8 ms·
I used to hate microsoft for locking us into shitty software for decades. But looking back I see that they gave us all an enormous windfall in the form of como
by m463 6y ago
I used to hate microsoft for locking us into shitty software for decades.
But looking back I see that they gave us all an enormous windfall in the form of comoditized hardware with decades of hardware growth. (hardware is the complement of OS software, so drive hardware costs down and OS sales go up)
You would think Apple as a hardware company would open up software to increase hardware sales, but instead it seems to try to control everything so it is fighting a battle on multiple fronts.
- Bud 6y agoNobody who actually understands Apple's business and how it works "would think" this.
- m463 6y agoYeah, maybe. They are driving the price of software to zero which helps ios and macos device sales. But I think if they work hard to close things they might end up with a bigger part of a smaller pie. I don't know, maybe they don't need help from people on the outside and can do it all themselves.
- dang 6y agoOk, but instead of putting down someone who knows less, please share some of what you know so the rest of us can learn something. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html (a recent longer explanation of this principle, for anyone who cares, is https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25130956 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25130956)
- Bud 6y agoYou're right. Again.
- tachyonbeam 6y agoApple started out open. The Apple II has 7 extension slots and loads of peripherals available. It was also user serviceable. This is what Steve Wozniak wanted, and it worked, it was a smashing success. Steve Jobs, on the other hand, had another vision for the company, where Apple would control the user experience. The Macintosh Plus had just two extension slots, and users couldn't open the case, you needed a special extra long screwdriver.
- linguae 6y agoExactly; Steve Jobs envisioned a closed architecture for the Mac. Thankfully for Mac users who wanted a more open experience, Apple released the Macintosh II in 1987, which was styled similarly to PCs and had six NuBus expansion slots. From then until the release of the cylindrical Mac Pro in 2013, Apple always had Macs with expansion slots in its lineup. From 2013 to 2019 Apple didn’t sell Macs with internal expansion slots, but Apple resumed selling internally expandable Macs once the current “cheese grater” Mac Pro was released, albeit at a significantly higher price point compared to the 2006-12 cheese grater Mac Pro.
- pjmlp 6y agoOn the contrary. There was nothing open about NuBus, Quicktime, QuickDraw, QuickDraw 3D,.... Apple's platforms like every other 16 bit computer, with exception of IBM PC clones, was always its own eco-system.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y ago> You would think Apple as a hardware company would open up software to increase hardware sales, but instead it seems to try to control everything so it is fighting a battle on multiple fronts. Purely on the business perspective, Apple has seen tremendous benefit with their locked ecosystem and vertical integration. Bringing that strategy to the PC market was bound to happen and it's likely going to work extraordinarily well for their share holders if performance/productivity benefits (from Apple Silicon) at low-mid end forces traditional PC consumers to Mac. On the consumer perspective, Would we accept a $1000 PC couple of years back with no means to install other Operating System (Officially), Only 3-5 years of updates(if lucky), Use only manufacturer approved apps, Repair only at their approved centres? Then why did we accept it to be a norm for >$1000 smartphones? We made them smell money with our consumer decisions to trade 'freedom in computation' in smartphones and it's now coming to haunt us with personal computers. The line between Smartphones and PCs have been blurred with Apple Silicon, Google will do it with their Chromebooks(which was already happening even without their custom silicon [Update cycle, Locked boot-loaders etc.]) and Microsoft with their Surface line up.
- zaroth 6y agoThere’s never been more diverse software, more readily and easily available, than there is today (mainly due to the web and app stores). Software has never been easier to write, to distribute, or to monetize. Users don’t care about if the platform is “open” or if they can install Linux. In fact, in many cases, the things are a massive source of pain to end users that want devices that just work, which the iPhone and iPad largely do. It’s also, by the way, never been easier to build your own hardware from ready-made components and platforms. I don’t know why we should lament users choosing devices that are easy, fun and reliable to use, and that provide them with single tap access to massive software libraries and entice them to pay for that software. Seems like an absolute win to me.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoIf the early pioneers of Computers & Internet thought the same way we wouldn't be even having this conversation. I think they made conscious decisions to keep computing out of total control by capitalism. Unfortunately we've failed them & ourself with our consumer decisions.
- ranit 6y agoIt was not Microsoft, it was IBM that “gave us” commoditized hardware.
- tluyben2 6y agoIt was MS who forced it big; they wanted standardisation on both professional and 'home computers'; IBM PC (clones) and MSX[0] respectively, both running MS software. MSX failed, but the idea was the same; a hardware standard everyone would adhere to and MS would have the software for. MS was a huge factor in making that happen; no-one knows what would've happened if they would not have done that. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSX
- Someone 6y agoI don’t think Microsoft had anything to do with the PC hardware becoming open. IBM chose commodity hardware. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Personal_Computer#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Personal_Computer#History: “The idea of acquiring Atari was considered, but rejected in favor of a proposal by Lowe that by forming an independent internal working group and abandoning all traditional IBM methods, a design could be delivered within a year, and a prototype within 30 days. The prototype worked poorly, but was presented with a detailed business plan which proposed that the new computer have an open architecture, use non-proprietary components and software, and be sold through retail stores, all contrary to IBM practice” That was before even the choice for a CPU was made (makes me wonder how prototypical that prototype was), so I don’t see how Microsoft would have been involved at the time.
