6 ms·
Thanks for the info (didn't know this) Isn't there something inherently wrong with society when an industry that provides little value to society make so much
by ThomPete 16y ago
Thanks for the info (didn't know this)
Isn't there something inherently wrong with society when an industry that provides little value to society make so much money that they can afford to pay better than anyone else?
- JonWood 16y agoYes, there is certainly something wrong with it, but for some reason the entire country is effectively owned by the banking industry at the moment (despite the fact the country in fact owns a good chunk of the banking industry). Personally I'd quite like to see the government actually tax them at decent rates, and call the bluff that they're all going to up and leave if they have to contribute to the country. The chances of that happening when the current government all made a fortune in investment and banking careers is low though.
- gaius 16y agoI don't know where you get that "little value to society" nonsense from. Asset allocation is a non-trivially hard problem, and the alternative to doing it our way is Five Year Plans and the like, which tend to result - and this is actual, historical fact - in tens of millions of people starving.
- wazzles 16y agoYea it's definitely a non trivial problem to rip people off with as much success as the likes of Goldman. IBs are completely socially useless, excessively criminal, and for the most part just exploit clients through front-running etc. I used to work for one, now I work for a startup that actually makes stuff. Happy days.
- ThomPete 16y agoYou seem to be confusing what is difficult with what is beneficial to society. But if how hard a problem is would be an indication of how beneficial then there are plenty of jobs that is grossly underpaid. You also seem to be assuming that there can be only two possible solutions to this problem. But please don't let your strawmen be my burden.
- gaius 16y agoNo - my point is that countries that have sophisticated financial services industries have historically been extremely unlikely to make catastropic errors of asset allocation resulting in famine, etc. If we had a group - let's call it The Party - deciding what to invest where, and they ballsed it up, then you get the Great Leap Forward (30M starving to death is half the population of the UK).
- ThomPete 16y agoAnd where exactly did I promote such a solution?
- Nrsolis 16y agoRight where you made a value judgement about the "value" the algorithmic component of the financial services sector provides to society.
- geebee 16y agoI'd rather live in a country with lots of lawyers and bankers than none. And some of these lawyers and bankers are, without question, very valuable to society. People who look favorably on these industries would probably describe the rent-collection or wealth-destroying activities of these sectors as the regrettable but minor (and maybe inevitable) byproduct effect of an activity that is, on the balance, very positive. We all have these types - high tech has patent trolls (er, innovative technology development partnerships), but nobody would say that the tech sector is a rent-collecting segment of the economy (though many would say that patent trolls are part of the legal industry, not the high tech industry). Other people like Wooley at the LSE (quoted in the article) take a far dimmer view: “The amount of rent capture has been huge,” Woolley said. “Investment banking, prime broking, mergers and acquisitions, hedge funds, private equity, commodity investment—the whole scale of activity is far too large.” I asked Woolley how big he thought the financial sector should be. “About a half or a third of its current size,” he replied"
- adaml_623 16y agoI think there are more than 2 alternatives to the Asset Allocation problem. There's no need to polarise the debate by saying that the alternative to Banker Bonuses (and the rest of the system) is millions of people starving.
- arethuza 16y agoFalse dichotomy - the choice isn't between a completely unregulated financial system and Stalin.
- geebee 16y agoJohn Cassidy wrote a piece for the New Yorker titled "what good is wall street?" that takes a dim view of the economic usefulness of the financial sector (1) http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/11/29/101129fa_fact_cassidy http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/11/29/101129fa_fact_... It's a long article, but this is probably the strongest case for banking as rent-collection (or even worth, wealth-destruction) you'll read in the mainstream press (ie., as opposed to academic journals). (1) not an opposition to banking per se, which he sees as immensely valuable
- whyleyc 16y ago"an industry that provides little value to society" Whilst this is a nice popular statement to trot out in the current climate, it is simply not true, at least not in fiscal terms. Some facts: * The financial services industry accounted for 10% of GDP in 2009 * It provides 4% of total employment in the UK (1 million jobs) * It contributes 28% of the UK’s total exports of services * It contributed £53.4bn in tax in 2009/10 (11% of total government receipts) Much as everyone would like to say "sod the bankers, let them go elsewhere", the truth is doing so would likely torpedo the economy. Source: http://217.154.230.218/NR/rdonlyres/E01CD45A-053F-4C9B-BDAA-2E16CF668268/0/BC_RS_ContributionofFinancialServicesintheUK.pdf http://217.154.230.218/NR/rdonlyres/E01CD45A-053F-4C9B-BDAA-...
- wazzles 16y agoUm, nice try. Takes a lot of 50 billions to add up to 1.5 trillion. Especially when you include interest. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfinance/8262037/Bank-bail-out-adds-1.5-trillion-to-debt.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/banksandfina...
- whyleyc 16y agoYou're assuming two things here: (1) The country would have been better off financially not to bail the banks out and let them burn (2) The nationalised banks won't end up turning a profit for taxpayers in the long run anyway Both of which could be considered shaky assumptions. See Robert Peston's analysis on this very topic for more: http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/robertpeston/2010/03/can_taxpayers_profit_from_nort.html http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/thereporters/robertpeston/2010/03...
- ThomPete 16y agoThe day that the banks choose to bail out it's customers I might consider changing my opinioin about the value the provide to society. (not saying that they don't provide any)
- 16y ago
- Nrsolis 16y agoThom, if you're so convinced that the financial industry provides so little benefit to modern society, why don't you try and live in a country without one. The Great Depression in the US (which effectively wiped out a significant portion of the financial industry here) was the source of much misery and pain. Pick up a book on bond valuation and capital allocation and tell me if YOU would like to do that work for yourself. Finance is hard won and specialized knowledge. Don't dismiss that expertise.
- ThomPete 16y agoWhy the strawman? I never said it wasn't of any value. I have repeatedly clarified that I am talking in the context of this article and about certain parts of the financial industry, namely the part can afford to pay better than anyone else. The developers working on your average netbank aren't in question here their salaries are not extreme. All I am saying is that the kind of developers that the OP is talking about are being lost to parts of the financial industry that aren't providing value to society but primarily to themselves and I find that problematic. That has nothing to do with my view of other parts of the banking industry.
- Nrsolis 16y agoThey aren't being "lost" to the financial industry. They are proving "value" to the consumers of those (valuable) services. You could make the same argument for home health care workers and cardiac nurses. Potential home health care workers aren't "lost" to the nursing industry. Society VALUES what they provide to a greater degree because it compensates them more. You seem to be laboring under the assumption that a career in the financial services industry is a guarantee of high-income. The truth is quite different. Life in the financial services industry has its own downsides (insecurity of income, long hours, poor working conditions generally) which you seem to be glossing over to make your argument. On my last flight to Mountain View, I sat next to a guy who left a job at Goldman Sachs (as a broker) to go do ad sales for Google. His reason: better working conditions and quality of life. Don't assume that your choices are everyone else's. The high pay in the financial services industry is there because the work is hard and few people can or are willing to do it.