3 ms·
The author seems to believe that the RISC/CISC distinction is still important while presenting evidence that demonstrates the opposite. The author presents a r
by aidenn0 6y ago
The author seems to believe that the RISC/CISC distinction is still important while presenting evidence that demonstrates the opposite.
The author presents a reasonably non-controversial RISC list
1. Fixed size
2. Instructions designed to use specific parts of CPU in a predictable manner for facilitate pipelining.
3. Load/Store architecture. Most instructions operate on registers. Loading and storing to memory is generally done with specific instructions only for that purpose.
4. Lots of registers to avoid frequent memory access.
Very few chips since the late 90s have fulfilled all of these. 32-bit ARM never had 4, modern ARM doesn't have #2. An ARM Thumb2 chip that supports division only has #3.
When RISC came out, it really meant fewer, simpler instructions (CPUs had been adding instructions almost as fast as transistors got cheaper). This implies #1 and #3, and #3 requires #4 for performance. #2 got included primarily because CPU speeds had hit the point where pipelining yielded big performance gains, and #1 and #3 meant it was easier to implement in RISC first.