- ThrowawayR2 6y agoWhen IBM lost control of the PC market when Compaq and other clones started coming out and their proprietary PS/2 PCs were rejected by the market, the power to define what a PC was fell into the hands of Microsoft, who still holds it today through their Windows hardware certification program. It is Microsoft who is keeping PC hardware open, albeit probably more because of fear of more anti-trust scrutiny than any altruistic motives.
- bitwize 6y agoApple is in the business of selling systems that work to end users. Unfortunately, the only way that they can provide that assurance is total control over both the hardware and the software. In fact I suspect that within ten or so years, Apple will eliminate the final dependency -- on NVIDIA -- and migrate the Mac (and everything else) to a custom ISA.
- justinclift 6y agoWhat dependency on Nvidia do Apple have? From memory, Apple haven't used Nvidia in any of their products in years due to bad Nvidia behaviour ages ago.
- bitwize 6y agoThey are an ARM licensee. ARM was acquired by NVIDIA. If there's bad blood between NVIDIA and Apple, all the more reason for Apple to drop ARM and go with a custom, Apple-designed ISA.
- alacombe 6y agoARM is a joint-venture between Apple and Acorn, each had 43% of the capital back in 1996. Apple has a lifetime architecture license, they couldn't care less about who own ARM...
- jamil7 6y agoNot sure Apple would ever go completely custom, their MO when they need a component is to try to find something existing first (webkit, llvm) and adapt it. If there was bad blood they’d sooner adopt RISCV.
- nindalf 6y agoApple has a lifetime license for ARM. There is nothing Nvidia can do to Apple on this front or any other. But more than that, Nvidia needs Apple. Apple selling ARM macs to developers means that all developer tool chains are being updated to support ARM. This is vital to Nvidia’s plans of ARM server chips. It would never have been a reality without the M1 or something like it.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoAnother way to look at it: Microsoft forced PC buyers to use their software by making deals with OEMs to preinstall it on every PC, hiding the cost of the software from the consumer. Most consumers did not purchase a PC with no software installed, and then purchase a license to Windows separately; the software and license came with the computer. There are probably more similarities between Apple and Microsoft than there are differences, however tempting it may be to focus on the differences. People love to criticise the RPi. It has its flaws and shortcomings. Nevertheless, it is a rare example of a computer that does not come with an "OS" preinstalled. Buyers can choose from a variety of OS and make their own bootable SD cards.
- RuggedPineapple 6y agoThe raspberry pi does have an OS preinstalled that users cant remove, which is why its so hard to get full support for the basic linux stack on there. The GPU has a proprietary low level OS/firmware blob that handles basic system functions and loading linux and starting the CPU once all that is done and is required for the board to start. This is a big part of why Armbian/Ubuntu dont have full support yet for example. Its not impossible but its weird and complex for OS developers and one of the strengths of the alternative boards, which can generally boot and run a full linux stack with hardware support for everything on the board.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Roritharr 6y agoWhat's the best RPi alternative in your opinion?
- RuggedPineapple 6y agoI drool over the Odroid N2+, but mostly I just use a Raspberry Pi. 32 bit Raspbian is fine for me and most of it works fine (although the fake kernel mode switching video driver is less then ideal) and i don't really care to lose the huge community for when I need to figure out an issue. Makes figuring out problems a google search solution and not a debug probe solution.
- flohofwoe 6y ago> Apple as a hardware company Apple is now (primarily) a software-service company, and from that point of view, a locked-up platform makes a lot of business sense (unfortunately). Selling hardware is only the first step in locking customers into their service-ecosystem. In this new Apple world, app-developers are essentially Uber/Lyft-style gig-workers, not independent businesses.
- toyg 6y ago> Apple is now (primarily) a software-service company They like to tell everyone that, but it's still very much a lie. More than 50% of their revenues come straight from iPhone hardware sales. Services are barely under 18%, and that includes absolutely everything they can throw in there (icloud, appstore, etc). Everything else is hardware. Apple is a hardware company that is desperately trying to ensure their future when, inevitably, they'll get a few iPhones wrong and consumers will move on. It's a bit like Persian Gulf countries investing in airlines and anything else to ensure they'll have a future when oil runs out.
- alisonkisk 6y agoApple has made many hardware mistakes and will continue to do so. All their software is designed to sell hardware; they rarely support non-Apple hardware.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoBusiness is conservative. If it stops making bucketloads of money with the current formula then they will change. Otherwise expect the same for as long as it works for them.
- kube-system 6y agoApple's marketing approach is primarily to view hardware and software as inseparable parts of the same product. Their main differentiator in the market is their ability to control the end-user experience to a greater degree than their competitors. They are probably of the opinion that opening up software would decrease their target customer satisfaction and subsequently decrease sales.
- alisonkisk 6y agoIBM did that by licensing the PC "clone" design, not Microsoft. Microsoft added the lockdown layer on top.
- pjmlp 6y agoThey did not license anything, Compaq stole it from them.