6 ms·
Google is dysfunctional. Their promo incentives favor short-term thinking. The original founders are gone. The only reason they're alive is their ad/search mo
by echelon 6y ago
Google is dysfunctional. Their promo incentives favor short-term thinking.
The original founders are gone.
The only reason they're alive is their ad/search moat. It's a walking IBM/Oracle, otherwise.
Don't forget when it leaked a year or so ago that even Google Cloud Platform is on their chopping block if they don't meet targets.
I wouldn't trust this company with anything. Photos, music, youtube videos, mail. They do not care.
- 1-6 6y agoIt's fun to ride on tidal waves like reorgs though!
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoUnless you depend on Google's services, yes.
- josephg 6y agoOr simply want to chat with your friends on their platform without nervously keeping a finger on the pulse. Chat in gmail, or hangouts? Oh that’s google plus now, wait it isn’t plus. Google voice? Google duo? Is that still a thing? Is Google meet the same as hangouts? All my friends churned away from google’s IM solutions and I doubt we’re ever coming back. Who’s got time for all that?
- cma 6y agoThey moved chat from gmail for a while exclusively to Google+ to promote it, killing off their chat advantage and end the end they also failed to make Google+ take off.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sova 6y agoDid somebody say Google Wave?
- MattGaiser 6y ago> Their promo incentives favor short-term thinking. Can you please explain more?
- karatinversion 6y agoI have never worked for Google, but the story in previous similar discussions had been that Google’s performance reviews largely weigh launching new products to the exclusion of everything, so anyone who wants to get promoted can’t afford to “get stuck” maintaining an existing product without at least a significant rewrite.
- MattGaiser 6y agoAh ok. I have heard that story as well.
- jakevoytko 6y agoThis is basically true, although "to the exclusion of everything else" is more extreme than my experience. At the time I left ~5 years ago, it was common for promotion rejections to be given the explanation "the current thing that you're working on hasn't launched yet, so the promotion committee couldn't properly assess your impact. If you successfully launch it, that would clearly demonstrate impact." If you were a shoo-in via your existing work (i.e. you were obviously underpromoted), then it wouldn't matter as much. But since most people were trying to get promoted the instant they had a plausible case, it meant that a lot of people were focused on launching One Last Thing. Since I left, I understand that they've revamped the promotions up to Senior such that managers that are familiar with your work consider your promotion instead of a random committee. I'm curious to hear whether that has affected the "launch launch launch" push for promotions under staff engineer. I know through my network that staff+ promotions can still be held up for this reason.
- dvtrn 6y agoPromotion "committee" ??
- stingraycharles 6y agoFor those who care, this is the article & HN discussion about the leaked memo that GCP may be axed if they don’t reach certain targets by 2023: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/google-brass-set-2023-as-deadline-to-beat-amazon-microsoft-in-cloud https://www.theinformation.com/articles/google-brass-set-202... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21815260 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21815260
- neolog 6y agoI can't read the story, just the first bit, but it says "risk losing funding" not "axe".
- swiley 6y agoProprietary software without funding is software without maintainers, another way of saying dead by most people's definition.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- echelon 6y agoWould you stake your company or project on GCP if Google decided it was going to reduce funding of the platform? They show time and time again that they're willing to pull the rug out from under people that depend on their platforms.
- teawrecks 6y agoSame thing.
- ProAm 6y agoIt's the first death pang to not be funded in a company the lives on getting promoted by 'new features or products'
- notyourwork 6y agoThe longer this goes on the more I try to iteratively decouple myself from google. For those with a google voice number, any suggestions on best choice for porting your number elsewher?
- colechristensen 6y agoTwilio, possibly.
- mmastrac 6y agoAs someone who tried this, it's problematic - no support for group texts and iffy support for MMS attachments. I really wanted it to work, but occasionally even my 2FA codes would just not arrive.
- colechristensen 6y agoWhen did you try it and what did you try?
- mmastrac 6y agoApprox a year ago, ending maybe six months ago.
