5 ms·
Wikipedia says damage is proportional to axle weight to the 4th power: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_weight#cite_ref-13 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ve
by adrianN 6y ago
Wikipedia says damage is proportional to axle weight to the 4th power: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_weight#cite_ref-13 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_weight#cite_ref-13
- chrismorgan 6y agoI remember my dad telling me that when I was in my late teens. That it’s the fourth power startled me. To give an idea of what this means: For a 50 tonne semi-trailer with five axles, (⁵⁰⁄₅)⁴ = 10,000 units of damage. 2 tonne vehicle with two axles, 1 unit of damage. That one truck, only 25 times as heavy as a pretty heavy car, is doing 10,000 times as much damage to the road. Thus indeed if you have basically any heavy freight at all on a road, the rest is negligible.
- scrumbledober 6y agoI noticed while driving to Tahoe the last time that the right lane on the mountain roads was absolutely trashed in the tire path. I assume this is mostly due to chain usage, but it was incredibly more present in the right lane where semis drive.
- b212 6y agoWow, I always knew the semis are ruining roads but this 10k factor just blew me away, crazy! Thanks for a great post.
- brownbat 6y agoAnd, by implication, they're a massively higher contributor to local pollution. I was surprised to learn that most road pollution is no longer generated by tailpipes, but by the grinding of brake, tire, and road into dust through friction. Vehicle weight has an outsized effect there too.
- handol 6y ago> Thus indeed if you have basically any heavy freight at all on a road, the rest is negligible. Racetracks don't carry freight, but the surface does goes bad in a couple decades.
- sho_hn 6y ago> Thus indeed if you have basically any heavy freight at all on a road, the rest is negligible. There's many more passenger cars than freight trucks on the roads. It doesn't change the math all that much, but the 1-to-1 comparisons in the thread didn't account for this factor.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoThe last time this was posted I dug in to this and it appeared as though 2 vs 4 tires per axle was not tested, in the original or follow up paper usually referenced. They were testing trucks vs trucks with the same axle type, but different numbers of axles (hence axle weight instead of vehicle weight). It could be that four tires on a truck axle are much more effective at spreading the weight than two car tires. Or it could be that it's not much better, as the forces are still placed on a relatively small area of asphalt. How this makes cars and trucks compare is, as far as I could understand from the literature when I dug in to it, an untested open question. There could be a 10,000 factor difference. Or if two tires at each end are spreading the weight over 2x the surface area and you assume that matters, then you have to divide that 10,000 by 2^4 and it's now only 625x as damaging. I suspect the reason nobody cares enough to test this is that it would still be a gap large enough to make cars insignificant.
- dumbfounder 6y agoThe 4th power claim is alarming, yes. But are we focused too much on road wear and not enough on the money spent to increase the capacity of roads? My gut says that widening a road is at least an order of magnitude more expensive than maintaining one, so whatever we can do to reduce the number of cars is more worthy of focus than just getting all the trucks off the road.
- a1369209993 6y agoFWIW, if we assume it's based on tire weight, a 50-tonne 18-wheeler actually does (50/9)^4 ≈ 952.6 times as much damage, not 625. > I suspect the reason nobody cares enough to test this is that it would still be a gap large enough to make cars insignificant. That seems likely, yes.
- reitzensteinm 6y agoRight, because you don't double up the two front wheels which are used for steering. I suspect that more weight is put on the rear and trailer axles than the front as well, and that two tires in close proximity aren't as good as two tires separated by greater distance. So even 1000x is probably optimistic. My main point though is just that the study happened to use truck axles as a measurement and that can't blindly be substituted for car axles. The back of the napkin math is just there to show the difference it can potentially make.
- Someone 6y ago100 kg bicycle (including rider), 0.00000625 units of damage. So, getting people out of their cars onto bicycles cuts road maintenance cost. Because of that, building bike lanes/paths can be cheaper than not building them. (And 50 tonne trucks are very rare on most city roads, I hope)
- Aerroon 6y agoThere is one issue though. Bike lanes tend to require better road conditions for people to want to use them. Roads do degrade over time due to weather. This means that the difference between a vehicle at x weight vs no vehicle at all will be negligible. I don't know what the x is though.
- 0xB31B1B 6y agothe vast majority of road degredation isn't due to weather, its due to weight wear. As heavy vehicles travel down the road, they create a "ripple" on the road surface in front of the axle. You can create a similar effect if you run your hand across a loose sheet on top of your bed (you will see the wrinkle in the sheet in front if your hand). This bending is the method of road wear that causes like 99% of the maintenance need.
- bobthepanda 6y agoFrost heaving is also a significant contributor to road wear in winter areas.
- myself248 6y agoIf that were the case, then roads would be almost equally bad everywhere regardless of the weather. As a Michigander, the dictionary does not contain words to express how strongly I disagree with that implication.
- labawi 6y agoWhile I may disagree with GP about the exact method of wear, regional differences are mostly due to construction not weather or wear. Roads ~50km west of us look almost new, while ours usually develop potholes or at minimum cracks, within a year. It's a different country, so different standards.
- megablast 6y agoExcept we need trucks. We don’t need private cars.
- hallway_monitor 6y agoMaybe you don't, don't assume to know my needs
- chrismorgan 6y agoA very substantial portion of truck freight in countries like Australia and the USA is inter-city—almost all, for larger semi-trailers and B-doubles. But for inter-city freight, rail is much cheaper than road, once you account for all costs, rather than allowing society and passenger cars to subsidise the roads for trucks.
- sagarm 6y agoWe need transportation networks for goods. Rail is at least one alternative.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y agoThat is insane. I will remember this for life now.