10 ms·
I often see this stuff and every result from every person I've seen is that fingerprints are unique. Even with DNT enabled, tools like uBlock, privacy badger (a
by godelski 6y ago
I often see this stuff and every result from every person I've seen is that fingerprints are unique. Even with DNT enabled, tools like uBlock, privacy badger (an EFF tool!), etc people are still unique. How does one actually become not unique? I'm on Apple hardware, so I can't imagine my hardware is unique (other than silicon lottery) and using Firefox. Testing in Safari shows "nearly unique" (1 bit difference than my FF results) so I gotta imagine that near is myself.
How does one actually make themselves non-unique?
And can we make things more transparent? How many bits is enough?
- suifbwish 6y agoAre you kidding? Apple has all but stripped away the ability to make a profit from Apple users as they all identify as the same advertising ID now if you use the safari browser. Facebook stock took a huge hit right after that update.
- z3t4 6y agoWe cant do anything about our fingerprints. But we can make sure no one knows who the fingerprint belongs to.
- n0nc3 6y agoYou make yourself non-unique by looking like others. In that sense your privacy is limited by the precautions that others take. Turning off javascript is a very good thing to do. The more people that do it, the stronger a protection it will be.
- alquemist 6y agoWhat I want for Christmas is javascript disabled by default, plus one-click ability to enable for specific sites. Random browsing => no javascript. Play a browser game => javascript. I have this today with Flash, would be nice to have it for all client-side code execution.
- stickfigure 6y agoI use a Chrome extension called "Quick Javascript Switcher". If you click the icon in the bar, it switches JS off/on for the domain - using Chrome's built-in allow/block list for JS. I honestly could not live without it. At this point I have pretty much every news and recipe site on the internet blocked. Visiting a new site, as soon as I hear my fan spinning up I reach for the "no-JS" button and the page suddenly becomes responsive again. I'm not quite to the "no JS as default" level but I'm close.
- Rivosa 6y agoGenuine question: Why use Chrome? Google themselves admited they are an ad company rather than a search engine company. Why use a browser by a company where their main revenues are ads.
- stickfigure 6y agoI don't care? Of all the evils in the world, I just don't think advertising warrants much concern. I am tempted to use Firefox more to avoid browser monoculture. But Chrome pretty much just works.
- n0nc3 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NoScript https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NoScript
- alquemist 6y agoChristmas came early this year :) Thanks!
- eindiran 6y agoFor anyone considering taking the dive: NoScript takes a bit of time to get used to, but stick with it. You'll build up some things you are happy to whitelist, plus always have the backup option of disabling temporarily within a tab. In a week or two, your new workflow will feel completely natural.
- godelski 6y agoI don't buy this. A 2017 Macbook Air and Safari should be a pretty common setup, yet I am far from unique (more bits than the FF I'm running).
- mpeg 6y agoTurning off javascript actually makes your browser more unique, in most cases, as it's so rare for people to do.
- lultimouomo 6y agoBut it blocks a whole lot of other fingerprinting techniques, so I think the net output is decreasing your uniqueness.
- iguy 6y ago> You make yourself non-unique by looking like others. ... limited by the precautions that others take Yes. This is why it would ideally be done by the browser, not by individuals. If Safari reported only its top-level version number (and only exposed the installed-by-default fonts, and so on) then millions of others would suddenly look like me.
- nazgulnarsil 6y agoI'm guessing each one bit reduction decreases the number of people they can uniquely identify by half.
- monkeycantype 6y agoMaybe we need to run browsers in a virtual machines that poison data gathering by simulating rolling profiles populated with fake history and bookmarks, where all your real bookmarks, history, cookies and passwords are held outside of the browser by a separate program that interacts with the browser using an automation framework like puppeteer. I wonder what already exists like this?
- arminiusreturns 6y agoNow you are in sockpuppet land, and there are a few established companies that keep a low profile as is the modus operandi for the miccimac (curious about the term?, look up Ray McGovern)
- monkeycantype 6y agomaybe proxying my browsing via a sockpuppet, but rather than actively polluting the internet with automated traffic, I want my browser to be a library of garbage that punishes any attempt to analyse me. It's highly unlikely I'm going to do anything with this thought, but if I do I think I'll call it Lignin, after the complex structural compound in plants that no organism was able to digest for the first 60 million years after its appearance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lignin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lignin (I'm going to go read about mcgovern now.)
