4 ms·
if you care about democracy at all — then get out and vote YES TO AV. Get a grip. If one cares about democracy "at all" then they need to go out and vote Yes t
by petercooper 16y ago
if you care about democracy at all — then get out and vote YES TO AV.
Get a grip. If one cares about democracy "at all" then they need to go out and vote Yes to one extremely narrow option that's only, arguably, mildly better than the status quo? This is nothing more than an appeal to emotion.
- MikeTaylor 16y agoYou misrepresented the call to vote here by trimming the quote down too far. What the original article says is: "Please: if you’ve ever complained about how our politicians don’t represent us and the people who do represent us can’t get elected; if you’re sick of having to choose between two lizards; if you care about democracy at all — then get out and vote YES TO AV." So I did make an actual case, rather than just appealing to emotion.
- petercooper 16y agoYou made a case but wrapped it up with an appeal to which way someone should vote. Sheepishly voting Yes because someone suggested they might not care about democracy otherwise is not very democratic. If someone cares about democracy, all they need to do is vote full-stop.
- Isofarro 16y agoI can't remember the last time the UK had a referendum about voting reform, and based on that it's quite tough to figure out when the next one will be if the winning result is "No". A clear "No to AV" may be interpreted that no voting reform is needed.
- corin_ 16y agoThere has never been a referendum about voting reform before in the UK (in fact, the only single previous referendum that was nation-wide was more than 35 years ago, and was related to our membership in the EEC).
- NickPollard 16y agoMildy better than the status quo is still better than the status quo. Don't fall into the trap of the Status Quo fallacy; vote for your preference about the two options you are given, don't abstain just because you're waiting for the 'perfect' option (hint: it doesn't exist).