9 ms·
The fact that a D major is a different hand-shape than a C major lets me recognize where on the keys I should have my hand to play them -- like the ridges on th
by jazzyjackson 6y ago
The fact that a D major is a different hand-shape than a C major lets me recognize where on the keys I should have my hand to play them -- like the ridges on the F/J keys on a qwerty give you the home row, the uneven placement of black keys makes the middle C obvious by sight and by feel.
And this next part is just conjecture but I think the uniqueness of each chord aides in muscle memory, that is, it's a feature not a bug that a b minor feels different in my hand than an a minor, makes it easier to recall that specific hand arrangement.
Makes it easier to look over one's shoulder and know exactly what chord they're playing too!
- thomastjeffery 6y agoIt's not without its benefits, but I think it's also important to recognize the faults. Frankly, I think the problem of knowing "where" is less important than it seems. There are plenty of pieces that demand the player move their hand pretty far without much opportunity to feel for placement. Eric Satie's Gymnopedie No.1 comes to mind. I find that fixed seating tends to make this a non-issue. Even so, we could add nubs. There isn't a law against it. > it's a feature not a bug that a b minor feels different in my hand than an a minor But should it? After all, they are both the same Aeolian mode. They sound the same, excepting only that they are in different keys. Shouldn't they feel that way, too? > Makes it easier to look over one's shoulder and know exactly what chord they're playing too! Does it? It's pretty trivial to tell what chord a guitar player is playing, even if it's a bar. I don't see any reason it would be more difficult with a homogeneous piano/keyboard layout.
- veridies 6y agoThere are about 40 different barre chords you would commonly play, not including minors and thinking only of the two most common hand shapes. On the piano, there would be roughly 80, and you wouldn't be able to get some guidance based on shape like you could with those 44.
- bluGill 6y agoIf a and b minor sound the same you need a better tuner who understands that tuning is a compromise and making everything the same is unmusical. Down with equal temperament!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dehrmann 6y agoPeople who play fretless instruments and trombone players are able to figure out where they're playing with just one marker.
- yongjik 6y agoIt's not unusual for a piano piece to require huge jump almost instantly, e.g., here in Beethoven's Sonata Op 111, the left hand jumps three and a half octaves down - https://youtu.be/WGg9cE-ceso?t=423 https://youtu.be/WGg9cE-ceso?t=423 Having a row of identical keys would make such a jump virtually impossible to get right. As far as I know, string instruments (like violins) usually don't require such a wide jump - well in case of a violin, you literally don't have the distance!
- thomasahle 6y ago> Having a row of identical keys would make such a jump virtually impossible to get right. You could color each octave in a different color. Would make the jump much easier than now, while at the same time preserve the similarity of chords.
- pclmulqdq 6y agoMost of the time, jumps like that are done by touch. You often need to look at something else like the music, the other hand, or the conductor.
- dehrmann 6y agoThat's a valid requirement, but having to play scales and chords differently in every key is a pretty big price for that.
- mantap 6y agoJust make the keys have different shapes. There is no need to have the information encoded in the layout.