- arminiusreturns 6y agoI screwed the term up, its actually MICCIMAT
- bigiain 6y agoYou’d need to do this carefully, to avoid it standing out just as clearly as a unique tracking id. Its like if I were an analyst at a national security TLA, I’d treat TOR traffic as a big red “look at me!!!” flashing light. Sure, you _might_ be using TOR to anonymously report a pot hole to your local authorities, but you’re _way_ more likely than average to be doing something the government has “a war on”. (So as an analyst I’d assume you’re involved in drugs, terrorism, child abuse, or insisting on government accountability.) You probably don’t want “a library of garbage”, you probably want something a little smarter that breaks all your traffic into totally plausible “normal looking” traffic but with each stream (browser tab/website pair I guess in this context) looking like a different but totally “normal” session. So your HN session looks like a totally stock Win10 Edge browser session, but when you click over to (or open a tab to) eff.org, it changes to maybe a SamsungS20 session, and when you flip somewhere like NYT - all the page loads and the hundreds of tracking pixels all see what looks like a macOS Safari session. Do-able, I think, but more complex that simple “garbage” traffic. Needs stateful session inspection so it could do things like stripping referred headers when you change top level sites/urls, while sending them normally to image/xhr/tracking URL calls from within a site.
- thethirdone 6y agoMy results for cover your tracks is not unique (only 13 bits). Not enabling javascript prevents lots of fingerprinting.
- surround 6y agoThe Tor browser is really effective at preventing fingerprinting.
- sillysaurusx 6y agoNot really. Even something as small as maximizing your tor browser window can indicate to whoever's watching that you're one of N people using that same screen resolution. And sure, N is pretty big for popular websites. But the less popular the site, the less it holds up. Tor is about the most effective thing we have, but I'm not sure "really effective" is fair. It gets the job done sometimes, but it also leaves a lot to be desired. Still, I'm grateful Tor exists.
- deadwing0 6y agoWhen starting up Tor, aren't you confronted with a message about not maximizing the window? I wonder how many users follow that and leave it as is. Is there anything else that makes it not really effective?
- dymax78 6y ago>When starting up Tor, aren't you confronted with a message about not maximizing the window? I've never seen that message before, but that would explain why it always opens up 'windowed'.
- nitrohorse 6y agoI'm pretty sure that because Tor Browser ships w/ `privacy.resistFingerprinting.letterboxing` set to `true` by default since 9.0 [1] (Oct. 22 2019 [2]), users can resize the windows now without affecting their fingerprint. [1] https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/31059 https://trac.torproject.org/projects/tor/ticket/31059 [2] https://blog.torproject.org/new-release-tor-browser-90 https://blog.torproject.org/new-release-tor-browser-90
- ta3614305836241 6y ago
- saagarjha 6y agoYep, I don’t trust this very much. Two of the same iPhones that are fully updated and in the same region should be essentially indistinguishable by the things they mentioned.
- absolutelyrad 6y agoIt isn't. I've worked with a company in past that has the most advanced tech available. It can uniquely identify iPhones of same model/make/year/os/safari version in the same region under the same ip address. They promised that the tech would always give a stable and unique id from the browser. And it worked too, but it wasn't public and not for ad tech purposes.
- na85 6y agoPalantir? How would you defend against that profiling tech?
- saagarjha 6y agoHow does it work?
- from 6y agoNot the original commenter but my guess is that it is some kind of fine-grained CPU fingerprinting. Something like: http://s3.eurecom.fr/docs/ccs18_iskander.pdf http://s3.eurecom.fr/docs/ccs18_iskander.pdf
- spijdar 6y agoOh, fascinating. I've suspected this is possible for a long time, but have never seen any ideas on implementing it. I have a POWER9 desktop, and a fair share of other users do so for privacy/security concerns, pretty hardcore Tor browser guys and the like. I've mentioned before that fingerprinting firefox on ppc64le would be very easy because of timing the non-JIT'd JS engine. I guess there's potential for much more specific fingerprinting.
- mayneack 6y agoFor what its worth, I have mostly non-standard things and it thinks I'm not unique (18 bits) Brave, piehole, ubuntu, custom desktop computer. I didn't even disable javascript.
- bbirk 6y agoI had the same problem, but after setting tracking protection to strict in ff I am now only nearly-unique according to this test. Also this page [1] shows some more details around fingerprinting, although I don't know if it works the same as the page announced here. [1] https://amiunique.org/fp https://amiunique.org/fp
- alquemist 6y agoIronically, amiunique.org is broken with JS disabled.
- throwaway189262 6y agoThere's Firefox plugins like Chameleon that corrupt fingerprints. Besides that, Tor browser is really your only option. We're in so deep it will take years to reverse fingerprinting vectors. If it's even possible
- deadwing0 6y agoAre there any catalysts to reverse our course?
