4 ms·
Your sample size is too small. In my experience with thousands of servers with 64-512GB of ECC ram, not very many of them will have any ECC reports during use.
by toast0 6y ago
Your sample size is too small. In my experience with thousands of servers with 64-512GB of ECC ram, not very many of them will have any ECC reports during use. Usually, everything works fine, but sometimes something will go wrong, and it's nice to know.
Of course, that's when I'm not paying the bills. I don't have ECC on my home systems, because of added expense, lower performance (no XMP ECC ram when I was shopping), and extra research needed. If a consumer oriented motherboard says it supports ECC, that may mean it lets you use ECC ram, but doesn't enable any of the reporting, which would be mostly useless; not completely useless, because used ECC ram from server retirements is sometimes very inexpensive, but it's often fully buffered, which is less likely to work in consumer platforms.
- marcan_42 6y ago> If a consumer oriented motherboard says it supports ECC, that may mean it lets you use ECC ram, but doesn't enable any of the reporting, which would be mostly useless That is largely a feature of OS software, not the motherboard. Linux on AMD motherboards which support ECC has reporting. There is no reason why it wouldn't. If the ECC is there and active, Linux can get the information (EDAC). On Intel though, they flat out fuse ECC off on consumer CPUs for market segmentation reasons. If you want a consumer motherboard with ECC, you go AMD.
- qwertox 6y ago> it lets you use ECC ram, but doesn't enable any of the reporting Is there any special term which does describe this capability? How would I find out if that reporting exists? Only by reading the Manual and looking through the BIOS pages?
- toast0 6y agoYeah, I think you have to read through the manual, or contact support to confirm or find a review that specifically addressed it; unfortunately.
- Laforet 6y agoIn my own experience almost every motherboard will happily accept unbuffered ECC ram and ignore the parity bit. Registered DIMMs, however, will only work with both MCH and BIOS support so I don't expect them to work unless explicitly stated in the specs.