- CtrlAltT5wpm 6y agoOne of the only reasons I'm still with Google Voice is because having your number with them mitigates (far as I can tell) SIM swap attacks. Yeah, someone can swap my SIM, but effectively nothing goes to the carrier number, just the GV number, which is much harder to socially engineer (even if some of that is because it's impossible to get someone on the phone). If you tightly lock down your GV account, it should be much more difficult to compromise than a random cell carrier. I don't know if there's a comparable service, but I'm dying to pay for one, if only to not have a single point of failure.
- 6y ago
- ashtonkem 6y agoIt becomes a self fulfilling prophecy eventually. As Google shuts down random services during fits of pique, they build a reputation for being mercurial and unreliable. And then when they actually need to see significant numbers to justify large projects (Stadia, GCP), they struggle to pull in users because nobody trusts them. Google eventually pulls the plug due to low adoption, and all consumers biases against relying on Google are validated.
- steelframe 6y agoI know someone who left Google about 6 months ago after having worked there for 12 years, and I had a lot of interesting conversations with them recently. I left Google many years ago. Google is in the midst of an epic struggle to transform itself. I think it's succeeding in turning into a sustainable post-ads company, and I think Google will be around for many years to come. However the transformation is not pleasant for many of the SWEs, particularly those in GCP. I can say with some confidence that GCP is not in peril. TK is turning the ship around, and a fresh infusion of "conventional company" executives are doing what it takes to make the changes happen. A lot of Google SWEs are suddenly being directly exposed to revenue targets that they have to meet by clawing enterprise sales from Amazon and Microsoft. Not all of them are up to the task, and many are fleeing to... well, I bet many of them are getting a "rude awakening" about how the tech industry outside of their popping Google bubble has to operate. All of the sudden they can't sit back in their castle and wave their "A/B test" wands to figure out which experiments draw in 20,000 daily users vs. 17,000 daily users. Instead they have to take orders from sales and PM as they scream at them to hurry up and build features to get 5 or 6 more enterprise contracts signed by such-and-such a date. Google SWEs have never needed to pay any heed to sales or PM; they just used to do whatever they felt like doing, launching it, creatively selecting metrics that demonstrate "success," collecting their promos, and dancing along to the next shiny thing. That fantasy world is gone. As ads revenue falters, the real world is slamming into Google full-force. I actually expect the opposite of "not caring" about photos, music, etc. to happen. Google is quickly moving into a phase where a reputation for shipping and supporting stable, durable, and compatible solutions is what it desperately needs in order to win and keep enterprise customers. We're going to see it happen, and the Google SWEs who survive are the ones who are willing to humble themselves, roll up their sleeves, and compete head-to-head with AWS and Azure SWEs on a level playing field. It will mean harder work for less pay, fewer promos, and less autonomy. I have a hard time feeling sorry for anyone working at Google today. It's still a very privileged place to work, especially in the midst of the global turmoil going on around us right now. I do, however, have little patience for any Google SWEs who still expect the "ship shiny, collect promo" career path to work out for them there.
- gogopuppygogo 6y agoIf that shift you described is indeed under way then public relations should all be fired. Google has a well deserved horrible track record and no serious enterprises should consider it.
- Florin_Andrei 6y ago> Their promo incentives favor short-term thinking. I'm seriously asking myself these days if this is how Google dies, and we're just seeing the early signs of it.
- lwhi 6y agoIf anything, I think this is a great reason why Apple, Google, Amazon and Facebook should be broken up. There's an argument from an anti-monopoly / competition point of view. But perhaps organisational as well? Perhaps smaller companies which favour local (product focused) concerns would actually benefit all of us?
- dang 6y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25164921 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25164921.
- heavyset_go 6y agoI trusted them with my music collection and they shut the service down in favor of the vastly inferior YouTube Music.
- gbh444g 6y agoDoes Google have a choice, though? The crux of the problem is who gets to capture the value. Conventional companies don't let employees capture value, so employees rationally act like employees and not like business owners. This is why Zoom's founder left Cisco. This is why the GCP's "most important person" will rationally jump ship shortly before the tough conversation about revenue targets.