- bigiain 6y agoWe just need to make sure the browser suppliers are in total opposition to the surveillance capitalism and personalised advertising industry. So while Chrome is such a dominant browser? No. It’s not gonna happen. Google will keep writing “inadvertent errors” that exempt their own tracking cookies from user instructions to delete them. https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/chrome-google.html https://lapcatsoftware.com/articles/chrome-google.html
- throwaway189262 6y agoGoogle owning the dominant browser and mobile OS is a travesty for privacy. What we really need is a consortium of companies to rally behind FireFox for mutual benefit, like how Linux is done
- ColinHayhurst 6y agoMost of Firefox funding comes from Google
- genewitch 6y agoYes, but having companies/entities other than google funding them would reduce the "say" google has in the browser design and implementation.
- 6y ago
- sillysaurusx 6y agoUse whonix. https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Documentation https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Documentation It's basically a virtualbox VM that you run a browser inside of. No, it's not really practical. But yes, it works. If you're doing nefarious things, that's probably the #1 thing you should use.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gruez 6y agoThat doesn't really solve the fingerprinting issue. Hardly anyone uses whonix for everyday browsing, so you'll be that guy[1] with the obfuscated fingerprint [1] https://xkcd.com/1105/ https://xkcd.com/1105/
- fastball 6y agoI use Brave, and this website says I have a randomized fingerprint which protect from tracking.
- ffpip 6y agoYes. They randomize your fingerprint output, every session, and for every website. https://brave.com/brave-fingerprinting-and-privacy-budgets/ https://brave.com/brave-fingerprinting-and-privacy-budgets/
- bigiain 6y agoIt says my iPad running iOS14.2 with no particular attempt to increase or decrease its privacy level is unique. Most of that seems to be the small sample size they have so far couples with the fact Safari is telling them my screen size, en-au language setting, and my Sydney/Australia Timezone. I suppose it’s entirely plausible I’m the only iPad Air 2 user on 14.2 in Sydney to have checked using their site so far...
- dehrmann 6y agoOne of the easier ways to not look unique is use a popular iOS device because Apple pushes updates hard, so OS and browser versions tend to move in sync, they don't maintain that many SKUs (4 right now, and I'm not even sure if the 12 and 12 Pro are different enough for fingerprinting to detect), and their devices are pretty popular. Various privacy trackers also block fingerprinting code. If you need a new hobby, uBlock Matrix is the hard way to block most fingerprinting.
- messe 6y agouMatrix is no longer maintained, sadly.
- bigiain 6y agoSo like a lot of rabbithole hobbies. "All you need to do is pick up this abandoned github project, fork it, fix all the outstanding show stopper issues, bring it up to date with advances in browsers since it was last regularly maintained, and add in my own personal must face feature! Bob's your uncle! The you just need to avoid whatever inevitability it was that caused the previous maintainer to abandon it, deal with the usual crowd of self entitled and demanding-to-the-point-of-abuse users who refuse to contribute pull requests or money, and worry about tremendously overreaching to the point of fraudulent DMCA or patent lawsuits and having GitHub roll over to the RIAA or whoever doesn't like what other people use the code to do." :sigh:
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoHere is another way to look at it. Not expecting anyone to agree; it's just a thought experiment. Instead of asking "How do we become "non-unique""? We could ask "How do we send less data to the parties who want to do tracking?" For example, User A sends 2-3 HTTP headers, the bare minimum, e.g., Host, Connection, maybe User-Agent or Cookie in some instances if required. User A has disabled Javascript unless she needs it. User B sends a potentially unlimited number of HTTP headers (User B does not care to control the headers she sends, she just leaves that to the applications). User B leaves Javascript enabled regardless of whether it is needed. Each user may be "unique", with sufficient effort from the party doing tracking, but there's an argument that User A is less interesting to the tracking parties than User B. Both users have footprints, both can be tracked, but one is sending much more data to the trackers than the other. She's leaving more detailed tracks, so to speak. User A is leaving a more generic footprint. There is also an argument that finding "uniqueness" among a large group of "User B's" would be easier than amongst a large group of "User A's". If we were trying to achieve the impossible goal of "non-uniqueness" it would arguably be easier to try to have all users appear to be identical to User A than trying to get all users to match User B what with all the additional potential variables User B presents thanks to uncontrolled HTTP headers and Javascript's access to her computer's resources (and all the potential issues and "options" that raises).
- atoav 6y agoIf non-uniqueness means "there are others that look like you", it is clear that giving them less identifying clues makes things harder. The question is how to do it tho, because some things might actually be useful: if your browser tells the site you prefer dark themes the site can react and display your prefered color scheme. If the browser tells the site how big your viewport is it can give you a site that fills that viewport neatly — and if the site can do these useful things it can also track you using that info.
- antepodius 6y agoThe viewport can be filled neatly by html/css. No javascript required.
