3 ms·
His figure incorporates both jobless workers — people who were actively searching for work in the past month — as well as adults who are earning below $20,000 a
by arp242 6y ago
His figure incorporates both jobless workers — people who were actively searching for work in the past month — as well as adults who are earning below $20,000 a year, or below the poverty line.
- WalterBright 6y agoIt's a more meta observation that "poverty" has many subjective definitions. Certainly many (not all) people we would consider living in poverty today would be considered well off even 100 years ago. For example, owning a functioning automobile was a huge luxury only for the rich 100 years ago. For another example, the terms of the debate have shifted. It used to be about the objective state of the poor people. Today it is less about that and more about the subjective state of poor people relative to the state of wealthy people, i.e. "inequality".
- arp242 6y agoOwning a car wasn't a requirement to get anywhere 100 years ago though, or to hold a job, whereas it is for many areas/people now. Or another example: I really don't like smartphones, for all sorts of reasons not worth getting in to here. But having one is sort-of a requirement these days since all kinds of services are only available as a phone app, and many company's primary method of contact is WhatsApp, and a lot of social life happens on there as well. Of course you can go without one, but it's debilitating. There are a few more things like this. Income has risen, but so have mandatory costs for a normal life.
- WalterBright 6y agoIf you don't like the car example, pick an attribute where poor people 100 years ago were better off than today.
- arp242 6y agoI think this is missing the point. You can always point to people who have it worse off throughout all of history.
- WalterBright 6y agoAny average metric where poor people were better off 100 years ago will do.
- arp242 6y agoI think we're talking a bit past each other here; I don't deny that on average poor people were generally worse off 100 years ago (although I'm not a student of history, so there may be some nuance here, or not, I'm not sure), but I don't think that's important here. Of course "poverty" is subjective, but IMHO it's a disgrace that (working!) people struggle to make ends meet every month, and would definitely classify that as "poverty". That peasants 100 years ago had it worse is just irrelevant here, in my view. I'm not entirely sure what the intention of your comment was, but by your reasoning we could relativise every war as "it's not as bad as WWII" or every pandemic as "it's not as bad as the black death", and that doesn't strike me as a helpful or constructive way to deal with the problems that exist in the here and now.