they want. If they want to give it to a kind stranger who made their day better, who are you to tell them not to. I've had some awesome servers who have genuinely made me happier when I need it, screw it, I'll give them money to say thank you.
- SilasX 6y agoThat's what the term "virtue signaling" is for. (or one of the things)
- tshaddox 6y agoSounds very similar to the stereotypical concept of American “freedom,” which has very little to do with maximizing the actual diversity of options one has to choose from.
- rhino369 6y agoMy theory is that culturally enforced typing is self perpetuating due to a collective action problem. I would absolutely stop tipping, but all I'd be doing is screwing a waiter out of their pay. The only way to end it, is if we all collectively decided to stop the practice so that waiters could negotiate a real wage.
- anonunivgrad 6y agoNo, we like it because it gets us better service, at least the way we define better. Europeans are fine with less attentive waiters, but Americans are not. There's no sinister or complicated sociological reason beyond that.