- mswann 6y agoUsing the Tor Browser from torproject.org with the so called "safest" security settings (that I usually use) I am not unique (currently 1 in 15k browsers have the same fingerprint as mine - which is not exactly great but still better than unique). With "standard" security settings (I switch to those mainly for watching videos) I am unique among the tested 288,728 others (screen qualities and not using the recommended default language en stick out).
- craftinator 6y ago> How does one actually become not unique? Actually, let's look at a different solution up the same vein, how does someone become NOT themselves? I think that right now it's less about how to blend in, and more about how to swap identifying features. What about a pool of users, like a vpn, except the pool exercises identifiable information swapping!
- throwaway_pdp09 6y ago> How does one actually make themselves non-unique? Though this is highly desirable, for a guy like me who is rather paranoid I'm not going to worry too much. I disable js and block lots of sites (based on MVPS but also my own personal list - anything that gets through gets put into my personal list). After that, I don't care too much if they track me cos they aren't getting bugger all useful - if everyone did that, what market would be left for advertisers? I'll still read more of the article and try to close more holes, but perhaps a 95% solution is sufficient? What do you think?
- l33tman 6y agoIn my test (umatrix, but no other preventions), the main sources of uniqueness were the fonts installed, the HTTP-ACCEPT header, and WebGL fingerprinting. Especially the fonts installed was very interesting and I hadn't thought of that before. The JS just iterates over thousands of known fonts in a div/span and sees if the browser can render it to build a list. It's enough that you've installed a single uncommon font and together with everything else you suddenly became unique just by that. You're not going to block all of these "dynamic" prints just by changing browser or installing a single plugin. Even if you run in a VM, unless you actually flush and reinstall that VM every session, you're eventually going to amass customizations inside the VM that can be fingerprinted.. :/
- genewitch 6y agowindows 10 pro has "Windows Sandbox" which is a VM that runs windows 10 that is only ephemeral storage. Closing the VM and restarting it is 100% fresh again. There's ways to do it with virtualbox and qemu as well by setting the disks to the same ephemeral style.
- EastSmith 6y agoLooks like fonts are basically cookies with side effects (rendering characters).
- ignoramous 6y agoForget webgl and fonts, content blockers also fail at blocking third-party analytics masquerading as first-party analytics. Exhibit A: https://gist.github.com/sperand-io/fc211731e31c628232abb998febb077b https://gist.github.com/sperand-io/fc211731e31c628232abb998f...
- nitrogen 6y agoGitHub requires logging in to view gists??
- viseztrance 6y agoThe problem is that the same font is rendered differently by different video cards, hence why your hardware can get fingerprinted.
- d_theorist 6y agoSetting DNT probably makes you more unique. You’re putting yourself in the vanishingly small set of people who have that bit set.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoslightly dated but still relevant for maintaining privacy, especially the later parts that talk more about tradecraft then obsessing over DNT etc: https://web.archive.org/web/20180714043311/https://iotdarwinaward.com/post/improve-your-privacy-in-age-of-mass-surveillance/ https://web.archive.org/web/20180714043311/https://iotdarwin... crucial bit is to blend into the crowd instead of standing out (the paradox is the harder we try to mitigate on a technical level the more we'll stick out). instead use hardware compartmentalization, pseudonymous identities (not anonymous ones) and focus on operational techniques (modify your behavior). technology can be a means but often it is just part of a strategy. (e.g. instead of "let's encrypt all the comms" why not eliminating some comms altogether - no need to worry about data that doesn't get stored in the first place etc)
- AreYouElite 6y agostylometry can identify you, or even just the times you are online, what content you visit. We need a browser plugin for this. Some button in the corner of your browser that you click to sanitize your post of any identifying features.
- ta3614305836241 6y agoWe could successfully become non-unique (~10 bits) with 2 approaches: 1. TOR browser on Safest setting 2. Firefox using the strictest privacy settings except allowing 1st party cookies, and using Private Browsing; toggling privacy.resistFingeprinting to True in about:config; and using the uBlock and NoScript add-ons These were successful on both desktop and mobile (except iOS)
- dkdk8283 6y agoDefaults in a VM. No plugins
- dkdk8283 6y agoHaving software that helps mitigate timing attacks and pre-fetches uninteresting content is a start. Disabling JS will be painful but helpful tool. Although disabling JS makes you a uniquely identifiable user. Not sure, but I think this should spark disfission.
- stelfer 6y agoProbably never. Unique in the Crowd: The privacy bounds of human mobility[1]. [1]https://www.nature.com/articles/srep01376 https://www.nature.com/articles/srep01376
- jcynix 6y agoYou might want to try https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privoxy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Privoxy, a "privacy enhancing proxy" which works by reducing the stuff a browser sends before passing it on. Edit: removed typo.